A Simple Method for the Control Time of a Pumping Station to Ensure a Stable Water Level Immediately Upstream of the Pumping Station under a Change of the Discharge in an Open Channel

Peiru Yan, Zhao Zhang, Xiaohui Lei, Ying Zheng, Jie Zhu, Hao Wang, Qiaofeng TanWater 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a straightforward method to calculate the optimal "control time" for pumping stations in open channel systems. This is crucial for maintaining a stable water level upstream, preventing operational issues and ensuring safety, especially during changes in water flow. The method uses reverse analysis and considers factors like initial discharge, variable discharge, and water depth to determine this critical timing.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In open channel systems with multiple pumping stations, maintaining a consistent water level immediately upstream of each station is vital. This stability ensures efficient pumping operations, prevents damage to channel linings, and avoids potential catastrophic events like drying up the forebay or causing unit vibrations. Current automatic control methods often struggle with the dynamic nature of switching working conditions (e.g., changes in upstream discharge). While existing research focuses on economic operations and energy savings, there's a need for a practical, simple method to determine the precise timing for pumping station adjustments to guarantee upstream water level stability during discharge variations.

Methods

The core of this paper is a novel, simple method for determining the "control time" of a pumping station. This method employs reverse analysis. The authors first establish a one-dimensional hydrodynamic model of the open channel, using the variable upstream discharge and a fixed downstream water level as boundary conditions. They then simulate the pumping station's discharge process under ideal conditions. The control time is calculated by equating the "ideal pumping volume" (what would be needed to maintain a constant water level) with the "actual pumping volume" over a specific time interval, considering a step change in discharge. This interval is defined by the initial arrival time of the flow change (1% increase) and the complete arrival time (99% increase). The Saint Venant equations are used for the open channel, with modifications for inverted siphons treated as head loss. The Preissmann four-point implicit difference method and the chasing method are used for numerical solutions.

Datasets

The study utilizes data from the Jiaodong Water Diversion Project, specifically the section from Songzhuang sluice to Huibu pumping station (G1–P1). The hydrodynamic model was verified using measured water level data from May 16-21, 2018. The case study for control time analysis used simulated data based on the project's design parameters and operational conditions. No new benchmark datasets were introduced.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Simplicity is Key: The paper champions a "simple and rapid method" for a complex engineering problem, making it more accessible for practical application compared to highly complex algorithms.
  • Reverse Analysis for Control Timing: Using reverse analysis to determine control time is a novel approach that directly addresses the need for stable upstream water levels.
  • Discharge Change Propagation: The study highlights that the control time is intrinsically linked to how quickly changes in upstream discharge propagate through the channel.
  • Interplay of Factors: The research clearly demonstrates that initial discharge, the magnitude of discharge change, and upstream water depth are not independent variables but collectively influence the optimal control time.

Key Results

The study's findings, based on the Jiaodong Water Diversion Project case study, reveal several key relationships:

  • Initial Discharge: A larger initial discharge leads to a shorter control time. This is attributed to increased flow and wave velocities, which allow changes to propagate faster. The relationship is described as a power function.
  • Upstream Discharge Change: Increasing the upstream discharge reduces the control time, while decreasing it increases the control time. This is linked to the propagation velocity of the flow.
  • Water Depth: The control time decreases as the water depth immediately upstream of the pumping station increases. This is explained by the increased wave velocity and its greater influence on propagation velocity compared to the flow velocity decrease. An exponential relationship is observed.
  • Experimental Verification: The hydrodynamic model was validated against real-world data with minimal errors, confirming its reliability. The control time method was also shown to effectively return the upstream water level to its target after a discharge fluctuation.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Pumping Unit Discharge Consistency: The upstream variable discharge should ideally match the pumping units' discharge capabilities.
  • Applicability: The method is best suited for wide channels with significant storage capacity. Narrow channels or those with dramatic discharge changes might experience critical water level exceedances.
  • Characteristic Curve Ignored: The study did not explicitly consider the pumping station's characteristic curve, which could be important for more precise control.

Future research directions suggested include:

  • Developing multi-step control methods for narrow channels or situations with dramatic discharge changes.
  • Incorporating the pumping station's characteristic curve into the control time determination.
  • Further investigation into the influence of discharge changing time (i.e., how quickly the discharge actually changes, not instantaneously).

Summary updated

Abstract

For an open channel with cascade pumping stations, the water level immediately upstream of the pumping station should be kept constant to ensure pumping stability and lining safety. In this study, a simple method was proposed to determine the control time of the pumping station to ensure a stable water level immediately upstream of the pumping station using reverse analysis. The variable discharge process and fixed water level were taken as the upstream and downstream boundaries of the one-dimensional open channel hydrodynamic model, and the discharge process of the pumping station was obtained under ideal conditions. The control time was determined by the equivalent water volume change considering the step change of the discharge of the pumping station. A case study was performed using the Jiaodong water diversion project from Songzhuang sluice to Huibu pumping station (G1–P1), and the effects of the initial discharge, variable discharge, and downstream water level on the control time were investigated. The results show that (1) the larger the initial discharge, the shorter the control time; (2) increasing the upstream discharge reduced the control time, while decreasing the upstream discharge increased the control time; (3) the control time decreased with the increase of the water depth immediately upstream of the pumping station.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{yan2021simple,
  author = {Peiru Yan and Zhao Zhang and Xiaohui Lei and Ying Zheng and Jie Zhu and Hao Wang and Qiaofeng Tan},
  title = {{A Simple Method for the Control Time of a Pumping Station to Ensure a Stable Water Level Immediately Upstream of the Pumping Station under a Change of the Discharge in an Open Channel}},
  booktitle = {Water},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.3390/w13030355},
}
Figure