A review of structural brain abnormalities in Pallister‐Killian syndrome

Cathryn Poulton, Gareth Baynam, Clarissa G. Yates, Hamid Alinejad‐Rokny, Simon Williams, Helen Wright, Karen Woodward, Soruba Sivamoorthy, Joanne Peverall, Peter Shipman, David Ravine, John Beilby, Julian Ik‐Tsen HengMolecular 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper reviews structural brain abnormalities in Pallister-Killian Syndrome (PKS), a rare genetic disorder. By analyzing two new cases and a literature review of 93 patients, the study reinforces the strong association between PKS and brain malformations, highlighting ventricular abnormalities, corpus callosum issues, and cerebral atrophy as most common. The findings aim to improve diagnostic suspicion and prognostic understanding for this complex syndrome.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Pallister-Killian Syndrome (PKS) is a rare genetic disorder characterized by a specific chromosomal abnormality (tetrasomy of chromosome 12p). While neurological defects are known to be associated with PKS, the full spectrum of structural brain abnormalities and their prognostic implications for neurodevelopmental outcomes have not been comprehensively quantified. Clinicians may face challenges in diagnosing PKS, especially in individuals who survive infancy, due to the mosaic nature of the genetic abnormality. This paper aims to address this gap by providing a detailed review of brain abnormalities in PKS, combining new case data with a systematic literature review, to better inform diagnosis and prognosis.

Methods

The study employed a multi-pronged approach:

  • Case Studies: Two new patients diagnosed with PKS were described, detailing their clinical presentations and neuroimaging findings.
  • Cytogenetic Analysis: Standard cytogenetic protocols, including G-banded chromosome analysis and Fluorescence In Situ Hybridization (FISH), were used to confirm the PKS diagnosis and assess mosaicism.
  • Chromosomal Microarray: For one proband, chromosomal microarray was performed to detect copy number variations.
  • Neuroimaging: Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI) and Computed Tomography (CT) scans were utilized to visualize brain structures.
  • Literature Review: A comprehensive review of published literature was conducted to identify cases of PKS with reported intracranial scans. This involved surveying over 150 reports to gather data on 93 cases with available imaging.

Datasets

The study utilized two primary sources of data:

  • Newly Reported Cases: Data from two patients with PKS, including their clinical histories, genetic analyses, and neuroimaging results.
  • Literature-Derived Dataset: A compilation of 93 previously reported cases of PKS with documented intracranial scans, extracted from published literature. This dataset served as the basis for the literature review and statistical analysis of abnormality frequencies.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Strong Association Confirmed: The study strongly reinforces the link between PKS and structural brain abnormalities, with a significant majority of affected individuals showing some form of malformation.
  • Common Abnormality Patterns: Ventricular abnormalities, corpus callosum issues, and cerebral atrophy emerge as the most frequently observed structural brain anomalies in PKS patients.
  • Mosaicism Challenges Diagnosis: The mosaic nature of the 12p aneuploidy can make diagnosis difficult, often requiring specialized techniques like interphase FISH to detect low-level mosaicism, as seen in one of the probands.
  • Potential for Prognostication: Identifying specific brain abnormalities may offer clues for predicting neurodevelopmental outcomes and seizure risk, even in cases where seizures are not yet evident.
  • Genetic Basis for Malformations: The paper begins to map minimal critical regions on chromosome 12p and identify candidate genes that may underlie specific brain abnormalities observed in PKS, suggesting a diverse neurogenetic basis.

Key Results

  • Out of 93 reviewed PKS cases with intracranial scans, 77.41% (72/93) exhibited structural brain abnormalities.
  • The most frequently reported abnormalities were:
  • Ventricular abnormalities: 45.83% (33/72)
    • Cerebral atrophy: 29.17% (21/72)
    • Corpus callosum abnormalities: 25.00% (18/72)
  • Less frequent abnormalities included macrocephaly (12.5%; 9/72) and polymicrogyria (4.17%; 3/72).
  • The study identified specific minimal critical regions on chromosome 12p associated with atrophy, corpus callosum defects, and macrocephaly, implicating various candidate genes.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Detection Bias: The authors acknowledge that the literature review may be subject to detection bias, meaning certain abnormalities might be over or under-represented due to reporting practices.
  • Mosaicism Detection: The difficulty in detecting low-level mosaicism for 12p aneuploidy is highlighted as a potential reason for the rarity of some reported associations.
  • Unusual Features: One proband presented with unusual features (cystic disease of multiple organs, epibulbar dermoids, hypoplastic optic discs) not typically associated with PKS. Further identification of such cases is needed to establish stronger associations.
  • Future Directions: The paper suggests that a better understanding of the functions of 12p genes within the identified critical regions will be crucial for elucidating their direct roles in brain development and how gene dosage contributes to neuropathological features in PKS. Neuroimaging is recommended as an informative tool, even in PKS cases without apparent seizures.

Summary updated

Abstract

Our study reinforces the association between brain abnormalities and PKS, and documents a diverse neurogenetic basis for structural brain abnormalities and impaired function in children diagnosed with this rare disorder.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{poulton2017review,
  author = {Cathryn Poulton and Gareth Baynam and Clarissa G. Yates and Hamid Alinejad‐Rokny and Simon Williams and Helen Wright and Karen Woodward and Soruba Sivamoorthy and Joanne Peverall and Peter Shipman and David Ravine and John Beilby and Julian Ik‐Tsen Heng},
  title = {{A review of structural brain abnormalities in Pallister‐Killian syndrome}},
  booktitle = {Molecular},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.1002/mgg3.351},
}
Figure