A Service System with Randomly Behaving On-demand Agents

Lam M. Nguyen, Alexander L. StolyarSIGMETRICS 2016 · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper tackles the challenge of efficiently managing on-demand service systems with unreliable agents (servers) who might join late or leave after service. The authors develop an adaptive invitation scheme and analyze its stability using fluid limits and switched linear systems, providing sufficient conditions for efficient operation and suggesting local stability implies global stability.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Modern service systems, like call centers or telemedicine platforms, often rely on on-demand agents. The core problem is how to dynamically invite these agents to match a fluctuating customer demand, ensuring minimal waiting times for both customers and agents. This is complicated by two key factors: agents don't always arrive instantly after being invited (they have a random delay), and their behavior after completing a service is uncertain – they might rejoin the queue or leave the system entirely. The paper aims to design a real-time, adaptive invitation strategy that can handle this randomness and keep queues small, even as customer demand grows significantly.

Methods

The authors employ a multi-pronged approach:

  • Fluid Limits: They analyze the system's behavior in an asymptotic regime where the customer arrival rate becomes very large. This allows them to approximate the discrete system dynamics with continuous differential equations, simplifying analysis.
  • Switched Linear Systems: The fluid limit model turns out to be a switched linear system, meaning its dynamics change based on certain conditions (e.g., the sign of the queue difference). The paper leverages techniques from this field to study system stability.
  • Common Quadratic Lyapunov Functions (CQLF): This is a standard tool in control theory for proving the stability of linear systems. The authors use CQLFs to derive sufficient conditions for the exponential stability of their fluid limit model.
  • Adaptive Feedback Scheme: The core of their proposed solution is a feedback-based scheme that adjusts the number of pending agent invitations based on real-time queue lengths and their changes.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Agent Rejoining is Crucial: The paper generalizes previous models by allowing agents to rejoin the queue after service, making the model more realistic for many applications. This adds significant complexity to the system dynamics.
  • Complex Fluid Dynamics: The fluid limit trajectories exhibit intricate behavior, with different differential equations governing different regions of the state space and a "reflecting boundary" that prevents certain states.
  • Local Stability as a Proxy for Global Stability: The authors derive sufficient conditions for local stability of the fluid limit system. They conjecture that for this model, local stability is sufficient for global stability, a significant simplification if true, and provide strong numerical evidence for this conjecture.
  • Trade-offs in Agent Behavior: The parameters governing agent acceptance probability, service times, and rejoining behavior directly influence the stability conditions, highlighting the importance of tuning these parameters for optimal performance.

Key Results

  • Theorem 1: Establishes the convergence of the fluid-scaled processes to a deterministic fluid limit trajectory, which is a solution to a system of differential equations with a reflecting boundary.
  • Theorems 2 & 3: Provide sufficient conditions (in terms of system parameters like arrival rate, service rate, and agent behavior probabilities) for the local exponential stability of the fluid limit system. These conditions are derived using the CQLF machinery.
  • Numerical Evidence: Extensive simulations support the theoretical findings, demonstrating that when the derived local stability conditions are met, the adaptive invitation scheme performs well, and the system appears to be globally stable.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Conjectures: The paper presents strong conjectures about the sufficiency of local stability for global stability and the role of matrix A- being Hurwitz for stability. These are supported by simulations but require formal proof.
  • Generalizations: The authors suggest future research could explore further generalizations of the agent invitation model, such as different arrival processes, service time distributions, or more complex agent behaviors.
  • Practical Implementation: While the paper provides theoretical conditions, translating these into practical, real-time control parameters for actual service systems would be a valuable next step.

Summary updated

Abstract

We consider a service system where agents (or, servers) are invited on-demand. Customers arrive as a Poisson process and join a customer queue. Customer service times are i.i.d. exponential. Agents' behavior is random in two respects. First, they can be invited into the system exogenously, and join the agent queue after a random time. Second, with some probability they rejoin the agent queue after a service completion, and otherwise leave the system. The objective is to design a real-time adaptive agent invitation scheme that keeps both customer and agent queues/waiting-times small. We study an adaptive scheme, which controls the number of pending agent invitations, based on queue-state feedback. We study the system process fluid limits, in the asymptotic regime where the customer arrival rate goes to infinity. We use the machinery of switched linear systems and common quadratic Lyapunov functions to derive sufficient conditions for the local stability of fluid limits at the desired equilibrium point (with zero queues). We conjecture that, for our model, local stability is in fact sufficient for global stability of fluid limits; the validity of this conjecture is supported by numerical and simulation experiments. When the local stability conditions do hold, simulations show good overall performance of the scheme.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{nguyen2016service,
  author = {Lam M. Nguyen and Alexander L. Stolyar},
  title = {{A Service System with Randomly Behaving On-demand Agents}},
  booktitle = {SIGMETRICS},
  year = {2016},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=_hyYqj9B6o6},
}
Figure