A rolling analysis on the prediction of value at risk with multivariate GARCH and copula

Yang Bai, Yibo Dang, Cheolwoo Park, Taewook LeeCommunications 2018 · DOI

Abstract

Risk management has become a cornerstone of financial operations over the last two decades. Value at Risk (VaR), introduced by JP Morgan in 1995, remains the most prevalent quantitative measure for evaluating risk across portfolio management and asset allocation. This paper investigates a one-day-ahead VaR prediction framework for high-dimensional portfolios using a combination of multivariate GARCH models and copula methods. By employing a rolling analysis to capture the instability of parameter estimates, the study demonstrates a robust and flexible modeling process that accounts for asset interactions and non-normal return distributions.

Introduction

In modern finance, the ability to accurately predict potential losses is vital. Value at Risk (VaR) serves as the industry standard for this purpose, yet traditional calculation methods often fall short. Most conventional models rely on the assumption of a multivariate normal distribution—the belief that asset returns follow a symmetric bell curve and maintain linear relationships.

However, empirical evidence suggests that financial markets are far more complex, characterized by "fat tails" (extreme events occurring more frequently than predicted) and asymmetric dependencies (the tendency for assets to correlate more strongly during market downturns than during upturns). Furthermore, as portfolios increase in size, the computational complexity of modeling these relationships grows exponentially. This paper addresses these challenges by proposing a hybrid framework that decouples individual asset volatility from collective dependency structures.

Methodology

The researchers utilize a sequential modeling process designed to handle the nuances of high-dimensional financial data:

1. Marginal Time-Series Modeling

To capture the mean and volatility of individual assets, the study employs ARMA-GARCH models. The authors compare three specific multivariate GARCH specifications:

  • Constant Conditional Correlation (CCC): Assumes static relationships between assets.
  • Dynamic Conditional Correlation (DCC): Allows asset relationships to evolve over time.
  • Generalized Orthogonal GARCH (GO-GARCH): Utilizes a linear mapping to uncorrelated components, offering significant computational efficiency for high-dimensional portfolios.

2. Dependency Modeling via Copulas

The core innovation of this framework is the use of copulas to model the joint distribution of assets independently of their marginal behaviors. This allows for the use of Skewed-$t$ distributions for individual assets to capture fat tails while using specific copula structures for the group:

  • Elliptical Copulas: Including Gaussian and $t$ copulas.
  • Archimedean Copulas: Such as Gumbel and Clayton, which are capable of capturing asymmetric tail dependence.
  • Nested Archimedean Copulas (NAC): A hierarchical approach used to manage portfolios with five or more assets, preventing mathematical instability as dimensionality increases.

3. Rolling Analysis and Backtesting

Rather than relying on a static fit, the authors implement a "moving window" analysis (typically 250 or 500 days). This approach updates the model parameters daily, ensuring the VaR prediction remains responsive to shifting market regimes. The models are then validated using Unconditional and Conditional Coverage tests to ensure the predicted VaR accurately reflects realized losses at a 95% confidence level.

Data and Empirical Results

The study tested various portfolios constructed from NYSE and NASDAQ historical data (2005–2016), ranging from 3-dimensional (e.g., AMZN, Ford, Shell) to 9-dimensional sets (including Google, Microsoft, and Goldman Sachs).

Key Insights

  • The Advantage of Decoupling: The ability to separate the modeling of individual asset risk from the joint dependency structure proved essential for capturing the "lower tail dependence"—the phenomenon where assets crash in unison.
  • Efficiency of GO-GARCH: For high-dimensional data, GO-GARCH emerged as the most balanced choice, providing a sophisticated view of changing covariances without prohibitive computational costs.
  • Dimensionality and Conservatism: While the models were highly accurate for 3D and 5D portfolios, they exhibited a conservative bias in 9D portfolios. In these cases, the models often predicted higher risk than was realized (exceedance rates of 1.5% to 4.5% against a 5% target). While this "safe" bias is preferable to underestimating risk, it suggests that copula efficiency may slightly diminish as more assets are added.

Conclusion

This research demonstrates that a hybrid GARCH-Copula framework, supported by a rolling window analysis, provides a flexible and robust tool for modern risk managers. By moving beyond the limitations of multivariate normality, the model better accounts for the realities of market volatility and asset correlation. Future work will focus on automating the selection of optimal copulas and refining the moving window size to better balance historical data with sudden market shocks.

Summary updated

Abstract

Risk management has been a crucial part of the daily operations of the financial industry over the past two decades. Value at Risk (VaR), a quantitative measure introduced by JP Morgan in 1995, is the most popular and simplest quantitative measure of risk. VaR has been widely applied to the risk evaluation over all types of financial activities, including portfolio management and asset allocation. This paper uses the implementations of multivariate GARCH models and copula methods to illustrate the performance of a one-day-ahead VaR prediction modeling process for high-dimensional portfolios. Many factors, such as the interaction among included assets, are included in the modeling process. Additionally, empirical data analyses and backtesting results are demonstrated through a rolling analysis, which help capture the instability of parameter estimates. We find that our way of modeling is relatively robust and flexible.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{bai2018rolling,
  author = {Yang Bai and Yibo Dang and Cheolwoo Park and Taewook Lee},
  title = {{A rolling analysis on the prediction of value at risk with multivariate GARCH and copula}},
  booktitle = {Communications},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.29220/csam.2018.25.6.605},
}
Figure