A scalable and flexible hybrid energy storage system design and implementation

Younghyun Kim, Jason Koh, Qing Xie, Yanzhi Wang, Naehyuck Chang, Massoud PedramJournal of Power Sources 2014 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents a novel hybrid energy storage system (HESS) design that integrates lead-acid batteries, lithium-ion batteries, and supercapacitors. The system's key innovation lies in its scalable architecture and a sophisticated control methodology that optimizes energy efficiency and flexibility for load leveling applications, demonstrating significant improvements over traditional energy storage systems.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Reliable and economical electricity supply is crucial, especially with the increasing integration of renewable energy sources and the growing demand for electricity in various applications like electric vehicles and residential power. Traditional energy storage systems (ESS) often face limitations in cost, efficiency, and lifespan due to the inherent characteristics of a single storage technology. While hybrid ESS (HESS) offer a promising solution by combining different storage technologies to leverage their strengths and mitigate weaknesses, designing and controlling such systems to achieve optimal performance is complex. This paper addresses the challenge of creating a practical, scalable, and flexible HESS that can effectively manage energy for applications like household load leveling, overcoming the limitations of homogeneous ESS.

Methods

The authors propose a HESS architecture based on a "single shared bus" topology, which offers good scalability and flexibility. This architecture connects multiple energy storage modules (supercapacitor, lithium-ion battery, and lead-acid battery) to a common DC bus. The system is modular, with each energy storage bank comprising a homogeneous array of storage elements and a bidirectional charger.

Key methodological contributions include:

  • Modular Design: The HESS is built from five distinct modules (AC converter, CTI capacitor, supercapacitor bank, lithium-ion battery bank, and lead-acid battery bank) connected via a Charge Transfer Interconnect (CTI) for energy transfer and a Control Area Network (CAN) for communication. This modularity allows for easy scalability and replacement of components.
  • Hybridization Architecture: A single shared DC bus architecture is chosen for its scalability and flexibility, allowing for a higher degree of freedom in energy flow management compared to passive parallel or cascaded converter architectures.
  • Novel Control Methodology: A sophisticated system-level control strategy is implemented. This involves a system controller that determines optimal CTI voltage and current for each energy storage bank to maximize energy efficiency and reliability. This is complemented by individual bidirectional chargers within each bank that manage their respective energy storage elements.
  • Cascaded Control Loop: To address CTI voltage fluctuations, a cascade control loop is employed. The AC-DC rectifier from the grid acts as a voltage-regulating component, while other power converters operate in current-regulating mode, ensuring stable CTI voltage and efficient energy transfer.
  • Charge Management Policy: A priority-based charge management policy is developed for load leveling. It prioritizes supercapacitors, then lithium-ion batteries, and finally lead-acid batteries for charging/discharging based on their cycle efficiency and lifespan, aiming to minimize power loss and optimize overall system efficiency.

Datasets

The paper does not explicitly mention training datasets. However, it utilizes a publicly available hourly average residential load profile from Southern California Edison territory [50] for system design and analysis. The experimental results are based on measurements from the implemented prototype.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • HESS as a System-Level Design Problem: The paper emphasizes that achieving the benefits of HESS goes beyond just combining different storage technologies; it requires a holistic system-level design approach, particularly in control and management.
  • Scalability and Flexibility through Architecture: The single shared bus architecture and modular design are crucial for enabling scalability and flexibility, allowing the system to adapt to different storage configurations and future expansions.
  • Optimizing for Efficiency: The control strategy's focus on power converter efficiency and the cycle efficiency of individual storage elements is key to achieving overall system efficiency, especially in dynamic load conditions.
  • Priority-Based Management: The hierarchical approach to energy management (supercapacitor > Li-ion > lead-acid) is a practical way to extend the lifespan of more sensitive battery technologies while leveraging the strengths of each component.
  • CTI Voltage as a Dynamic Control Parameter: Recognizing that CTI voltage can be dynamically adjusted to improve conversion efficiency under varying load conditions is a significant insight for optimizing HESS performance.

Key Results

  • Successful Load Leveling: The implemented HESS successfully maintained a fixed grid power input of 40 W, independent of load power fluctuations ranging from 15 W to 220 W.
  • Dynamic CTI Voltage Control: The system demonstrated the ability to dynamically adjust the CTI voltage within a 6-36 V range to achieve optimal conversion efficiency under different load conditions.
  • Efficient Power Conversion: The bidirectional charger exhibited good power converter efficiency, closely matching datasheet specifications, with efficiency dropping as the voltage difference between input and output increased.
  • Demonstrated HESS Operation: Experimental results validated the effectiveness of the proposed control method and charge management policy, showing the sequential charging and discharging of different energy storage banks as dictated by the load demand.
  • Prototype Implementation: A functional 300 W HESS prototype with 6.3 Wh supercapacitors, 115 Wh lithium-ion batteries, and 163 Wh lead-acid batteries was successfully designed and implemented.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Capacity Determination Not Covered: The paper explicitly states that the focus is on system architecture and control methods, not on the determination of optimal energy storage capacity.
  • Cost Optimization: While the paper mentions cost as a factor, the primary focus is on performance and efficiency. Future work could explore optimizing the HESS design for economic feasibility and faster return on investment (ROI).
  • Limited Scope of Storage Technologies: The prototype uses three specific storage technologies. Future work could explore incorporating other types of energy storage elements.
  • Experimental Validation: While experimental results are presented, further validation with more extensive and diverse load profiles and operating conditions would be beneficial.
  • Advanced Control Algorithms: The paper suggests that the charge management policy could be further improved by considering factors like energy storage element cost. Exploring more advanced optimization algorithms for control decisions is a potential avenue for future research.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{kim2014scalable,
  author = {Younghyun Kim and Jason Koh and Qing Xie and Yanzhi Wang and Naehyuck Chang and Massoud Pedram},
  title = {{A scalable and flexible hybrid energy storage system design and implementation}},
  journal = {Journal of Power Sources},
  year = {2014},
  doi = {10.1016/j.jpowsour.2013.12.102},
}
Figure