A Simplified Path Searching and Correcting Method for the Calculation of Initial Value of Libration Periodic Orbit

Yao Xiong, Yuan Hong, Xin Yang, Yang Zhang, Qingbo GanChinese 2020 · DOI

This paper, published in the Chinese Journal of Space Science, tackles one of the most persistent headaches in astrodynamics: finding the "perfect start" for complex orbits in a three-body system. By simplifying the search for initial values, the authors provide a more intuitive path for mission designers to navigate the chaotic gravitational dance between the Earth and the Moon.

TL;DR

The researchers developed a simplified geometric method to calculate the initial values required to "seed" periodic orbits (like Halo and Distant Retrograde Orbits) in the Earth-Moon system. Their approach demonstrates that a single search space can yield multiple distinct types of orbits, and they provide handy polynomial equations to help engineers skip the tedious trial-and-error phase of mission design.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In the Circular Restricted Three-Body Problem (CRTBP)—think of a satellite moving under the influence of both the Earth and the Moon—finding a periodic orbit is not as simple as drawing a circle. Because the gravitational environment is non-linear and highly sensitive, you need an extremely precise "initial guess" (position and velocity) to find an orbit that repeats itself.

Traditionally, finding these guesses involves complex searches or heavy reliance on existing databases. The challenge is that different types of orbits (like the famous "Halo" orbits used for lunar communications) exist in the same regions of space. Distinguishing between them and finding the exact starting conditions for a specific mission requirement remains a computational bottleneck.

Methods

The authors utilize a Simplified Path Searching and Correcting Method. The core logic relies on two pillars:

  1. Poincaré Sections and Symmetry: Instead of looking at the whole orbit, they look at where the orbit crosses a specific plane (like the $xz$-plane). Because many periodic orbits are symmetric, they only need to find the conditions where the satellite crosses this plane perpendicularly.
  2. Jacobi Constant Variation: The Jacobi constant ($J$) is a measure of the energy in the system. By holding the starting position ($x_0$) constant and varying $J$, the authors look for "zero-crossings" in velocity components.
  3. Differential Correction: Once the simplified search provides a "rough" initial value, they apply a standard differential correction algorithm to "polish" that guess into a mathematically precise, repeating periodic orbit.
  4. Polynomial Fitting: After generating several successful orbits, they used 4th-order polynomial fitting to create equations that can predict the necessary initial velocity and position for a range of starting points.

Datasets

The study doesn't use an external dataset but rather generates its own data through numerical simulations based on the physical constants of the Earth-Moon system (specifically using the mass ratio $\mu = 0.0122$). They validated their method by recreating known orbit families, such as Halo orbits near the $L_1$ Lagrange point and Distant Retrograde Orbits (DROs).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "One-to-Many" Mapping: One of the most interesting findings is that a single starting position on the $x$-axis can lead to entirely different types of orbits (e.g., a DRO vs. a Halo orbit) simply by changing the energy (Jacobi constant).
  • Orbit Co-existence: The paper highlights that Halo orbits and DROs often "live" in the same search parameters. This means a search intended for one might accidentally find the other, which is a crucial consideration for automated mission planning.
  • Bifurcation Points: The authors observed that as the starting position moves, certain orbit families disappear or transform. For instance, at specific boundaries, Halo orbits might vanish, giving way to planar Lyapunov orbits or Vertical orbits.
  • Practical Shortcuts: By providing Equations (6) and (7), the authors offer a "cheat sheet" for calculating initial $z$-axis positions and $y$-axis velocities for Halo orbits, significantly reducing the need for exhaustive searching.

Key Results

  • Successful Classification: The method successfully identified and categorized DRO, Halo, Lyapunov, and Vertical orbits.
  • Precision: The "rough" guesses from the simplified search were close enough that the differential correction converged quickly to precise values (detailed in Table 2).
  • Predictive Power: The polynomial fitting for Halo orbits near $L_1$ showed high accuracy, allowing for the rapid generation of orbit families without re-running the full search algorithm.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Mapping the Relationship: While the paper shows that different orbits emerge from the search, the authors admit that the exact relationship between the initial search parameters and the resulting orbit type "needs further study." It is currently difficult to predict exactly which orbit type will appear without running the correction.
  • Singularity Issues: In some cases (marked with "—" in Table 1), the differential correction failed due to matrix singularities, suggesting the method has "blind spots" where the geometry becomes too complex for the simplified approach.
  • Model Complexity: The study is limited to the Circular Restricted Three-Body Problem. Real-world applications would eventually need to account for the eccentricity of the Moon's orbit and solar radiation pressure.

Summary updated

Abstract

In the restricted three-body problem, the path searching and correcting method is often used to calculate the approximate initial value of planar and three-dimensional periodic orbit. In this paper, in view of the Circular Restricted Three-Body Problem (CRTBP), a simplified mode of this method is applied to calculate the approximate initial value of several ordinary kinds of periodic orbit. The results show that the approximate initial value obtained by the simplified method is not unique, and the precise initial values derived from the unique values above using differential correction method often include both Halo and DRO (Distant Retrograde Orbit) orbits. Moreover, under certain boundary initial values, Halo orbit will disappear from the results and the planar Lyapunov orbit or Vertical orbit will appears. The relationship between these initial values using in this method and the certain kinds of orbit needs further study.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{xiong2020simplified,
  author = {Yao XIONG and Yuan Hong and Xin Yang and Yang Zhang and Qingbo Gan},
  title = {{A Simplified Path Searching and Correcting Method for the Calculation of Initial Value of Libration Periodic Orbit}},
  booktitle = {Chinese},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.11728/cjss2020.01.102},
}

Loading related content...

Figure