A scalable line-independent design algorithm for voltage and frequency control in AC islanded microgrids

Michele Tucci, Giancarlo Ferrari-TrecatearXiv 2017 · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel, "line-independent" decentralized control algorithm for AC islanded microgrids. This approach allows Distributed Generation Units (DGUs) to be added or removed seamlessly without affecting overall grid stability, and crucially, local controllers don't need to know the parameters of the connecting power lines.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Islanded microgrids, which operate independently of the main power grid, face a critical challenge in maintaining stable voltage and frequency. This is especially true as microgrids are becoming more dynamic, with Distributed Generation Units (DGUs) and loads frequently being connected or disconnected (Plug-and-Play or PnP operation). Traditional control methods often require detailed knowledge of the entire microgrid's topology and electrical parameters, making them inflexible and difficult to update when the grid configuration changes. Furthermore, the electrical coupling between DGUs through power lines can complicate stability analysis and controller design. This paper tackles the problem of designing a robust, scalable, and adaptable control system for AC islanded microgrids that can handle dynamic topology changes without requiring knowledge of the connecting line parameters.

Methods

The core of the proposed solution is a decentralized control synthesis procedure that is line-independent. This means:

  • Local Controller Design: Each DGU's controller is designed using only its own parameters and not the models of the power lines connecting it to its neighbors.
  • Plug-and-Play (PnP) Capability: When a new DGU is added, the controllers of existing DGUs do not need to be retuned. Similarly, removing a DGU doesn't destabilize the grid.
  • Formal Stability Guarantees: The authors provide a rigorous mathematical proof that stabilizing local controllers can always be computed, regardless of the specific electrical parameters of the DGUs and lines. This is achieved through the use of Linear Matrix Inequalities (LMIs) and Lyapunov stability theory, complemented by the LaSalle invariance principle.
  • Augmented System Model: To handle voltage and frequency tracking, the standard DGU model is augmented with integrators, creating a system that can maintain constant reference values.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The evaluation is performed through simulations using PSCAD.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Line-Independence is Key: The most significant insight is the development of a control design that completely decouples the controller from the parameters of the connecting power lines. This drastically simplifies PnP operations and makes the system more robust to changes in grid topology.
  • Formal Guarantees for PnP: Unlike some previous PnP approaches, this method provides formal guarantees of stability, ensuring that DGUs can be added or removed without compromising the entire microgrid's operation.
  • Universal Controller Computability: The proof that stabilizing controllers can always be computed, irrespective of electrical parameters, is a strong theoretical contribution. This implies a high degree of design flexibility.
  • Robustness to Clock Desynchronization: The paper demonstrates that while clock synchronization issues can affect tracking performance, they do not compromise the overall stability of the microgrid, a crucial practical consideration.

Key Results

  • Successful PnP Simulation: The proposed algorithm was validated through simulations in PSCAD on a 10-DGU islanded microgrid.
  • Stable Voltage and Frequency: Simulations showed that the microgrid maintained stable voltage and frequency during DGU plug-in/out events, load changes, and even when simulating significant phase shifts in DGU clocks.
  • Minimal Voltage Deviations: During dynamic events like DGU connection or load changes, voltage deviations from reference signals were small and quickly compensated.
  • Low Harmonic Distortion: The Total Harmonic Distortion (THD) of voltages remained below 5%, meeting IEEE standards.
  • Robustness to Topology Changes: The system demonstrated stability even when the network topology changed, leading to the formation of independent sub-islands.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Simulation-Based Validation: While the results are validated through simulations, real-world experimental validation is a natural next step.
  • Higher-Level Control: The authors suggest future research focusing on coupling these PnP local regulators with a higher control layer for power flow regulation among DGUs.
  • Non-Identical DGUs: The paper considers DGUs with potentially different electrical parameters, but further exploration into extreme parameter variations might be beneficial.
  • Clock Synchronization Impact: While stability is preserved, the paper notes that clock desynchronization affects tracking performance. Future work could explore methods to mitigate these performance impacts.

Summary updated

Abstract

We propose a decentralized control synthesis procedure for stabilizing voltage and frequency in AC Islanded microGrids (ImGs) composed of Distributed Generation Units (DGUs) and loads interconnected through power lines. The presented approach enables Plug-and-Play (PnP) operations, meaning that DGUs can be added or removed without compromising the overall ImG stability. The main feature of our approach is that the proposed design algorithm is line-independent. This implies that (i) the synthesis of each local controller requires only the parameters of the corresponding DGU and not the model of power lines connecting neighboring DGUs, and (ii) whenever a new DGU is plugged in, DGUs physically coupled with it do not have to retune their regulators because of the new power line connected to them. Moreover, we formally prove that stabilizing local controllers can be always computed, independently of the electrical parameters. Theoretical results are validated by simulating in PSCAD the behavior of a 10-DGUs ImG.
BibTeX
@misc{tucci2017scalable,
  author = {Michele Tucci and Giancarlo Ferrari-Trecate},
  title = {{A scalable line-independent design algorithm for voltage and frequency control in AC islanded microgrids}},
  year = {2017},
  eprint = {1703.02336},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1703.02336},
}
Figure