TL;DR
This paper introduces SMMR, a novel sentence scoring method for multi-document update summarization. It cleverly adapts the Maximal Marginal Relevance (MMR) framework to prioritize novel information by balancing query relevance with dissimilarity to previously read documents, achieving competitive results on the DUC 2007 update corpus.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Creating effective summaries of new information, especially when users have already been exposed to related content, is a significant challenge. Traditional summarization methods often focus on general relevance. However, "update summarization" requires identifying and presenting new information that a user hasn't encountered before. This means not only understanding what's relevant to a query but also what's novel compared to a user's existing knowledge base (the "history"). The core problem is how to efficiently score sentences to prioritize this novel information, especially as the amount of historical context grows.
Methods
The paper proposes SMMR (Scalable Maximal Marginal Relevance), an adaptation of the MMR algorithm for update summarization. MMR typically balances query relevance with redundancy among selected sentences. SMMR modifies this by:
- Query Relevance: Sentences are initially scored based on their relevance to the query. This is done using a combination of cosine similarity and a smoothed Jaro-Winkler distance (JWe) to account for potential misspellings and normalization issues.
- Novelty (Dissimilarity to History): The key innovation is how SMMR incorporates the "history" (previously read documents). As the history grows, SMMR increasingly prioritizes sentences that are dissimilar to the historical content. This is achieved by modifying the MMR objective function to explicitly penalize sentences that are similar to those already in the history. The paper uses a simple rational function
f(H)that decreases as the history size increases, effectively shifting the balance towards novelty. - Scalability: The method is designed to be scalable, meaning it can handle increasing amounts of historical data without becoming computationally prohibitive.
Datasets
- DUC 2007 update corpus: This dataset was used for both training (implicitly, for tuning parameters like
ain the similarity measure) and evaluation. The corpus consists of 10 topics, each with 25 documents, and the task is to produce short (~100 words) update summaries. The evaluation was performed on three document clusters (A, B, and C) per topic, simulating a user reading documents chronologically.
Key Insights and Ideas
- History as a Key Factor: The paper highlights that simply focusing on query relevance is insufficient for update summarization. The user's prior knowledge (history) is crucial and must be actively incorporated into the scoring mechanism.
- MMR's Adaptability: The Maximal Marginal Relevance framework, originally designed for redundancy reduction within a single summary, can be effectively adapted to prioritize novelty by treating the "history" as a source of redundancy to be avoided.
- Balancing Act: The core insight is the need for a dynamic balance between query relevance and novelty. As the user's exposure to information increases, the emphasis should shift from pure relevance to ensuring the summary contains genuinely new insights.
- Simplicity and Efficiency: SMMR avoids complex linguistic knowledge or extensive re-ranking post-processing, making it a computationally efficient and straightforward approach.
Key Results
- SMMR achieved promising results on the DUC 2007 update corpus, outperforming other sentence scoring methods tested.
- When compared to the official DUC 2007 results, SMMR would have been ranked second among participating systems.
- The paper notes that no post-processing was applied to the selected sentences, suggesting further potential for improvement.
- Interestingly, a simpler method (cosine + JWe) without explicit history consideration also performed well, which the authors attribute to the relatively low redundancy between clusters in the DUC corpus.
Limitations and Future Work
- Linguistic Quality: While SMMR focuses on selecting relevant and novel sentences, the paper acknowledges that approaches mixing IR techniques (like this one) require intensive work to ensure the final summary is fluent and coherent. This is identified as a key area for future investigation.
- Function
f(H): The paper uses a simple rational function forf(H). Exploring more sophisticated functions that better model the increasing prioritization of non-redundancy as history grows could be a direction for future work. - Scalability with Very Large Histories: While designed to be scalable, the performance with extremely large historical datasets might warrant further investigation.
Summary updated