A short history of thrombectomy – Procedure and success analysis of different endovascular stroke treatment techniques

Benjamin Friedrich, Tobias Boeckh‐Behrens, V Krüssmann, Sebastian Mönch, Jan S. Kirschke, Kornelia Kreiser, Maria Berndt, Manuel Lehm, Silke Wunderlich, Claus Zimmer, Johannes Kaesmacher, Christian MaegerleinInterventional 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper tracks the evolution of mechanical thrombectomy for ischemic stroke, demonstrating how advancements in devices and techniques have dramatically improved success rates and reduced complications. The key takeaway is that combination approaches, particularly those involving balloon guide catheters and aspiration, are now the most effective and should be considered standard of care.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Stroke, particularly ischemic stroke caused by large vessel occlusions (LVOs), is a time-sensitive medical emergency. Historically, treatment relied on intravenous thrombolysis (clot-busting drugs), but this was often insufficient for large clots. Mechanical thrombectomy, the physical removal of these clots using endovascular techniques, emerged as a crucial alternative. However, the field has seen a rapid evolution of devices and procedural strategies, leading to questions about which techniques are most effective and whether the differences in approach translate to tangible improvements in clinical outcomes. This paper aims to analyze the historical development of these techniques and assess their technical and clinical success rates at a single comprehensive stroke center.

Methods

The study analyzed a retrospective and prospective database of patients who underwent endovascular treatment for LVOs (specifically carotid-T or M1 segment of the middle cerebral artery) at a single center between 2008 and 2018. Patients were categorized into eight distinct intervention technique groups, ranging from early "old devices" to various combinations of guiding catheters, distal access catheters, aspiration catheters, stent retrievers, and balloon guide catheters (BGCs). Patients who required conversion to a different technique during the procedure or needed permanent stent implantation were excluded. Technical success was defined by the modified Thrombolysis In Cerebral Infarction (mTICI) score (mTICI 2b/3). The researchers analyzed reperfusion rates, first-pass reperfusion rates, the number of maneuvers required, procedure times, and the incidence of embolization to new territories (ENT). Statistical analysis involved Spearman correlation and Kruskal-Wallis tests to compare groups.

Datasets

The study utilized a combined retrospective and prospective database of 786 patients treated at a single comprehensive stroke center from January 2008 to June 2018. After exclusions (patients with unclear techniques or mixed techniques), 668 patients were included in the final analysis. This dataset represents a real-world clinical experience over a decade of evolving thrombectomy practices.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Evolutionary Leap: The progression from early mechanical devices to modern combination techniques has not been incremental; it represents a significant leap in technical efficacy.
  • The Power of Combination: Simply using a stent retriever is good, but combining it with other tools like aspiration catheters and, crucially, balloon guide catheters, dramatically boosts success rates.
  • Flow Modulation is Key: Balloon guide catheters (BGCs) appear to be a critical component in improving outcomes, likely by stabilizing the access and allowing for better flow control during clot retrieval.
  • Efficiency Gains: Newer techniques not only achieve better reperfusion but do so more efficiently, requiring fewer maneuvers and less time, which is critical in acute stroke care.
  • Safety Improvements: The development of these advanced techniques has also led to a significant reduction in complications like embolization to previously unaffected territories.

Key Results

  • Reperfusion Rates: Successful reperfusion rates varied significantly by technique, ranging from 56% to 100%.
  • BGC Impact: Techniques utilizing balloon guide catheters (BGCs) consistently showed higher success rates (above 90%) and improved procedural efficiency.
  • Efficiency Metrics: While older devices required a median of 3 maneuvers and 90 minutes for reperfusion, techniques like PROTECTPLUS achieved results in a median of 1 maneuver and 23 minutes.
  • Complete Reperfusion (mTICI 3): The rate of complete reperfusion (mTICI 3) increased dramatically from 12% with old devices to nearly 76% with PROTECTPLUS.
  • First-Pass Success: First-pass mTICI 3 rates also saw substantial improvement, rising from 3% with old devices to 51.5% with PROTECTPLUS.
  • Reduced Embolization: The rate of embolization to new territories (ENT) decreased from 14.7% with old devices to 0% with PROTECTPLUS.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Retrospective Nature: The study is based on a retrospective analysis of prospectively collected data, which has inherent limitations.
  • Small Group Sizes: Some technique groups, particularly "GC + Stent Retriever" and "BGC + Stent Retriever," had small sample sizes (n=12 and n=10, respectively), which may limit the generalizability of their specific findings.
  • Exclusion of Converted Cases: Excluding patients who required a change in technique during the procedure might introduce a bias, as these could represent more complex or difficult cases.
  • Lack of Long-Term Clinical Data: The study did not have comprehensive long-term clinical outcome data for all patients, relying on the assumption that successful reperfusion correlates with better outcomes.

Future work could focus on collecting long-term clinical outcome data to directly link technical success to patient benefit. Further research into optimizing combination techniques and understanding the nuances of flow modulation would also be valuable. The authors suggest that combination techniques, particularly those involving flow modulation, have emerged as the safest and most effective approach and should be considered standard of care.

Summary updated

Abstract

Technical success of MT has improved substantially over the past decade owing to improved materials and procedural innovations. Combination techniques including flow modulation have emerged to be the most effective approach and should be considered as a standard of care.<b>Level of evidence:</b> Level 3, retrospective study.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{friedrich2020short,
  author = {Benjamin Friedrich and Tobias Boeckh‐Behrens and V Krüssmann and Sebastian Mönch and Jan S. Kirschke and Kornelia Kreiser and Maria Berndt and Manuel Lehm and Silke Wunderlich and Claus Zimmer and Johannes Kaesmacher and Christian Maegerlein},
  title = {{A short history of thrombectomy – Procedure and success analysis of different endovascular stroke treatment techniques}},
  booktitle = {Interventional},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1177/1591019920961883},
}
Figure