A Review of Capability-Based System Development Model Research

Yuting Zhang, Jingyu YangAtlantis 2023 · DOI

Abstract

This paper outlines the development methods of a capability-based system with an emphasis on the key concepts of Capability Based Planning (CBP) and Capability Portfolio Management (CPM) by sorting out related research and application at home and abroad. It provides theoretical support for the construction of the system development model and makes prospects for capability-based system development.

Introduction

The strategic landscape of modern defense has shifted from a predictable "threat-based" model to an "intricate and uncertain" environment. Historically, weapon systems were developed in isolation to counter specific known adversaries, resulting in fragmented capabilities that lacked integration. Today, the focus has moved toward "capability-based" systems, prioritizing strategic goals over specific hardware projects. This transition addresses the gap between high-level vision and practical resource management.

Conceptual Framework for Capability-Based Development

The core of this shift lies in moving from asking "how to finish a project" to "what capabilities are required for strategic success." This involves a top-down approach where requirements are derived from mission objectives rather than bottom-up technical requests.

The conceptual hierarchy of capability-based planning and its transition to integrated joint operations.

As illustrated above, the process integrates requirements acquisition, planning, assessment, and acquisition to support System of Systems (SoS) operations and integrated joint warfare. This framework is driven by external uncertainties, diverse mission tasks, and rapidly evolving technologies.

Methodologies: CBP, CPM, and Mission Engineering

The research identifies three primary frameworks used globally to bridge the gap between strategy and implementation:

  • Capability Based Planning (CBP): A top-down methodology that identifies capability gaps within budget constraints, focusing on the "what" (mission goals) rather than the "how" (specific hardware).
  • Capability Portfolio Management (CPM): An evolution of CBP that applies economic principles, such as Markowitz portfolio theory, to optimize resource allocation by balancing cost, risk, and performance across a portfolio of assets.
  • Mission Engineering (ME): This approach provides operational context, often utilizing a "diamond model" to link Digital Engineering (DE) with Mission Engineering to provide a data-driven decision support system.

Key Insights: The DOTMLPF-P Lens and Economic Influence

A critical insight is the definition of capability through the DOTMLPF-P lens: Doctrine, Organization, Training, Material, Leadership, Personnel, Facilities, and Policy. This holistic view ensures that a system's effectiveness is not limited by its weakest non-material link. Furthermore, the adoption of "Portfolio Management" reflects an economic shift, treating defense assets as investments to maximize "return" (capability) while minimizing risk and cost. Additionally, the paper notes domestic efforts to create "strategic decoding grid platforms" based on industrial management chains (e.g., Huawei’s PPBEA) to translate high-level concepts into manageable control systems.

Analytical Tools and Global Applications

Various organizations have developed quantitative tools to support these frameworks. Notable examples include:

  • RAND Corporation: Developed the Portfolio Analysis Tool (PAT) and Building Blocks To Composite Options Tool (BCOT) to help decision-makers screen and evaluate different capability scenarios.
  • NATO: Released Alternative Analysis (AltA) in 2017 to provide holistic, independent viewpoints for military decision-makers, significantly reducing decision risk.
  • UK Ministry of Defence: The NITEWORKS project successfully modeled tradeoffs between strategic vision and military budgets at both the mission and strategic levels.
The analytical workflow from system engineering modeling to portfolio analysis using BCOT and PAT tools.

This workflow demonstrates how organizations translate system engineering data into actionable portfolio analysis, ensuring that individual system models contribute directly to high-level decision-making through tools like BCOT and PAT.

Conclusion and Future Directions

While significant progress has been made in shifting toward capability-based models, the research identifies three critical areas for future focus:

  1. The Quantification Gap: There is a persistent need for more robust, scientific frameworks to fully quantify integrated planning and management.
  2. Inherent Uncertainty: Models must evolve to account for "inherent uncertainty"—the internal risks and multi-faceted factors within the development process itself—rather than just external threats.
  3. Adversarial Dynamics: Planning must become "robust" and dynamic, explicitly accounting for the adversarial relationship to ensure systems can sustainably accomplish missions against an evolving opponent.

Summary updated

Abstract

This paper outlines the development methods of a capability-based system with an emphasis on the key concepts of Capability Based Planning (CBP) and Capability Portfolio Management (CPM) by sorting out related research and application at home and abroad.It provides theoretical support for the construction of the system development model and makes prospects for capability-based system development.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2023review,
  author = {Yuting Zhang and Jingyu Yang},
  title = {{A Review of Capability-Based System Development Model Research}},
  booktitle = {Atlantis},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.2991/978-94-6463-200-2\_135},
}
Figure