A Scan Statistic for Binary Outcome Based on Hypergeometric Probability Model, with an Application to Detecting Spatial Clusters of Japanese Encephalitis

Xing Zhao, Xiao‐Hua Zhou, Zijian Feng, Pengfei Guo, Hongyan He, Tao Zhang, Lei Duan, Xiaosong LiPLoS 2013 · DOI

Abstract

Spatial scan statistics are essential for identifying geographical clusters of events. While classic versions rely on Bernoulli or Poisson models, this paper introduces a Hypergeometric probability model to construct the likelihood function. Applied to Japanese Encephalitis (JE) data in Sichuan, China, the Hypergeometric (H) model identifies clusters identical to those found by Kulldorff’s method. However, simulation benchmarks reveal that the H model outperforms traditional statistics in scenarios involving high population density or large cluster sizes.

Introduction

In epidemiology, identifying "hotspots" or clusters of a disease is critical for resource allocation and understanding disease etiology. The most widely used tool for this is the spatial scan statistic. Traditionally, these statistics rely on Bernoulli or Poisson models to calculate the likelihood that a specific geographic window contains a cluster. However, these models often serve as approximations. For binary outcomes—where an individual is either a "case" or a "control"—the Hypergeometric distribution, which models sampling without replacement from a finite population, may provide a more precise fit.

Methods

The researchers proposed a shift from maximizing a likelihood ratio to minimizing a probability under the null hypothesis of complete spatial randomness.

  1. The H Model: Instead of the standard Poisson likelihood ratio, the Hypergeometric distribution calculates the probability of observing a specific number of cases within a window, given the total population and total cases in the entire study region.
  2. The "Most Strange Window": The test statistic identifies the window yielding the minimum probability, termed the "most strange window" as it is the least likely to occur by chance.
  3. Significance Testing: Monte Carlo simulations (99,999 random replications) determine the p-value to ensure detected clusters are statistically significant.
  4. Evaluation Metrics: Models were compared using Sensitivity (SEN)—the probability of detecting the true cluster—and Positive Predictive Value (PPV)—the proportion of the detected cluster that actually belongs to the true cluster.

Results and Application

The study utilized two primary datasets: 2009 Japanese Encephalitis (JE) cases in Sichuan, China, and a Northeastern US benchmark for simulation.

Real-World Application in Sichuan

When applied to the Sichuan JE data (596 cases across 181 counties), both the H model and the Poisson model identified identical primary and secondary clusters. The primary cluster was located in the southeast, while the secondary cluster appeared in the northeast.

Spatial clusters of Japanese Encephalitis in Sichuan province, China (2009) identified by the H and Poisson models.

Simulation Performance

Benchmarks indicated a performance trade-off between the models. The H model excels in urban areas and for large-scale clusters, whereas the Poisson model remains superior for rural areas or very small clusters.

Comparison of Sensitivity (SEN) and Positive Predictive Value (PPV) between the Hypergeometric (H) and Poisson (P) models across different population densities.

As shown in the simulation results, the H model consistently showed higher SEN and PPV in urban settings. For instance, in one urban simulation, the H model achieved a SEN of 86.40% compared to the Poisson's 84.00%. The H model's advantage became more pronounced as the size of the "hot-spot" cluster increased.

Discussion

The Hypergeometric model is fundamentally about sampling without replacement, which is theoretically more accurate for fixed populations in geographic regions than the Poisson model. While not a replacement for Kulldorff’s method, the H model serves as a specialized tool. It is particularly powerful for monitoring infectious diseases in high-density urban environments or when large-scale outbreaks are suspected.

Future work may extend the H model to accommodate irregularly shaped scanning windows and account for spatial autocorrelation, where neighboring areas naturally exhibit similar characteristics.

Summary updated

Abstract

As a useful tool for geographical cluster detection of events, the spatial scan statistic is widely applied in many fields and plays an increasingly important role. The classic version of the spatial scan statistic for the binary outcome is developed by Kulldorff, based on the Bernoulli or the Poisson probability model. In this paper, we apply the Hypergeometric probability model to construct the likelihood function under the null hypothesis. Compared with existing methods, the likelihood function under the null hypothesis is an alternative and indirect method to identify the potential cluster, and the test statistic is the extreme value of the likelihood function. Similar with Kulldorff's methods, we adopt Monte Carlo test for the test of significance. Both methods are applied for detecting spatial clusters of Japanese encephalitis in Sichuan province, China, in 2009, and the detected clusters are identical. Through a simulation to independent benchmark data, it is indicated that the test statistic based on the Hypergeometric model outweighs Kulldorff's statistics for clusters of high population density or large size; otherwise Kulldorff's statistics are superior.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhao2013scan,
  author = {Xing Zhao and Xiao‐Hua Zhou and Zijian Feng and Pengfei Guo and Hongyan He and Tao Zhang and Lei Duan and Xiaosong Li},
  title = {{A Scan Statistic for Binary Outcome Based on Hypergeometric Probability Model, with an Application to Detecting Spatial Clusters of Japanese Encephalitis}},
  booktitle = {PLoS},
  year = {2013},
  doi = {10.1371/journal.pone.0065419},
}
Figure