A search for bremsstrahlung solar axions using the Majorana low-background BEGe detector at Kimballton (MALBEK)

N. Abgrall, E. Aguayo, F. T. Avignone, A. S. Barabash, F. E. Bertrand, M. Boswell, V. Brudanin, M. Busch, A. Caldwell, Y-d. Chan, C. D. Christofferson, D. C. Combs, R.j. Cooper, R. J. Creswick, J. A. Detwiler, P. J. Doe, Y. V. Efremenko, V.Yu. Egorov, S. R. Elliott, J. Fast, P. Finnerty, F. M. Fraenkle, A. Galindo-Uribarri, G. K. Giovanetti, J. Goett, M. P. Green, J. Gruszko, V.e. Guiseppe, K. Gusev, A. Hegai, R. Henning, E. W. Hoppe, S. Howard, M. A. Howe, K. Keeter, M. F. Kidd, A. Knecht, O. Kochetov, С. И. Коновалов, R. T. Kouzes, B. D. LaFerriere, J. Leon, L. E. Leviner, J. C. Loach, J. MacMullin, S. MacMullin, M. G. Marino, R. D. Martín, S. Mertens, J. L. Orrell, C. O’Shaughnessy, Nicole Overman, D. G. Phillips, A. W. P. Poon, K. Pushkin, D. C. Radford, K. Rielage, R. G. H. Robertson, M. Ronquest, A. Schubert, B. Shanks, M. Shirchenko, K. J. Snavely, N. Snyder, D. Steele, A. M. Suriano, J. Thompson, V. Timkin, R. L. Varner, S. Vasilyev, K. Vetter, Kristopher Vorren, B. R. White, J. F. Wilkerson, W. Xu, E. Yakushev, A. R. Young, C.-h. Yu, V. YumatovarXiv 2014 · DOI · arXiv

TL;DR

Researchers have used a highly sensitive germanium detector to search for elusive solar axions, setting a new, stringent upper limit on their interaction strength with electrons. This work refines our understanding of axion physics and paves the way for future, even more sensitive experiments like the MAJORANA DEMONSTRATOR.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The Standard Model of particle physics has a "strong CP problem" – a theoretical parameter that should be tiny, but there's no fundamental reason why it must be. The Peccei-Quinn mechanism offers a solution by postulating a new particle, the axion, which is a hypothetical, very light, and weakly interacting particle. Axions could be produced in the Sun via a process called bremsstrahlung (similar to how X-rays are produced). Detecting these solar axions would be a significant discovery, providing evidence for physics beyond the Standard Model. However, axions are notoriously difficult to detect due to their weak interactions. This paper aims to improve the search for these solar axions, specifically by looking for their interaction with electrons in a germanium detector.

Methods

The experiment utilizes a low-background, high-purity germanium detector (specifically, a Broad Energy Germanium or BEGe detector) operated at the Kimballton Underground Research Facility. This location provides significant shielding from cosmic rays. The detector is designed to be sensitive to low-energy events. The core method involves searching for a specific signal: axioelectric absorption. This is where a solar axion interacts with an electron in the germanium crystal, depositing its energy and creating a detectable signal. The researchers analyzed data collected over 221.5 live days, applying various analysis cuts to remove unwanted noise and background events. They then performed an extended maximum likelihood fit to the energy spectrum in a region of interest (1.6 keV to 4.5 keV) where they expected to see axion signals, comparing it to a background-only model.

Datasets

The primary dataset consists of 221.5 live days of data collected by the MALBEK detector between November 2011 and August 2012. This data was processed and analyzed using established techniques for low-background detector experiments. No new benchmark datasets were introduced; rather, the analysis focused on interpreting the experimental data in the context of theoretical models.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Axions are elusive but potentially detectable: The paper highlights the ongoing quest to find axions, particles predicted by theory but not yet observed, and the specific challenge of detecting them from solar sources.
  • Germanium detectors are powerful tools: The use of a high-purity, low-background germanium detector demonstrates its suitability for searching for very low-energy interactions, crucial for axion detection.
  • Bremsstrahlung solar axions are a viable target: The experiment focuses on axions produced in the Sun via bremsstrahlung, a well-motivated production mechanism.
  • Annual modulation offers future sensitivity: The paper points out that the Earth's changing distance from the Sun throughout the year causes a predictable modulation in the solar axion flux, which can be exploited by future experiments to improve sensitivity.

Key Results

The MALBEK experiment placed an upper bound of $1.36 \times 10^{-11}$ (at 95% confidence level) on the direct coupling of DFSZ model axions to electrons ($g_{ae}$). This is a significant improvement over previous limits and provides a stringent constraint on axion properties. The paper also discusses the potential for future experiments, like the MAJORANA DEMONSTRATOR, to achieve even greater sensitivity, potentially reaching $g_{ae} > 3.5 \times 10^{-12}$ with a larger exposure.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that the sensitivity of this experiment is limited by the background rate in the detector. They also note that the axioelectric cross-section calculation used in some previous studies might not fully capture the relativistic limit, potentially affecting comparisons with other experiments. Future work will involve the MAJORANA DEMONSTRATOR, which will utilize a much larger mass of germanium detectors and aim for even lower backgrounds. This will allow for a more sensitive search for solar axions and the exploitation of the annual modulation effect for improved discovery potential.

Summary updated

Abstract

A low-background, high-purity germanium detector has been used to search for evidence of low-energy, bremsstrahlung-generated solar axions. An upper bound of $1.36\times 10^{-11}$ $(95% CL)$ is placed on the direct coupling of DFSZ model axions to electrons. The prospects for the sensitivity of the Majorana Demonstrator array of point-contact germanium detectors to solar axions are discussed in the context of the model-independent annual modulation due to the seasonal variation of the earth-sun distance.
BibTeX
@misc{abgrall2014search,
  author = {N. Abgrall and E. Aguayo and F. T. Avignone and A. S. Barabash and F. E. Bertrand and M. Boswell and V. Brudanin and M. Busch and A. Caldwell and Y-D. Chan and C. D. Christofferson and D. C. Combs and R.J. Cooper and R. J. Creswick and J. A. Detwiler and P. J. Doe and Y. V. Efremenko and V.Yu. Egorov and S. R. Elliott and J. Fast and P. Finnerty and F. M. Fraenkle and A. Galindo-Uribarri and G. K. Giovanetti and J. Goett and M. P. Green and J. Gruszko and V.E. Guiseppe and K. Gusev and A. Hegai and R. Henning and E. W. Hoppe and S. Howard and M. A. Howe and K. Keeter and M. F. Kidd and A. Knecht and O. Kochetov and С. И. Коновалов and R. T. Kouzes and B. D. LaFerriere and J. Leon and L. E. Leviner and J. C. Loach and J. MacMullin and S. MacMullin and M. G. Marino and R. D. Martín and S. Mertens and J. L. Orrell and C. O’Shaughnessy and Nicole Overman and D. G. Phillips and A. W. P. Poon and K. Pushkin and D. C. Radford and K. Rielage and R. G. H. Robertson and M. Ronquest and A. Schubert and B. Shanks and M. Shirchenko and K. J. Snavely and N. Snyder and D. Steele and A. M. Suriano and J. Thompson and V. Timkin and R. L. Varner and S. Vasilyev and K. Vetter and Kristopher Vorren and B. R. White and J. F. Wilkerson and W. Xu and E. Yakushev and A. R. Young and C.-H. Yu and V. Yumatov},
  title = {{A search for bremsstrahlung solar axions using the Majorana low-background BEGe detector at Kimballton (MALBEK)}},
  year = {2014},
  eprint = {1403.0475},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1403.0475},
}
Figure