A silkworm infection model to investigate Vibrio vulnificus virulence genes

Mai Yamamoto, Takashige Kashimoto, Yukihiro Yoshimura, Nao Tachibana, Shiho Kuroda, Yoshiko Miki, Sou Kitabayashi, Ping Tong, Jianbo Xiao, Kōichi Tanaka, Hiroshi Hamamoto, Kazuhisa Sekimizu, Koichiro YamamotoMolecular 2016 · DOI

Abstract

The halophilic marine bacterium, Vibrio vulnificus, occasionally causes fatal septicemia in immunocompromised patients. Mice are commonly used as experimental animals to investigate the virulence of V. vulnificus, however, a large number of mice are generally required for bioassays. The present study examined whether the invertebrate species, silkworms, can be used instead of mice to investigate V. vulnificus virulence. When the silkworms were inoculated with $1.2 \times 10^7$ colony forming units of V. vulnificus OPU1-Rf, a virulent strain of V. vulnificus, all injected silkworms died within 48 h, however, those injected with culture filtrate or diluent did not. This silkworm infection model was then used to isolate attenuated V. vulnificus mutants from 1,016 transposon-inserted mutants. Consequently, a harmless mutant, SW998, was isolated. In this strain, the transposon was inserted into the rtxA gene, which is a known V. vulnificus virulence gene. In conclusion, the present study demonstrated that silkworms are useful animals for investigating the virulence of V. vulnificus.

Introduction

Vibrio vulnificus is a "flesh-eating" halophilic bacterium found in warm seawater. In immunocompromised individuals, it can cause primary septicemia with a staggering mortality rate of over 50%. To understand its pathogenesis and develop therapies, researchers typically rely on mouse models. However, mice are expensive, require significant laboratory space, and involve complex ethical considerations—especially when screening thousands of bacterial mutants to identify virulence factors.

This study, published in Molecular Medicine Reports, explores the silkworm (Bombyx mori) as a reliable proxy for mammalian infection. Silkworms possess sophisticated innate immune systems with Toll and immune deficiency (IMD) pathways homologous to human TLR and TNF signaling, making them promising candidates for high-throughput genetic screening.

Establishing the Silkworm Infection Model

To determine if silkworms could serve as a viable model, researchers first established a lethal dose by injecting the virulent V. vulnificus strain OPU1-Rf directly into the silkworm's hemolymph. The results showed a clear dose-dependent lethality. While high doses led to total mortality within two days, culture filtrates (the liquid growth medium without the bacteria) did not kill the silkworms, suggesting that direct interaction between the bacteria and host cells is necessary for toxicity.

Figure 2: Survival curves of silkworms after injection with different doses of V. vulnificus OPU1-Rf, PBSG (diluent), and culture filtrate.

Screening for Attenuated Mutants

Using the established model, the researchers conducted a large-scale screen of 1,016 transposon-inserted mutants. A rigorous three-stage screening process was employed:

  1. Primary Screen: All 1,016 mutants were tested; 78 candidates showed reduced lethality.
  2. Secondary Screen: Re-testing narrowed the field to 16 attenuated candidates.
  3. Tertiary Screen: Final testing identified a single mutant, SW998, which was consistently harmless to the silkworms.
Figure 3: Survival curves comparing the virulent OPU1-Rf strain and the isolated attenuated mutant SW998.

Genetic Validation and Key Insights

Genetic mapping of the SW998 mutant revealed that the transposon had disrupted the rtxA gene. This gene encodes a repeats-in-toxin (RTX) cytotoxic factor, a well-documented major virulence factor in human and mouse infections. The discovery of rtxA through an unbiased screen in silkworms validates that the insect model responds to the same critical bacterial toxins as mammalian hosts.

Conclusion

The study successfully demonstrates that silkworms are an effective, ethical, and cost-effective alternative to mice for investigating V. vulnificus virulence. While differences in body temperature (silkworms are ectotherms) and exact physiological causes of death remain areas for future study, the silkworm model provides a powerful tool for large-scale genetic screening of marine pathogens.

Summary updated

Abstract

The halophilic marine bacterium, Vibrio vulnificus, occasionally causes fatal septicemia in immunocompromised patients. Mice are commonly used as experimental animals to investigate the virulence of V. vulnificus, however, a large number of mice are generally required for bioassays. The present study examined whether the invertebrate species, silkworms, can be used instead of mice to investigate V. vulnificus virulence. When the silkworms were inoculated with 1.2x107 colony forming units of V. vulnificus OPU1‑Rf, a virulent strain of V. vulnificus, all injected silkworms died within 48 h, however, those injected with culture filtrate or diluent did not. This silkworm infection model was then used to isolate attenuated V. vulnificus mutants from 1,016 transposon‑inserted mutants. Consequently, a harmless mutant, SW998, was isolated. In this strain, the transposon was inserted into the rtxA gene, which is a known V. vulnificus virulence gene. In conclusion, the present study demonstrated that silkworms are useful animals for investigating the virulence of V. vulnificus.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{yamamoto2016silkworm,
  author = {Mai Yamamoto and Takashige Kashimoto and Yukihiro Yoshimura and Nao Tachibana and Shiho Kuroda and Yoshiko Miki and Sou Kitabayashi and Ping Tong and Jianbo Xiao and Kōichi Tanaka and Hiroshi Hamamoto and Kazuhisa Sekimizu and Koichiro Yamamoto},
  title = {{A silkworm infection model to investigate Vibrio vulnificus virulence genes}},
  booktitle = {Molecular},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.3892/mmr.2016.5782},
}
Figure