A Simple and Efficient Estimation of the Average Treatment Effect in the\n Presence of Unmeasured Confounders

Chunrong Ai, Lukang Huang, Zheng ZhangarXiv 2018 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

Wang and Tchetgen Tchetgen (2017) studied identification and estimation of the average treatment effect (ATE) when some confounders are unmeasured. Under their identification condition, they showed that the semiparametric efficient influence function depends on five unknown functionals. They proposed to parameterize all functionals and estimate the average treatment effect from the efficient influence function by replacing the unknown functionals with estimated functionals. They established that their estimator is consistent when certain functionals are correctly specified and attains the semiparametric efficiency bound when all functionals are correctly specified. In applications, it is likely that those functionals could all be misspecified. Consequently, their estimator could be inconsistent or consistent but not efficient. This paper presents an alternative estimator that does not require parameterization of any of the functionals. We establish that the proposed estimator is always consistent and always attains the semiparametric efficiency bound. A simple and intuitive estimator of the asymptotic variance is presented, and a small scale simulation study reveals that the proposed estimation outperforms the existing alternatives in finite samples.

Introduction

In causal inference, the primary objective is often to determine the Average Treatment Effect (ATE)—the difference in outcomes attributable to a specific intervention. While randomized controlled trials are the gold standard for such estimation, researchers often rely on observational data where individuals select into treatment based on various factors, known as confounders. If all confounders are observed (e.g., age, socioeconomic status), adjustment is straightforward. However, the presence of unmeasured confounders—hidden variables affecting both treatment and outcome—presents a significant challenge to identification.

A common strategy to address unmeasured confounding is the use of an Instrumental Variable (IV). An IV is a variable that influences the treatment but has no direct effect on the outcome except through the treatment. Recent work by Wang and Tchetgen Tchetgen (2017) provided a framework to identify the ATE in these scenarios, but their estimation method relied on the correct specification of five complex mathematical functionals. This paper introduces a more robust, semiparametric approach that eliminates the need for researchers to guess these functional forms.

The Challenge of Misspecification

The "multiply robust" (mr) estimator proposed by Wang and Tchetgen Tchetgen (2017) is theoretically powerful but practically fragile. It requires the researcher to define parametric models for five different components of the data distribution. If any of these models are misspecified—a common occurrence in complex real-world datasets—the estimator can become biased or lose its efficiency. This "guessing game" creates a barrier to reliable causal inference in the presence of hidden factors.

Methodology: Sieve Estimation and Empirical Likelihood

To overcome the limitations of parametric modeling, this paper proposes a semiparametric plug-in estimator. The core innovation lies in moving away from rigid functional forms in favor of a flexible "sieve" estimation approach.

1. Flexible Approximation

Instead of forcing data into pre-defined models, the authors utilize basis functions (such as power series or splines). These "sieves" can approximate any smooth function with increasing accuracy as the sample size grows, allowing the data to dictate the shape of the underlying relationships.

2. Calibration via Empirical Likelihood

The method derives data-driven weights by solving a constrained optimization problem. Using a technique similar to generalized empirical likelihood, the weights are chosen to satisfy specific "moment conditions" derived from the IV assumptions. This calibration ensures that the estimator respects the fundamental physics of the causal model without requiring explicit parameterization of the five functionals.

3. The Plug-in Formula

Once the weights and the treatment’s relationship to the IV are estimated via the sieve approach, they are "plugged" into a simplified formula for the ATE. The authors also provide a "sandwich estimator" for variance, which simplifies the calculation of confidence intervals for practitioners.

Key Insights

  • Efficiency without Parameterization: The paper proves that it is possible to reach the semiparametric efficiency bound—the theoretical limit of how precise an estimator can be—without knowing the exact shape of the five functionals.
  • Universal Consistency: Unlike previous models that are only consistent if certain parts of the model are correct, this proposed estimator is always consistent, provided the basic IV identification assumptions are met.
  • Practical Tuning: The authors offer a data-driven method for selecting tuning parameters ($K_1, K_2$), which determine the complexity of the sieve approximation based on the available sample size.

Empirical Validation

The authors conducted a Monte Carlo simulation study to compare the proposed estimator (cbe) against the existing multiply robust (mr) alternatives. The study used a binary treatment, binary outcome, and a hidden Bernoulli confounder.

Robustness to Misspecification

The simulation results highlighted a stark contrast in performance when functional forms were misspecified. Under misspecification, the previous "mr" estimators produced extreme errors, with a Root Mean Square Error (RMSE) reaching as high as 884.5 for a true effect of 0.087. In the same scenario, the proposed cbe estimator remained stable, maintaining a very low bias (0.003) and a manageable RMSE (0.152).

Efficiency and Scaling

Even when the previous methods were given the advantage of perfectly specified models, the proposed estimator's standard deviation remained comparable. Furthermore, as the sample size increased from $N=500$ to $N=1000$, the bias and variance of the proposed estimator decreased consistently, confirming its theoretical properties in finite samples.

Conclusion

This paper provides a significant advancement in causal inference by making IV-based ATE estimation both simpler and more robust. By replacing rigid parametric assumptions with flexible sieve estimation and empirical likelihood calibration, the authors provide a tool that is less prone to researcher error and more adaptable to complex data. Future work may extend this framework to continuous treatments and address the challenges posed by high-dimensional covariates or weak instruments.

Summary updated

Abstract

Wang and Tchetgen Tchetgen (2017) studied identification and estimation of\nthe average treatment effect when some confounders are unmeasured. Under their\nidentification condition, they showed that the semiparametric efficient\ninfluence function depends on five unknown functionals. They proposed to\nparameterize all functionals and estimate the average treatment effect from the\nefficient influence function by replacing the unknown functionals with\nestimated functionals. They established that their estimator is consistent when\ncertain functionals are correctly specified and attains the semiparametric\nefficiency bound when all functionals are correctly specified. In applications,\nit is likely that those functionals could all be misspecified. Consequently\ntheir estimator could be inconsistent or consistent but not efficient. This\npaper presents an alternative estimator that does not require parameterization\nof any of the functionals. We establish that the proposed estimator is always\nconsistent and always attains the semiparametric efficiency bound. A simple and\nintuitive estimator of the asymptotic variance is presented, and a small scale\nsimulation study reveals that the proposed estimation outperforms the existing\nalternatives in finite samples.\n
BibTeX
@misc{ai2018simple,
  author = {Chunrong Ai and Lukang Huang and Zheng Zhang},
  title = {{A Simple and Efficient Estimation of the Average Treatment Effect in the\textbackslash\{\}n Presence of Unmeasured Confounders}},
  year = {2018},
  eprint = {1807.05678},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1807.05678},
}
Figure