A saturation hypothesis to explain both enhanced and impaired learning with enhanced plasticity

Td Barbara Nguyen-Vu, Grace Zhao, Subhaneil Lahiri, Rhea R. Kimpo, Hanmi Lee, Surya Ganguli, Carla J. Shatz, Jennifer L RaymondeLife 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

Enhanced synaptic plasticity, long thought to directly improve learning, can paradoxically lead to impaired learning. This study reveals that the history of neural activity, specifically synapse saturation, determines whether enhanced plasticity aids or hinders learning. This "saturation hypothesis" explains why the same genetically modified mice could either learn better or worse depending on their recent experiences.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The prevailing wisdom in neuroscience is that increasing synaptic plasticity—the ability of neural connections to strengthen or weaken—should directly translate to better learning and memory. However, a puzzling observation has emerged: in some cases, enhanced synaptic plasticity has been linked to impaired learning. This creates a conceptual dilemma: how can a mechanism designed to facilitate learning sometimes have the opposite effect? This paper aims to resolve this paradox by investigating the factors that dictate whether enhanced plasticity leads to improved or detrimental learning outcomes.

Methods

The researchers used a combination of behavioral experiments in mice and computational modeling.

  • Behavioral Experiments: They studied mice with genetically enhanced cerebellar Long-Term Depression (LTD), a form of synaptic plasticity, due to a double knockout (DKO) of MHCI H2-K<sup>b</sup>/H2-D<sup>b</sup> genes. These mice were trained on an oculomotor learning task (vestibulo-ocular reflex, VOR). They also used optogenetic stimulation to artificially induce LTD in wild-type (WT) mice. Crucially, they manipulated the recent history of experience through different pre-training paradigms.
  • Computational Modeling: They developed and analyzed various synaptic models with history-dependent learning rules. These models aimed to capture the observed behavioral phenomena, particularly the interplay between enhanced plasticity, saturation, and the effects of pre-training. They compared simple binary synapse models with more complex serial and multistate models.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • History Matters: The same mice with enhanced plasticity showed impaired learning under certain conditions and enhanced learning under others, all dependent on their recent activity history. This highlights that plasticity isn't a static property but is dynamically influenced by experience.
  • Synaptic Saturation is Key: The core idea is that synapses can become "saturated" – pushed into a state where they can no longer undergo further changes (LTD in this case). This saturation, especially in mice with a lower threshold for plasticity (like the DKO mice), can prevent them from learning, even if their overall plasticity capacity is high.
  • Pre-training as a "Desaturator": Specific pre-training (VOR-decrease training) could "desaturate" the synapses in DKO mice, restoring their ability to learn and even revealing enhanced learning compared to WT mice. Conversely, pre-training that saturated synapses impaired learning in WT mice.
  • Model Complexity is Necessary: Simple models of synaptic plasticity (e.g., binary synapses) failed to explain the observed results. More complex models incorporating history-dependent rules, "stubborn" synaptic states, and exponential decay of transition probabilities were required to recapitulate the experimental findings.

Key Results

  • Mice with enhanced cerebellar LTD (DKO mice) showed specific deficits in VOR-increase learning, but only under high-frequency training conditions.
  • Optogenetic stimulation to induce LTD in WT mice mimicked the learning impairment seen in DKO mice, supporting the saturation hypothesis.
  • VOR-decrease pre-training rescued the learning deficit in DKO mice and revealed enhanced learning compared to WT mice. This pre-training impaired learning in WT mice.
  • Computational models incorporating history-dependent plasticity and saturation successfully predicted these complex behavioral outcomes, while simpler models did not.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Experimental Validation of Synaptic Physiology: While the behavioral and modeling results strongly support the saturation hypothesis, direct experimental measurement of synaptic state changes (e.g., saturation levels) in vivo during learning is a crucial next step.
  • Generalizability: The study focused on cerebellar LTD and oculomotor learning. Future work should explore whether this saturation hypothesis applies to other forms of plasticity (LTP) and in different brain regions and learning tasks.
  • Mechanism of VOR-decrease Learning: The exact cellular mechanisms underlying VOR-decrease learning are not fully understood, and the models primarily captured its effect on reversing LTD saturation rather than its intrinsic mechanism.
  • Clinical Implications: The authors suggest that understanding these principles could guide the development of treatments for conditions involving impaired learning, potentially combining plasticity enhancers with strategies to control neural activity or using behavioral therapies to "desaturate" synapses.

Summary updated

Abstract

Across many studies, animals with enhanced synaptic plasticity exhibit <i>either</i> enhanced or impaired learning, raising a conceptual puzzle: how enhanced plasticity can yield opposite learning outcomes? Here, we show that the recent history of experience can determine whether mice with enhanced plasticity exhibit enhanced or impaired learning in response to the same training. Mice with enhanced cerebellar LTD, due to double knockout (DKO) of MHCI H2-K<sup>b</sup>/H2-D<sup>b</sup> (<i>K<sup>b</sup>D<sup>b-/-</sup></i>), exhibited oculomotor learning deficits. However, the same mice exhibited enhanced learning after appropriate pre-training. Theoretical analysis revealed that synapses with history-dependent learning rules could recapitulate the data, and suggested that saturation may be a key factor limiting the ability of enhanced plasticity to enhance learning. Optogenetic stimulation designed to saturate LTD produced the same impairment in WT as observed in DKO mice. Overall, our results suggest that the recent history of activity and the threshold for synaptic plasticity conspire to effect divergent learning outcomes.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{nguyenvu2017saturation,
  author = {TD Barbara Nguyen-Vu and Grace Zhao and Subhaneil Lahiri and Rhea R. Kimpo and Hanmi Lee and Surya Ganguli and Carla J. Shatz and Jennifer L Raymond},
  title = {{A saturation hypothesis to explain both enhanced and impaired learning with enhanced plasticity}},
  booktitle = {eLife},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.7554/elife.20147},
}
Figure