A Review on Recent Treatment Technology for Herbicide Atrazine in Contaminated Environment

Huijun He, Yongpan Liu, Shaohong You, Jie Liu, He Xiao, Zhi‐Hong TuInternational Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This review synthesizes recent advancements in technologies for removing the persistent herbicide atrazine from contaminated environments. It highlights the strengths and weaknesses of physicochemical, chemical, and biological methods, with a particular focus on promising integrated approaches like plant-microbial remediation and material-microbial combined technologies.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Atrazine is a widely used herbicide known for its effectiveness and low cost. However, its stable chemical structure leads to long persistence in the environment, posing significant risks to ecosystems and human health, including endocrine disruption and potential carcinogenicity. Existing treatment methods often struggle with complete removal, high costs, or secondary pollution, necessitating a comprehensive review of emerging and established technologies for its effective remediation.

Methods

This paper provides a systematic review of atrazine treatment technologies, categorizing them into four main areas:

  • Physicochemical Methods: Primarily focusing on adsorption using materials like activated carbon and biochar, as well as other functional materials like bentonite and zeolites.
  • Chemical Methods: Including oxidation-reduction reactions, specifically detailing the Fenton/Fenton-like method, ozone oxidation, and sulfate radical oxidation. Photocatalytic methods are also discussed.
  • Biological Methods: Covering microbial remediation (using bacteria and fungi) and phytoremediation (using plants).
  • Material-Microbial Integrated Technologies: This section highlights novel approaches that combine the properties of materials with the degradation capabilities of microorganisms, such as immobilized biocatalysts and composite biomaterials.

The review analyzes the advantages, disadvantages, and degradation mechanisms of each method.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Atrazine's Persistence is a Major Challenge: The inherent stability of atrazine makes its complete degradation difficult, requiring robust and efficient treatment strategies.
  • No Single Solution is Perfect: Each treatment category (physicochemical, chemical, biological) has its own set of limitations, from cost and efficiency to environmental impact.
  • Synergy is Key: The most promising future directions lie in combining different technologies to leverage their complementary strengths.
  • Material-Microbial Integration is a Hot Topic: Combining the physical/chemical properties of materials with the biological degradation power of microorganisms offers a powerful avenue for enhanced atrazine removal.
  • Plant-Microbial Remediation Offers a Green Approach: This method leverages the natural interactions between plants and microbes for a more environmentally friendly solution.

Key Results

The paper doesn't present new experimental results but rather synthesizes findings from numerous studies. Key takeaways from the reviewed literature include:

  • Adsorption: Activated carbon and biochar show good adsorption capacity, with some modified materials achieving removal rates over 90%. However, activated carbon can be costly and difficult to regenerate, while biochar shows promise as a sustainable alternative.
  • Chemical Oxidation: Fenton/Fenton-like methods can achieve high removal efficiencies (e.g., 98%), but are often limited by pH ranges and sludge generation. Ozone oxidation, especially with catalysts, can also be highly effective. Sulfate radical oxidation shows strong potential for degrading refractory pollutants.
  • Biological Methods: Microbial remediation can achieve complete degradation of atrazine (e.g., 100 mg/L in 15h), but is sensitive to environmental factors. Phytoremediation offers an eco-friendly option, with some plants showing significant atrazine accumulation and degradation.
  • Integrated Approaches: Plant-microbial remediation has shown removal rates as high as 95.7%. Material-microbial combined technologies, using immobilized microorganisms, have demonstrated removal rates close to 100% and good reusability.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations and suggest future research directions:

  • Functional Materials: Future research should focus on developing functional materials with excellent removal efficiency and minimal environmental impact.
  • Synergistic Treatment: The paper strongly advocates for the synergistic treatment of two or more technologies to achieve ideal atrazine removal, given its recalcitrant nature.
  • Microbial Remediation Limitations: Further research is needed to identify microorganisms with better performance and environmental tolerance, and to explore genetic engineering for improved degradation properties.
  • Phytoremediation Challenges: Screening suitable degraded plants, shortening degradation cycles, and addressing post-treatment plant disposal are crucial.
  • Material-Microbial Technology: Developing mild preparation conditions, selecting suitable entrapment media, and creating new biomaterials with low environmental impact and high recyclability are key for this emerging field.

Summary updated

Abstract

Atrazine is a kind of triazine herbicide that is widely used for weed control due to its good weeding effect and low price. The study of atrazine removal from the environment is of great significance due to the stable structure, difficult degradation, long residence time in environment, and toxicity on the organism and human beings. Therefore, a number of processing technologies are developed and widely employed for atrazine degradation, such as adsorption, photochemical catalysis, biodegradation, etc. In this article, with our previous research work, the progresses of researches about the treatment technology of atrazine are systematically reviewed, which includes the four main aspects of physicochemical, chemical, biological, and material-microbial-integrated aspects. The advantages and disadvantages of various methods are summarized and the degradation mechanisms are also evaluated. Specially, recent advanced technologies, both plant-microbial remediation and the material-microbial-integrated method, have been highlighted on atrazine degradation. Among them, the plant-microbial remediation is based on the combined system of soil-plant-microbes, and the material-microbial-integrated method is based on the synergistic effect of materials and microorganisms. Additionally, future research needs to focus on the excellent removal effect and low environmental impact of functional materials, and the coordination processing of two or more technologies for atrazine removal is also highlighted.
BibTeX
@article{he2019review,
  author = {Huijun He and Yongpan Liu and Shaohong You and Jie Liu and He Xiao and Zhi‐Hong Tu},
  title = {{A Review on Recent Treatment Technology for Herbicide Atrazine in Contaminated Environment}},
  journal = {International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.3390/ijerph16245129},
}
Figure