A Search for Kilonova Radio Flares in a Sample of Swift/BAT Short Gamma-Ray Bursts

Avery Eddins, K. H. Lee, A. Corsi, I. Bartos, Z. Márka, Szabolcs MárkaThe Astrophysical Journal 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper searches for faint, late-time radio flares from short gamma-ray bursts (GRBs) that could signal nearby binary neutron star (BNS) mergers, similar to the GW170817 event. While most GRBs in their sample showed no such emission, they identified one promising candidate, GRB 111126A, which warrants further investigation to confirm its origin.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The groundbreaking detection of gravitational waves (GWs) from the BNS merger GW170817, followed by its electromagnetic counterpart (a short GRB and a kilonova), revolutionized our understanding of these events. It revealed that short GRBs can be associated with BNS mergers and that their radio afterglows can be more complex than initially thought, with emission peaking much later than typical follow-up observations. This implies that many BNS mergers, and their associated radio flares, might have been missed. This paper addresses the challenge of identifying these potentially missed events by searching for late-time radio emission from a sample of short GRBs that lack precise localization and redshift information, making them prime candidates for nearby, previously undetected BNS mergers.

Methods

The researchers employed the Karl G. Jansky Very Large Array (VLA) to conduct radio observations of seven short GRBs from the Swift/BAT catalog. These GRBs were specifically chosen because they lacked accurate X-ray localizations and redshift measurements, increasing the likelihood of them being nearby BNS mergers. The observations were performed at two frequencies (3 GHz and 6 GHz) to capture potential late-time radio flares. The data was meticulously calibrated and analyzed using standard astronomical software. Candidate radio sources within the GRB error regions were identified and then subjected to a rigorous selection process. This process involved checking for signal-to-noise ratios, positional accuracy, and ruling out known persistent radio sources. They also analyzed the spectral indices of the candidate counterparts to distinguish between BNS merger emission, star formation, or active galactic nucleus (AGN) activity. Finally, they modeled the observed radio emission using a two-component BNS merger ejecta model to estimate distances and interstellar medium densities.

Datasets

The primary dataset consists of radio observations from the Karl G. Jansky Very Large Array (VLA) for seven specific short GRBs from the Swift/BAT catalog. Additionally, the study references and utilizes data from existing astronomical catalogs such as the NASA/IPAC Extragalactic Database (NED), the VLA FIRST catalog, the VLASS quick look image repository, and the Chandra Source Catalog.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "missed" population: The GW170817 event highlights that BNS mergers can produce late-time radio flares, but typical observational strategies might miss these if the GRBs are not well-localized or if follow-up observations are not extended for years.
  • Targeting the unknown: By focusing on GRBs without redshift information, the study aims to uncover nearby BNS mergers that would otherwise be indistinguishable from more distant events.
  • GRB 111126A as a promising candidate: The identification of a single radio candidate, GRB 111126A, is a significant result, suggesting that such searches can indeed yield potential counterparts.
  • Distinguishing origins is crucial: The spectral index analysis is vital for differentiating between BNS merger emission and other astrophysical sources like star formation or AGNs, underscoring the complexity of interpreting radio signals.

Key Results

Out of the seven GRBs observed, only one, GRB 111126A, yielded a candidate radio counterpart that passed all selection criteria. This candidate, GRB 111126A-Candidate-1, shows spectral properties that are broadly consistent with BNS merger emission, though an origin from star formation or an AGN cannot be definitively ruled out without further observations. The study also provides constraints on the properties of the other GRBs, indicating they are unlikely to harbor nearby BNS mergers with detectable late-time radio flares.

Limitations and Future Work

The primary limitation is the small sample size of seven GRBs, which naturally leads to a low detection rate. The identified candidate, GRB 111126A-Candidate-1, requires further follow-up observations to confirm its time variability and definitively establish its origin. The authors suggest that re-observing this candidate in 2024 would be crucial for further constraining its nature, especially if it is located at a distance of around 40 Mpc, where rising light curves are predicted. They also emphasize the need for continued observational programs targeting similar GRB samples to increase the chances of finding more nearby BNS merger events.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract The multimessenger detection of GW170817 showed that binary neutron star (BNS) mergers are progenitors of (at least some) short gamma-ray bursts (GRBs), and that short GRB jets (and their afterglows) can have structures (and observational properties) more complex than predicted by the standard top-hat jet scenario. Indeed, the emission from the structured jet launched in GW170817 peaked in the radio band (centimeter wavelengths) at ≈100 days since merger—a timescale much longer than the typical time span of radio follow-up observations of short GRBs. Moreover, radio searches for a potential late-time radio flare from the fast tail of the neutron-rich debris that powered the kilonova associated with GW170817 (AT 2017gfo) have extended to even longer timescales (years after the merger). In light of this, here we present the results of an observational campaign targeting a sample of seven, years-old GRBs in the Swift/BAT sample with no redshift measurements and no promptly identified X-ray counterpart. Our goal is to assess whether this sample of short GRBs could harbor nearby BNS mergers, searching for the late-time radio emission expected from their ejecta. We found one radio candidate counterpart for one of the GRBs in our sample, GRB 111126A, though an origin related to emission from star formation or from an active galactic nucleus in its host galaxy cannot be excluded without further observations.
BibTeX
@article{eddins2023search,
  author = {Avery Eddins and K. H. Lee and A. Corsi and I. Bartos and Z. Márka and Szabolcs Márka},
  title = {{A Search for Kilonova Radio Flares in a Sample of Swift/BAT Short Gamma-Ray Bursts}},
  journal = {The Astrophysical Journal},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3847/1538-4357/acc6c5},
}
Figure