A Roadmap for End-to-End Privacy and Security in Generative AI

Tobin South, Jules Drean, Abhishek Singh, Guy Zyskind, Robert Mahari, Vivek Sharma, Praneeth Vepakomma, Lalana Kagal, Srinivas Devadas, Alex Pentland2024 · DOI

Abstract

End-to-end security and privacy are increasingly urgent as generative AI is deployed in organizations and integrated into our daily lives. Many partial solutions exist across the research and practice landscape, yet none provide an end-to-end solution for generative AI. This paper provides a comprehensive framework for achieving end-to-end security and privacy in generative AI (GenAI), mapping out the complex AI supply chain and demonstrating how a modular "patchwork" of cryptographic and statistical tools can protect data from both malicious insiders and external attackers.

Introduction

The current state of generative AI is often described as a security "wild west." Models are frequently trained on undisclosed datasets, hosted by providers with full visibility into user interactions, and deployed without verifiable guarantees of computational integrity. As GenAI moves into high-stakes fields like healthcare, education, and legal services, several critical risks emerge:

  1. Data Leakage: Sensitive training data or user prompts (e.g., medical records) could be exposed via breaches or "memorized" and regurgitated by the model.
  2. Intellectual Property Theft: Proprietary model weights represent massive investments that require protection from external hackers and cloud providers alike.
  3. Lack of Trust: Users currently lack the means to verify that a provider is running the specific model claimed or that training data excludes copyrighted material.

A Dual-Axis Security Framework

To address these challenges, the authors propose a dual-axis classification system to organize security defenses based on attacker models and desired security properties.

Figure 1: Mapping security properties and attacker types to technical solutions.

Attacker Models

  • Internal Attackers: Entities within the pipeline, such as a malicious cloud host, who have visibility into raw data or can tamper with code.
  • External Attackers: Users with "black box" access via APIs who attempt to extract information through adversarial prompting.

Security Properties

  • Privacy: Ensuring that sensitive information, including training data, model weights, and user prompts, does not leak.
  • Verifiability: Providing cryptographic proof that AI pipeline steps were executed correctly and with integrity.

The Generative AI Pipeline

The roadmap maps existing technologies—including Homomorphic Encryption (HE), Trusted Execution Environments (TEEs), Federated Learning (FL), and Zero-Knowledge Machine Learning (ZK-ML)—to specific stages of the AI supply chain.

Figure 2: The generative AI pipeline and its constituent computational steps.

The pipeline consists of five primary stages: Data Collection, Pre-training, Fine-tuning, Inference, and Retrieval. Each stage presents unique vulnerabilities that require specific cryptographic or statistical interventions.

Key Insights and Technical Trade-offs

A central theme of the paper is the necessity of a "patchwork" approach. No single technology provides a complete solution. For instance, a secure system might employ Federated Learning for data collection, Differential Privacy during training to prevent memorization, and TEEs for secure inference.

The authors distinguish between privacy and verifiability, noting that a system can be private yet unverifiable (a "black box"), or verifiable yet public. End-to-end security requires both. Furthermore, while tools like Differential Privacy effectively mitigate external extraction risks, they do not protect against internal threats. For internal defense, hardware isolation (TEEs) or advanced encryption (HE/MPC) is required.

Performance and Implementation

  • Confidential Computing (TEEs): Identified as a high-performance solution for internal privacy, though it lacks the absolute mathematical guarantees of Multi-Party Computation (MPC).
  • Zero-Knowledge Proofs: Considered the gold standard for verifiability, allowing providers to prove model execution without revealing secret weights.
  • Overhead: A significant hurdle remains the performance overhead; methods like Homomorphic Encryption are still orders of magnitude slower than standard computation.

Limitations and Future Directions

While many tools are nearing production readiness, significant engineering challenges remain. Deploying massive models in secure enclaves and overcoming the latency of cryptographic methods are primary bottlenecks. Additionally, this framework focuses on the "plumbing" of data security and computational integrity rather than model alignment issues like bias or hallucinations.

As "agentic" AI systems capable of taking autonomous actions become more prevalent, these cryptographic guardrails will transition from optional features to mandatory requirements for societal integration.

Summary updated

Abstract

End-to-end security and privacy are increasingly urgent as generative AI is deployed in organizations and integrated into our daily lives. Many partial solutions exist across the research and practice landscape, yet none provide an end-to-end solution for generative AI.
BibTeX
@misc{south2024roadmap,
  author = {Tobin South and Jules Drean and Abhishek Singh and Guy Zyskind and Robert Mahari and Vivek Sharma and Praneeth Vepakomma and Lalana Kagal and Srinivas Devadas and Alex Pentland},
  title = {{A Roadmap for End-to-End Privacy and Security in Generative AI}},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.21428/e4baedd9.9af67664},
}
Figure