A Sampling-Based Heuristic for Tree Search Applied to Grammar Induction

AAAI 1998

TL;DR

This paper introduces SAGE, a novel sampling-based heuristic for tree search that intelligently explores complex state spaces by adaptively focusing on promising alternatives. It demonstrates strong performance on the challenging problem of grammar induction, particularly in the context of the Abbadingo DFA learning competition.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Many problems in artificial intelligence and operations research involve searching through vast state spaces to find optimal solutions. Traditional methods like genetic algorithms or greedy randomized adaptive search procedures (GRASP) rely on designing effective "operators" to transform existing solutions into new ones, which often requires a deep understanding of the problem's structure and a well-defined neighborhood. However, for problems where solutions are constructed procedurally (e.g., building a grammar step-by-step), defining such operators can be extremely difficult. This difficulty can lead to search algorithms getting trapped in suboptimal solutions (local optima) due to the "epistasis" of the problem representation, where components are highly interdependent.

While traditional AI backtracking search algorithms can handle these problems, they often struggle with combinatorial explosion without problem-specific heuristics. These heuristics, however, typically don't leverage information about the distribution of solutions within the search space itself. This paper addresses the gap of developing a search algorithm that can efficiently explore tree-like or DAG-like state spaces, particularly when procedural construction is involved, by adaptively learning and exploiting the distribution of solutions without requiring explicit problem-specific heuristics for local search.

Methods

SAGE is a population-based, stochastic search algorithm designed for tree and DAG search. Its core innovation lies in its sampling-based heuristic for evaluating internal nodes in the search tree. Instead of relying on predefined local search operators, SAGE estimates the "goodness" of a partial solution (an internal node) by performing random sampling: it constructs a complete solution by making random choices from that node downwards until a leaf is reached, and then evaluates the quality of this complete solution.

The algorithm operates iteratively with two phases:

  1. Construction Phase: Each processing element in SAGE's population constructs a candidate solution by randomly selecting choices from the current partial solution.
  2. Competition Phase: Processing elements compare the scores of their constructed solutions. Promising alternatives (nodes in the search tree) are allocated more "representatives" (processing elements) in the next iteration, effectively focusing the search. This competition is managed on a mesh-like architecture, allowing for efficient parallelization.

A key aspect is the "commitment degree," which represents the current depth of search in the tree. SAGE adaptively manages this degree to balance exploration (searching wider) and exploitation (focusing on promising paths). It uses a diversity measure of the population to decide when to increase the commitment degree, preventing the search from becoming too narrow or too broad.

Datasets

The paper evaluates SAGE on the Abbadingo DFA learning competition dataset. This dataset consists of a series of increasingly difficult problems for learning Deterministic Finite Automata (DFAs). The problems vary in the size of the target DFA and the sparsity of the training data. The authors also generated their own problem instances using a similar procedure to the Abbadingo challenges for comparative analysis.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Exploiting Solution Distribution: The central idea is that the distribution of solution quality within the search space itself is valuable information that can guide search. SAGE leverages this by sampling and then focusing on promising areas.
  • Procedural Construction Friendly: SAGE is particularly well-suited for problems where solutions are built incrementally, as it doesn't rely on predefined neighborhood structures or transformation operators that are hard to design for such problems.
  • Adaptive Focus: The competition phase, where promising alternatives gain more "representatives," allows SAGE to adaptively focus its search without explicit problem-specific knowledge for local search.
  • Parallelism: The population-based nature of SAGE makes it amenable to efficient parallel implementation on distributed systems.
  • Commitment Degree Management: The adaptive control of the commitment degree (search depth) is crucial for balancing exploration and exploitation, preventing premature convergence or excessive breadth.

Key Results

SAGE was a successful participant in the Abbadingo DFA learning competition, solving several difficult problems (1, 2, 4, 5, and 7). It demonstrated competitive performance, especially on problems with moderate complexity. For instance, it solved problem 7, which was at the edge of what SAGE could manage with its standard configuration.

In comparative analysis against the Trakhtenbrot-Barzdin (T-B) algorithm and an evidence-driven heuristic (EDH), SAGE generally outperformed T-B. While EDH, a greedy algorithm, was faster, SAGE showed comparable or better performance, particularly when using larger population sizes. However, for very large target DFAs, SAGE's computational resource requirements increased significantly, suggesting the need for problem-specific heuristics to improve scalability.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that SAGE's performance is heavily dependent on the construction procedure. If the procedure doesn't provide reliable information about solution quality, SAGE's performance suffers. They note that designing an appropriate construction procedure often requires experimentation.

A key limitation identified is SAGE's scalability for very large state spaces. As the size of the target DFA increases, SAGE requires substantial computational resources. The authors suggest that introducing problem-specific heuristics into the construction procedure would be necessary for SAGE to address this scaling issue effectively. Future work could explore more sophisticated ways to manage the commitment degree and further optimize the competition phase for even better performance and scalability.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{1998sampling,
  title = {{A Sampling-Based Heuristic for Tree Search Applied to Grammar Induction}},
  booktitle = {AAAI Conference on Artificial Intelligence},
  year = {1998},
}
Figure