A review of the UK and British Channel Islands practical tidal stream energy resource

Daniel Coles, Athanasios Angeloudis, Deborah Greaves, Gordon D. Hastie, Matthew Lewis, Lucas Mackie, J.l. McNAUGHTON, Jon Miles, Simon P. Neill, Matthew D. Piggott, Denise Risch, Beth E. Scott, Carol Sparling, Tim Stallard, Philipp R. Thies, Stuart Walker, David White, Richard Willden, Benjamin J. WilliamsonProceedings of the Royal Society A Mathematical Physical and Engineering Sciences 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This review assesses the practical potential of tidal stream energy in the UK and British Channel Islands, confirming a significant resource of 34 TWh/year. It highlights that achieving cost competitiveness with conventional energy sources by 2031 hinges on deploying 124 MW of new capacity, which is projected to drive down costs to £150/MWh. The predictable nature of tidal power offers additional system-wide benefits, and current environmental impacts appear minimal, though further research is needed as arrays scale up.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The UK is committed to achieving net-zero greenhouse gas emissions by 2050, necessitating a significant shift away from fossil fuels towards renewable energy sources. While wind and solar power are key components of this transition, they are variable and intermittent, posing challenges for grid stability and requiring substantial balancing efforts. Tidal stream energy, with its predictable and cyclic generation pattern, offers a potential solution to complement these variable sources and reduce overall system costs. However, a comprehensive understanding of its practical resource, economic viability, and environmental implications is crucial for its successful integration into the energy mix. This paper addresses the need for a critical, multi-faceted assessment of tidal stream energy's contribution to the UK's future energy landscape, moving beyond theoretical potential to practical application.

Methods

This review synthesizes existing research and data to provide a comprehensive assessment. Key methodologies and approaches discussed include:

  • Hydrodynamic Modelling: The paper references the use of 2D hydrodynamic models (e.g., Flow Development-2D) to simulate tidal flows and estimate energy extraction potential at various sites. It also discusses the limitations of generic models and the need for site-specific, high-fidelity modelling.
  • Resource Estimation: The review critically examines national-scale practical resource estimates, such as those from The Carbon Trust, and discusses the impact of economic, environmental, regulatory, and social constraints on these estimates.
  • Economic Analysis: The paper delves into the Levelized Cost of Energy (LCoE) for tidal stream projects, analyzing the influence of technology learning rates, economies of scale, and economies of volume. It compares these projections with those of other energy technologies.
  • Environmental Impact Assessment: The review synthesizes findings from studies on hydro and sediment dynamics, collision risk with marine life, and habitat change and displacement. It also considers noise pollution from turbine operations.
  • System Integration Analysis: The paper explores the role of tidal stream energy in grid balancing, the challenges of grid connection in remote areas, and the potential for integration with energy storage solutions.

Datasets

The paper does not introduce new datasets but relies on and synthesizes data from a wide range of existing sources, including:

  • Operational Project Data: Information from operational tidal stream projects, such as MeyGen 1A, is used to inform cost reduction trajectories and reliability assessments.
  • Government Reports and Studies: Data from reports by the Department for Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy (BEIS), the Carbon Trust, and the Offshore Renewable Energy Catapult (OREC) are extensively cited.
  • Academic Research: Findings from numerous peer-reviewed studies on hydrodynamic modelling, environmental impacts, and economic assessments are integrated.
  • Industry Data: Cost data provided by tidal stream project developers is utilized in LCoE projections.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Predictability is a Game-Changer: The inherent predictability of tidal streams, unlike wind and solar, offers significant advantages for grid balancing and can lead to substantial whole-system cost savings, which are often not captured in standard LCoE calculations.
  • Cost Reduction is Crucial and Achievable: While currently expensive, tidal stream energy has a steep cost reduction trajectory. Deploying a modest 124 MW of new capacity by 2031 is projected to make it cost-competitive with technologies like CCGTs and biomass, driven by learning rates and economies of scale.
  • Environmental Impacts are Manageable (So Far): Current monitoring of single devices and small arrays shows no evidence of significant detrimental environmental impacts, such as collisions or major habitat disruption. However, the impacts of large-scale arrays require ongoing monitoring and research.
  • Grid Integration is a Major Hurdle: The best tidal stream resources are often in remote areas with limited grid capacity, necessitating significant infrastructure upgrades and careful spatial planning.
  • Policy Support is Essential: The historical reliance on government subsidies (ROCs and CfDs) highlights the critical role of policy in enabling the deployment and cost reduction of tidal stream energy.

Key Results

  • Practical Resource: The UK and British Channel Islands have a practical tidal stream energy resource of approximately 34 TWh/year, equivalent to 11% of the UK's current annual electricity demand.
  • Cost Competitiveness: Installing 124 MW of prospective capacity by 2031 is estimated to reduce the LCoE to below £150/MWh, making it competitive with CCGTs, biomass, and anaerobic digestion.
  • Capacity Requirements: Achieving the 34 TWh/year resource requires approximately 11.5 GW of installed capacity, with significant portions allocated to the Pentland Firth (6 GW) and Channel Islands (2 GW).
  • Environmental Impact: No collisions between marine animals and turbines have been detected to date. Impacts on stratification and predator-prey interactions from large arrays are projected to be an order of magnitude less than those from climate change.
  • Whole-System Cost Savings: Diversifying a 100% wind portfolio with tidal stream and wave energy could reduce balancing expenditure by approximately £700 million/year.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Model Fidelity and Validation: The review highlights the need for updated national-scale practical resource studies using high-fidelity, site-specific hydrodynamic modelling and improved validation with field measurements.
  • Constraint Sensitivity: Further research is needed to quantify the sensitivity of the practical resource to various constraints (economic, environmental, regulatory, social) and to identify opportunities for constraint retirement.
  • Whole-System Cost Quantification: A more robust quantification of whole-system costs and enhanced LCoE (eLCoE) for tidal stream is necessary to fully understand its value in the energy system and compare it accurately with other technologies.
  • Environmental Monitoring of Large Arrays: While current impacts are minimal, ongoing field measurements are crucial to establish the impacts of scaling up tidal stream arrays and to validate predictive models, especially in areas where modelling accuracy is limited.
  • Policy Support: The paper implicitly suggests that continued and potentially ring-fenced policy support, such as through CfD auctions, is vital for tidal stream to achieve its cost reduction potential and contribute to the UK's energy targets.

Summary updated

Abstract

This review provides a critical, multi-faceted assessment of the practical contribution tidal stream energy can make to the UK and British Channel Islands future energy mix. Evidence is presented that broadly supports the latest national-scale practical resource estimate, of 34 TWh/year, equivalent to 11% of the UK's current annual electricity demand. The size of the practical resource depends in part on the economic competitiveness of projects. In the UK, 124 MW of prospective tidal stream capacity is currently eligible to bid for subsidy support (MeyGen 1C, 80 MW; PTEC, 30 MW; and Morlais, 14 MW). It is estimated that the installation of this 124 MW would serve to drive down the levelized cost of energy (LCoE), through learning, from its current level of around <mml:math xmlns:mml="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML"><mml:mrow><mml:mn>240</mml:mn> <mml:mo> </mml:mo> <mml:mrow><mml:mtext>£</mml:mtext></mml:mrow> <mml:mrow><mml:mo>/</mml:mo></mml:mrow> <mml:mrow><mml:mtext>MWh</mml:mtext></mml:mrow> </mml:mrow> </mml:math> to below <mml:math xmlns:mml="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML"><mml:mrow><mml:mn>150</mml:mn> <mml:mo> </mml:mo> <mml:mrow><mml:mtext>£</mml:mtext></mml:mrow> <mml:mrow><mml:mo>/</mml:mo></mml:mrow> <mml:mrow><mml:mtext>MWh</mml:mtext></mml:mrow> </mml:mrow> </mml:math> , based on a mid-range technology learning rate of 17%. Doing so would make tidal stream cost competitive with technologies such as combined cycle gas turbines, biomass and anaerobic digestion. Installing this 124 MW by 2031 would put tidal stream on a trajectory to install the estimated 11.5 GW needed to generate 34 TWh/year by 2050. The cyclic, predictable nature of tidal stream power shows potential to provide additional, whole-system cost benefits. These include reductions in balancing expenditure that are not considered in conventional LCoE estimates. The practical resource is also dependent on environmental constraints. To date, no collisions between animals and turbines have been detected, and only small changes in habitat have been measured. The impacts of large arrays on stratification and predator-prey interaction are projected to be an order of magnitude less than those from climate change, highlighting opportunities for risk retirement. Ongoing field measurements will be important as arrays scale up, given the uncertainty in some environmental and ecological impact models. Based on the findings presented in this review, we recommend that an updated national-scale practical resource study is undertaken that implements high-fidelity, site-specific modelling, with improved model validation from the wide range of field measurements that are now available from the major sites. Quantifying the sensitivity of the practical resource to constraints will be important to establish opportunities for constraint retirement. Quantification of whole-system benefits is necessary to fully understand the value of tidal stream in the energy system.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{coles2021review,
  author = {Daniel Coles and Athanasios Angeloudis and Deborah Greaves and Gordon D. Hastie and Matthew Lewis and Lucas Mackie and J.L. McNAUGHTON and Jon Miles and Simon P. Neill and Matthew D. Piggott and Denise Risch and Beth E. Scott and Carol Sparling and Tim Stallard and Philipp R. Thies and Stuart Walker and David White and Richard Willden and Benjamin J. Williamson},
  title = {{A review of the UK and British Channel Islands practical tidal stream energy resource}},
  booktitle = {Proceedings of the Royal Society A Mathematical Physical and Engineering Sciences},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1098/rspa.2021.0469},
}
Figure