A review of the effects of unilateral hearing loss on spatial hearing

Daniel P. Kumpik, Andrew J. KingHearing 2018 · DOI

TL;DR

This review explores how the brain adapts to unilateral hearing loss, demonstrating remarkable plasticity in spatial hearing. Even with one deaf ear, the auditory system can re-weight sensory cues and learn new mappings to maintain sound localization, offering hope for improved rehabilitation strategies.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Our ability to pinpoint the location of sounds is crucial for navigating our environment, identifying threats, and communicating effectively. This spatial hearing relies heavily on comparing the subtle differences in sound arriving at our two ears – known as binaural cues (interaural time differences, ITDs, and interaural level differences, ILDs). However, what happens when one ear doesn't hear as well as the other? Unilateral or asymmetric hearing loss presents a significant challenge to this binaural processing, potentially leading to difficulties in sound localization and understanding speech in noisy environments (spatial release from masking). This paper addresses the critical question of how the auditory system copes with this imbalance, particularly focusing on the brain's adaptive mechanisms, both during development and in adulthood, and their implications for hearing rehabilitation.

Methods

This paper is a review, synthesizing findings from numerous experimental studies. The primary methods discussed involve:

  • Animal Models: Studies using animals (e.g., ferrets, cats, barn owls) where hearing loss is experimentally induced (e.g., by earplugging) during critical developmental periods. This allows for controlled investigation of the long-term effects of early-life hearing loss and the brain's subsequent reorganization.
  • Human Psychoacoustics: Behavioral experiments with human participants, including those with natural unilateral hearing loss and those with temporary induced hearing loss (e.g., using earplugs). These studies assess performance on tasks like sound localization and spatial release from masking under various conditions.
  • Electrophysiology: Recording neural activity in different parts of the auditory system (e.g., auditory cortex, inferior colliculus) in animals to understand how neuronal responses change in response to altered auditory input.
  • Computational Modeling: While not explicitly detailed as a method in the review, the discussion of binaural cues and their processing implies underlying computational models of auditory perception.

The novelty lies in the focus on the adaptive strategies of the auditory system, moving beyond simply describing deficits to understanding how the brain compensates for hearing loss.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper reviews existing research that likely utilized various datasets of auditory stimuli (pure tones, broadband noise, speech) and head-related transfer functions (HRTFs) for simulating spatial acoustics.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Developmental Vulnerability and Plasticity: Unilateral hearing loss during development can lead to lasting deficits by weakening the representation of the deprived ear. However, this same period is also characterized by significant plasticity, allowing the brain to adapt.
  • Cue Reweighting: The auditory system doesn't just "give up" when binaural cues are compromised. It actively reweights the importance of different cues, often increasing reliance on spectral cues (which are less affected by head shadowing) from the intact ear for horizontal localization.
  • Adult Brain Adaptability: While developmental plasticity is profound, the adult brain also exhibits remarkable adaptability. Through training, individuals with unilateral hearing loss can learn to better utilize available cues and even remap binaural information.
  • "Lazy Ear" (Amblyaudia): Persistent deficits in binaural processing can occur even after hearing is restored, a phenomenon akin to amblyopia in vision, highlighting the critical role of early auditory experience.
  • Clinical Implications: The brain's capacity for adaptation has significant implications for developing more effective rehabilitation strategies for individuals with unilateral hearing loss, potentially involving targeted training.

Key Results

  • Compensatory Localization: Humans with single-sided deafness can often localize sounds accurately in azimuth, suggesting they rely more heavily on spectral cues from their hearing ear.
  • Animal Model Adaptation: Ferrets raised with unilateral earplugs showed significant adaptation in sound localization, both behaviorally and at the neural level in the auditory cortex. They could maintain accurate localization even with the earplug in place.
  • Training Benefits: Adult humans with induced unilateral hearing loss can improve their sound localization performance with training, demonstrating that plasticity is not limited to development.
  • Cue Remapping: In some cases, adaptation involves not just reweighting cues but also learning new mappings between altered binaural cues (ILDs/ITDs) and spatial locations.
  • BMLD and BILD: While not a primary focus of the review, the paper references the importance of binaural masking level differences (BMLD) and binaural intelligibility level differences (BILD) for speech perception in noise, which are often impaired by unilateral hearing loss.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Generalizability: The authors acknowledge that further research is needed to determine if the observed plasticity generalizes to more realistic listening conditions (e.g., complex soundscapes) and other tasks, such as spatial unmasking.
  • Timing of Intervention: The review highlights the importance of the timing of interventions for hearing loss, particularly in children, as developmental plasticity is crucial.
  • Individual Variability: There is considerable individual variability in the capacity to adapt, suggesting that personalized rehabilitation strategies may be necessary.
  • Hearing Aid Design: The paper touches upon the challenges of hearing aid design, particularly for behind-the-ear devices, in preserving spectral cues that are vital for spatial hearing. Future work could focus on optimizing hearing aid algorithms to better support spatial processing.
  • Therapeutic Translation: Translating these findings into practical, effective clinical rehabilitation programs for hearing-impaired listeners remains a key area for future work. This includes developing training protocols that are easy to use and confer broad generalization.

Summary updated

Abstract

The capacity of the auditory system to extract spatial information relies principally on the detection and interpretation of binaural cues, i.e., differences in the time of arrival or level of the sound between the two ears. In this review, we consider the effects of unilateral or asymmetric hearing loss on spatial hearing, with a focus on the adaptive changes in the brain that may help to compensate for an imbalance in input between the ears. Unilateral hearing loss during development weakens the brain's representation of the deprived ear, and this may outlast the restoration of function in that ear and therefore impair performance on tasks such as sound localization and spatial release from masking that rely on binaural processing. However, loss of hearing in one ear also triggers a reweighting of the cues used for sound localization, resulting in increased dependence on the spectral cues provided by the other ear for localization in azimuth, as well as adjustments in binaural sensitivity that help to offset the imbalance in inputs between the two ears. These adaptive strategies enable the developing auditory system to compensate to a large degree for asymmetric hearing loss, thereby maintaining accurate sound localization. They can also be leveraged by training following hearing loss in adulthood. Although further research is needed to determine whether this plasticity can generalize to more realistic listening conditions and to other tasks, such as spatial unmasking, the capacity of the auditory system to undergo these adaptive changes has important implications for rehabilitation strategies in the hearing impaired.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{kumpik2018review,
  author = {Daniel P. Kumpik and Andrew J. King},
  title = {{A review of the effects of unilateral hearing loss on spatial hearing}},
  booktitle = {Hearing},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.1016/j.heares.2018.08.003},
}
Figure