A Review of Smart Materials for the Boost of Soft Actuators, Soft Sensors, and Robotics Applications

Yufei Hao, Shixin Zhang, Bin Fang, Fuchun Sun, Huaping Liu, Haiyuan LiChinese 2022 · DOI

Abstract

With the advance of smart material science, robotics is evolving from rigid robots to soft robots. Compared to rigid robots, soft robots can safely interact with the environment, easily navigate in unstructured fields, and be minimized to operate in narrow spaces, owing to the new actuation and sensing technologies developed by the smart materials. In this review, different actuation and sensing technologies based on different smart materials are analyzed and summarized. According to the driving or feedback signals, actuators are categorized into electrically responsive, thermally responsive, magnetically responsive, and photoresponsive actuators; sensors are categorized into resistive, capacitive, magnetic, and optical waveguide sensors. The advantages and disadvantages of these technologies are compared, and their potential applications in robotics are presented.

The Soft Robotics Revolution

Traditional robots are typically constructed from rigid links and gears, powered by bulky motors and monitored by stiff encoders. While precise, these "hard" robots struggle with safety in human-centric environments and cannot easily navigate narrow or unstructured gaps. Soft robotics offers a solution by utilizing materials that don't just support a robot but are the robot—materials that can deform, stretch, and "feel" external stimuli. The challenge lies in selecting the right smart material for the job, as each comes with significant trade-offs in speed, force, and sensitivity.

Classification of Smart Materials

The authors provide a systematic classification of smart materials based on their functional roles as either actuators (muscles) or sensors (nerves).

Soft Actuators (The Muscles)

Actuators are categorized by their driving signals:

  • Electrically Responsive: Includes Dielectric Elastomer Actuators (DEAs), HASEL actuators, and Ionic Polymer-Metal Composites (IPMCs). These are valued for their high speed and biomimetic potential.
  • Thermally Responsive: Includes Shape Memory Polymers (SMPs), Liquid Crystal Elastomers (LCEs), and Shape Memory Alloys (SMAs).
  • Magnetically Responsive: Composites mixing magnetic particles with soft silicone, ideal for untethered control.
  • Photoresponsive: Polymers embedded with light-sensitive fillers (e.g., azobenzene).
Examples of electrically responsive soft actuators, including dielectric elastomers and liquid dielectric reservoirs.

Soft Sensors (The Nerves)

Sensors are categorized by their feedback mechanisms:

  • Resistive: Using liquid metals or carbon nanotubes to measure changes in resistance during deformation.
  • Capacitive: Measuring changes in the overlapping area or distance between flexible electrodes.
  • Magnetic: Utilizing Hall sensors to detect the movement of embedded magnets.
  • Optical Waveguide: Using light intensity or refractive index changes in flexible fibers to detect strain.

Key Insights and Performance Comparison

A major advancement in sensor design is the use of microstructuring. Solid elastomers are often too incompressible for high-sensitivity pressure sensing; adding microstructures (pyramids, pores, or wavy patterns) to the dielectric layer allows the material to compress more easily, significantly boosting sensitivity.

Performance metrics vary significantly across material classes:

  • Speed: Dielectric Elastomers (DE) are the fastest actuators, with response times < 200 µs, making them ideal for biomimetic flapping. Liquid Crystal Elastomers (LCE) are much slower, often taking > 60 seconds to respond.
  • Force and Energy: Shape Memory Alloys (SMA) offer the highest energy density among thermal actuators.
  • Sensing Range: Resistive sensors are best for measuring large strains, while capacitive sensors are preferred for applications requiring low hysteresis and high repeatability.
Thermally responsive actuators and their applications in soft robotic locomotion and gripping.

Limitations and Future Outlook

Despite the "boost" from smart materials, several hurdles remain for site-ready applications:

  • Safety and Power: Many high-performance electrical actuators (like DEAs) require thousands of volts, raising safety concerns for human-robot interaction.
  • Thermal Lag: Thermally responsive materials are limited by slow cooling rates, restricting their cycle frequency.
  • Environmental Interference: Capacitive and magnetic sensors are highly sensitive to external electromagnetic noise.
  • Stability: Most of these materials are still in the laboratory phase. Long-term stability, repeatability, and commercial-scale fabrication are the next major frontiers for the field.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract With the advance of smart material science, robotics is evolving from rigid robots to soft robots. Compared to rigid robots, soft robots can safely interact with the environment, easily navigate in unstructured fields, and be minimized to operate in narrow spaces, owning to the new actuation and sensing technologies developed by the smart materials. In the review, different actuation and sensing technologies based on different smart materials are analyzed and summarized. According to the driving or feedback signals, actuators are categorized into electrically responsive actuators, thermally responsive actuators, magnetically responsive actuators, and photoresponsive actuators; sensors are categorized into resistive sensors, capacitive sensors, magnetic sensors, and optical waveguide sensors. After introducing the principle and several robotic prototypes of some typical materials in each category of the actuators and sensors. The advantages and disadvantages of the actuators and sensors are compared based on the categories, and their potential applications in robotics are also presented.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{hao2022review,
  author = {Yufei Hao and Shixin Zhang and Bin Fang and Fuchun Sun and Huaping Liu and Haiyuan Li},
  title = {{A Review of Smart Materials for the Boost of Soft Actuators, Soft Sensors, and Robotics Applications}},
  booktitle = {Chinese},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1186/s10033-022-00707-2},
}
Figure