A Review of fMRI Affective Processing Paradigms Used in the Neurobiological Study of Posttraumatic Stress Disorder

Alyson Negreira, Chadi G. AbdallahChronic 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This review categorizes and synthesizes fMRI studies on affective processing in Posttraumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD), highlighting how different experimental paradigms reveal inconsistent neural patterns. The authors propose that understanding these inconsistencies is crucial for refining neurobiological models of PTSD and developing effective treatments.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Posttraumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD) is a complex and debilitating mental health condition. While its symptoms are well-documented, the underlying neurobiological mechanisms, particularly those related to how individuals with PTSD process emotions and trauma-related information, remain poorly understood. For decades, researchers have used neuroimaging techniques like fMRI to investigate these mechanisms, but the findings across studies are often inconsistent. This inconsistency makes it difficult to build a cohesive understanding of PTSD's neurobiology and to develop targeted treatments. This paper aims to address this by systematically reviewing and organizing the various fMRI paradigms used to study affective processing in PTSD, in hopes of explaining the observed heterogeneity in findings and identifying more robust patterns.

Methods

The authors conducted a selective review of task-based fMRI studies on affective processing in adult individuals with PTSD. They identified studies using keywords related to PTSD, neuroimaging, and emotion. To organize the vast literature, they developed a heuristic framework that categorizes the experimental paradigms into three main types:

  1. Symptom Provocation Paradigms: These aim to elicit re-experiencing symptoms by using stimuli directly related to the traumatic event, such as personalized scripts, images, sounds, or smells.
  2. Conscious Trauma-Unrelated Stimuli Paradigms: These use standardized, non-trauma-related stimuli (like emotion faces or pictures) to explore general emotional processing.
  3. Unconscious Trauma-Related and Unrelated Paradigms: These present affectively laden stimuli outside of conscious awareness, using techniques like affective priming or backward masking, to assess automatic emotional responses.

For each category, the review summarizes the common methodological structures, experimental aims, and reported neural activation patterns. The findings are then compared to the traditional "functional neurocircuitry model" (FNM) of PTSD.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper is a review of existing literature, not an empirical study with its own dataset.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Paradigm Matters: The way researchers probe affective processing in PTSD significantly influences the observed brain activity. Different paradigms tap into distinct neural systems and cognitive processes, leading to varied results.
  • Amygdala Hyperactivation is Robust (Under Specific Conditions): Unconscious presentation paradigms consistently show amygdala hyperactivation in individuals with PTSD compared to control groups. This suggests the amygdala's role in automatic, non-conscious processing of emotional stimuli is a more reliable finding.
  • The Traditional Model is Incomplete: The traditional functional neurocircuitry model (FNM) of PTSD, which posits hyperactive amygdala and hypoactive medial prefrontal cortex (mPFC), is not consistently supported across all paradigms. The heterogeneity of findings suggests the neurobiology of PTSD is more complex than this model captures.
  • Heterogeneity is Multifaceted: The inconsistencies in findings are likely due to a combination of factors, including:
  • Biological Factors: Differences in the intensity and nature of the traumatic event experienced by participants.
  • Analytic Factors: Variations in statistical approaches, such as the choice between whole-brain versus region-of-interest (ROI) analyses, and the statistical thresholds used.
  • Unconscious Processing as a Key Area: Paradigms that bypass conscious awareness appear particularly effective at revealing differences in neural responses related to PTSD, especially concerning the amygdala.

Key Results

The review found that:

  • Symptom Provocation Paradigms: Showed a pattern of dorsal anterior cingulate cortex (dACC) hyperactivation and vmPFC hypoactivation in individuals with PTSD. However, findings for other regions were inconsistent.
  • Conscious Trauma-Unrelated Stimuli Paradigms: Consistently revealed vmPFC and rostral anterior cingulate cortex (rACC) deactivation, and amygdala hyperactivation in individuals with PTSD.
  • Unconscious Presentation Paradigms: Demonstrated the most consistent finding of amygdala hyperactivation in individuals with PTSD compared to control groups.

Across all paradigms, the authors noted a "paucity of reported hippocampal findings," which is interesting given the hippocampus's role in memory and fear extinction.

Limitations and Future Work

Limitations:

  • Scope of Review: The review narrowly focuses on affective processing paradigms and does not include studies using cognitive paradigms or those involving participants with mild traumatic brain injury or dissociative subtypes of PTSD.
  • Reliance on Existing Meta-Analyses: The review's findings are partly based on existing meta-analyses, which may have their own limitations.
  • FNM as a Framework: Using the FNM as the primary framework might limit the interpretation of findings that fall outside its scope.
  • Methodological Variability: The review acknowledges that differences in study design, comparison groups, and statistical analysis contribute to the heterogeneity of findings.

Future Work:

  • Refine Neurobiological Models: Future research should aim to develop more comprehensive neurobiological models that account for the complexity of PTSD, moving beyond the traditional FNM.
  • Standardize Methodologies: Greater standardization in experimental paradigms, comparison groups, and statistical analysis is needed to improve reproducibility.
  • Explore Analytic Approaches: Future studies should consider moving beyond ROI analyses to explore large-scale distributed networks using techniques like multi-voxel pattern analysis.
  • Investigate Biological and Analytic Factors: Further research is warranted to understand how biological factors (like trauma intensity) and analytic choices (like statistical thresholding) contribute to the observed heterogeneity.
  • Focus on Unconscious Processing: Given its consistent findings, further investigation into unconscious presentation paradigms is recommended.

Summary updated

Abstract

Posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) is a chronic and debilitating psychiatric disorder with a complex clinical presentation. The last two decades have seen a proliferation of literature on the neurobiological mechanisms subserving affective processing in PTSD. The current review will summarize the neuroimaging results of the most common experimental designs used to elucidate the affective signature of PTSD. From this summary, we will provide a heuristic to organize the various paradigms discussed and report neural patterns of activations using this heuristic as a framework. Next, we will compare these results to the traditional functional neurocircuitry model of PTSD and discuss biological and analytic variables which may account for the heterogeneity within this literature. We hope that this approach may elucidate the role of experimental parameters in influencing neuroimaging findings.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{negreira2019review,
  author = {Alyson Negreira and Chadi G. Abdallah},
  title = {{A Review of fMRI Affective Processing Paradigms Used in the Neurobiological Study of Posttraumatic Stress Disorder}},
  booktitle = {Chronic},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1177/2470547019829035},
}

Loading related content...

Figure