A Secure Wireless Information and Energy Cooperation Transmission Strategy in Spectrum Sharing Networks With Untrusted Dual-Relay

Daqian Zhao, Hui Tian, Ping ZhangIEEE Access 2019 · DOI

Introduction

Modern wireless communication systems are increasingly constrained by spectrum scarcity, energy limitations in IoT devices, and security risks in decentralized networks. This paper, published in IEEE Access, proposes a novel overlay spectrum sharing strategy that addresses these challenges simultaneously. By allowing secondary users (SUs) to harvest energy from primary signals in exchange for relaying services, the framework optimizes resource utilization while maintaining physical layer security against untrusted relays.

System Model and Transmission Strategy

The study considers a primary network consisting of a transmitter (PT) and a receiver (PU), and a secondary network with two energy-constrained SUs. These SUs act as relays but are considered "untrusted," meaning they might attempt to decode the primary system's confidential data. To mitigate this, the authors implement an Artificial Noise (AN)-aided joint time division- and power splitting-based strategy.

The proposed three-phase system model for secure information and energy cooperation.

The transmission process is divided into three distinct phases:

  1. Phase 1 (Broadcast): The PT transmits the confidential signal along with AN. SUs use a Power Splitting (PS) technique to divert a portion of the received signal to an Energy Harvester (EH) and the remainder to an Information Processor (IP). The PU, possessing the AN key, can cancel the noise, whereas the SUs cannot.
  2. Phase 2 (Relaying): The SUs employ the Amplify-and-Forward (AF) protocol to relay the PU's signal. AF is specifically chosen to prevent SUs from decoding the confidential information, a risk inherent in Decode-and-Forward (DF) protocols.
  3. Phase 3 (Secondary Transmission): Having fulfilled their relaying obligation, the SUs use the remaining time and harvested energy to transmit their own private data.

Optimization and Performance

The authors formulated a non-convex optimization problem to maximize the SU's achievable data rate. This problem involves the joint optimization of time division ratios ($\alpha, \beta$) and power splitting ratios ($\rho$). The solution accounts for both perfect and imperfect Channel State Information (CSI) using the fmincon Interior Point Algorithm.

Key Insights

  • Dual Utility of Artificial Noise: AN is traditionally a security tool, but here it also serves as an additional source of RF energy for the SUs to harvest.
  • Dominance of Time Allocation: Simulations revealed that the time division ratios have a more significant impact on system performance than transmit power or initial energy levels.
  • CSI Sensitivity: The system's performance is highly sensitive to channel estimation errors. Under imperfect CSI, residual interference from un-cancelled AN becomes a primary bottleneck for the secondary transmission rate.

Results and Discussion

Extensive Monte Carlo simulations validated the proposed strategy against several heuristic schemes with fixed parameters. The optimized joint strategy consistently outperformed heuristics, maintaining higher SU data rates even as the PU's security requirements became more stringent. Furthermore, the results confirmed that increasing the PT's transmit power directly enhances the SU's rate by providing more "fuel" for energy harvesting.

Conclusion

This research provides a comprehensive framework for secure and energy-efficient spectrum sharing. By integrating RF energy harvesting with physical layer security, the proposed strategy allows secondary devices to operate autonomously while assisting the primary network. Future research directions include exploring non-linear energy harvesting models and the impact of node mobility on channel estimation and security.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{zhao2019secure,
  author = {Daqian Zhao and Hui Tian and Ping Zhang},
  title = {{A Secure Wireless Information and Energy Cooperation Transmission Strategy in Spectrum Sharing Networks With Untrusted Dual-Relay}},
  journal = {IEEE Access},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1109/access.2019.2932762},
}
Figure