TL;DR
Bifacial solar panels, which capture light from both sides, promise higher energy yields and lower costs, but their performance characterization and simulation are complex. This review synthesizes the current state-of-the-art in measuring and modeling bifacial PV performance, highlighting the challenges and outlining future research directions needed for widespread adoption.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
The solar energy industry is constantly seeking ways to reduce the Levelized Cost of Energy (LCOE) to make solar power more competitive. Bifacial photovoltaic (PV) technology offers a promising avenue for achieving higher energy yields compared to traditional monofacial panels, which could lead to lower BOS (Balance of System) costs and, consequently, a lower LCOE. The International Technology Roadmap for Photovoltaic (ITRPV) predicts a significant increase in the market share of bifacial PV cells and modules. However, the unique nature of bifacial PV, where both sides contribute to power generation, presents significant challenges in accurately characterizing and simulating their performance. Standardized methods for indoor characterization and comprehensive outdoor simulation models are crucial for increasing the bankability of this technology. This paper addresses the need for a consolidated understanding of these characterization and simulation techniques to drive further research and development.
Methods
This review paper provides a comprehensive overview of existing methods for characterizing and simulating bifacial PV performance. It covers:
- Indoor Characterization: Discusses the extension of standard test conditions (STC) to account for rear-side irradiance and the development of draft technical specifications (IEC TS 60904-1-2). It highlights various "modified" characterization methods used by industry and the challenges in ensuring credibility.
- Outdoor Performance Assessment: Explains the necessity of outdoor measurements for real-world performance evaluation and the challenges associated with maintaining standard conditions. It details methods for measuring I-V characteristics, irradiance, and albedo.
- Bifacial PV Performance Modeling: Breaks down the modeling process into three key sub-models:
- Optical Model: Focuses on calculating front- and rear-side irradiance, considering direct, diffuse, and ground-reflected components. It reviews various transposition models and view factor models.
- Electrical Model: Discusses the application of single-diode and two-diode equivalent circuit models, highlighting the complexities of parameter extraction for bifacial cells.
- Thermal Model: Explains how module temperature is calculated, considering ambient temperature, wind speed, and irradiance, and the need for specific models for bifacial modules.
- Simulation Software: Reviews both open-source and commercial software tools used for bifacial PV performance modeling, such as PV_Lib Toolbox, bifacial_radiance, bifacialvf, and PVsyst.
Datasets
Not explicitly discussed in the paper as it is a review paper focusing on methodologies and models. The authors refer to various studies and datasets used in those studies for validation and comparison.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Bifaciality is More Than Just Rear-Side Gain: The performance of bifacial PV is not simply additive. Interactions between front and rear irradiance, optical properties, and module structure significantly influence the overall output.
- Standardization is Crucial: The lack of standardized characterization methods and reporting schemes for bifacial PV leads to inconsistencies and potential overestimation of performance, hindering market adoption. The draft IEC TS 60904-1-2 is a step towards standardization, but requires further refinement.
- Outdoor vs. Indoor: A Trade-off: While indoor measurements offer controlled conditions, they struggle to perfectly replicate real-world complexities like albedo variations and spectral content of rear-side irradiance. Outdoor measurements are essential but face challenges in maintaining standard temperature and irradiance.
- Modeling Complexity: Accurately modeling bifacial PV performance requires sophisticated optical, electrical, and thermal models that account for the interplay of various factors, including module geometry, installation conditions, and environmental variables.
- The "Albedo Effect" is Key: The ground reflectance (albedo) plays a significant role in the rear-side irradiance and overall energy yield of bifacial modules, making its accurate modeling and measurement critical.
- Edge Effects Matter: In bifacial PV systems, modules at the edges of arrays can experience different irradiance conditions compared to those in the middle, a factor that needs to be considered in detailed modeling.
Key Results
- The paper reviews numerous studies demonstrating that bifacial PV modules can achieve higher annual energy yields (e.g., up to 25% gain) compared to monofacial counterparts under optimal outdoor conditions.
- It highlights that current industry practices often use "modified" characterization methods, leading to unverified performance claims.
- The review details various empirical and physics-based models for predicting bifacial PV performance, with varying levels of complexity and accuracy.
- Comparisons between different simulation software (e.g., bifacial_radiance, bifacialvf, PVsyst) and outdoor measurements show agreement within a few percent, indicating the progress in modeling capabilities.
Limitations and Future Work
- Refinement of Standards: The draft IEC TS 60904-1-2 needs further refinement, particularly regarding procedures for single illumination sources to control unwanted illumination and properties of non-reflected materials.
- Inter-lab Comparisons: Essential for assessing reproducibility and identifying areas for improvement in characterization results.
- Simultaneous Illumination: Further experimental investigation is needed for simultaneous illumination measurements using two solar simulators.
- Energy Rating Standard: The development and popularization of an energy rating standard for bifacial PV devices, similar to IEC 61853 for monofacial modules, is vital.
- Spectral Albedo: A standard spectral albedo needs to be defined to accurately characterize rear-side irradiance.
- Physics of Rear-Side Irradiance: Deciphering the physics of rear-side irradiance remains a priority for performance simulation development.
- Real-World Phenomena: Incorporating factors like Potential Induced Degradation (PID) and soiling for different outdoor conditions into simulation models is crucial.
- Parameter Quantification: Thermal losses and other parameters need to be clearly understood and quantified for accurate modeling.
- International Collaboration: Continued international collaboration, such as through the PV Performance Modelling Collaborative (PVPMC), is needed to improve performance modeling and analysis.
Summary updated