A review of battery energy storage systems for ancillary services in distribution grids: Current status, challenges and future directions

K. Prakash, Muhammad Ali, Md. Nazrul Islam Siddique, Aneesh A. Chand, Nallapaneni Manoj Kumar, Daoyi Dong, H. R. PotaFrontiers in Energy Research 2022 · DOI

Abstract

Battery Energy Storage Systems (BESS) are essential for increasing distribution network performance. Appropriate location, size, and operation of BESS can improve overall network performance. The appropriately scaled and installed BESS helps meet peak energy demand, improve the advantages of integrating renewable and distributed energy sources, improve power quality control, and lower the cost of expanding or re-configuring the distribution networks. This paper investigates the feasibility of BESS for providing short-term and long-term ancillary services in power distribution grids by reviewing the developments and limitations in the last decade (2010–2022).

Introduction

The global transition toward Renewable Energy Sources (RES), such as wind and solar, is a cornerstone of modern climate policy. However, this shift introduces significant technical challenges for power distribution grids. Traditional fossil fuel plants provide mechanical inertia through large spinning turbines, which naturally stabilize the grid. In contrast, inverter-based renewables lack this "shock absorber" effect, leading to increased voltage fluctuations and frequency instability.

As traditional plants retire, Battery Energy Storage Systems (BESS) have emerged as a critical technology to fill the gap. This paper synthesizes a decade of research (2010–2022) to evaluate how BESS can provide the ancillary services necessary to maintain grid stability and resilience.

Systematic Review Methodology

To map the landscape of BESS research, the authors employed a rigorous two-pronged approach. First, using the PRISMA framework, they filtered an initial pool of 941 papers down to 115 high-impact articles. Second, they utilized VOSviewer bibliometric software to visualize the density and interconnection of scholarly work.

Figure 2: Bibliometric analysis showing the four primary research clusters: voltage regulation, peak shaving, power quality, and frequency support.

The analysis identified four dominant research themes: voltage regulators, battery management systems, renewable energy integration, and cost-benefit optimization. This visualization highlights the interdisciplinary nature of the field, linking technical control strategies with economic feasibility.

Categorizing Ancillary Services

A core contribution of this review is the classification of ancillary services into short-term and long-term categories based on their operational timescales.

Figure 3: Classification of ancillary services into short-term (seconds to minutes) and long-term (hours) applications.

Short-Term Services

Short-term services (seconds to minutes) are vital for immediate grid stability. These include:

  • Frequency Regulation: BESS can inject or absorb power in milliseconds, responding far faster than traditional thermal plants.
  • Voltage Support: Maintaining voltage within strict limits to prevent equipment damage.
  • Black Start: Providing the initial power needed to restart a grid after a total blackout.

Long-Term Services

Long-term services (hours) focus on bulk energy management and network reliability:

  • Peak Shaving: Reducing the load on the grid during high-demand periods, which can lower infrastructure expansion costs.
  • Congestion Relief: Managing power flow to prevent transmission lines from exceeding their thermal limits.
  • Power Smoothing: Buffering the intermittent output of wind and solar farms to ensure a steady supply.

Economic Viability and Technical Challenges

The review highlights that while the technology is maturing, economic success depends on more than just hardware.

The "Silent" ROI Killer: Many financial models overlook battery degradation. Factors like depth-of-discharge (DoD) and temperature management are the primary drivers of long-term profitability. Without accurate health modeling, the Return on Investment (ROI) can be significantly overestimated.

Market Maturity: In many regions, regulatory frameworks lag behind technological capabilities. There is often no formal market for "fast" frequency response, meaning BESS operators cannot always monetize the superior speed of their systems. However, leaders like Australia and California have shown that with the right incentives, projects like the Hornsdale Power Reserve can achieve breakeven in as little as two years.

Future Directions

The paper identifies several critical areas for future research:

  1. AI Integration: Utilizing Machine Learning to predict load spikes and renewable generation, allowing for proactive BESS dispatch.
  2. Cybersecurity: As grids become more decentralized and "smart," they become more vulnerable to cyber-attacks, necessitating robust defense protocols.
  3. Advanced Degradation Models: Developing real-time battery health monitors that can be integrated directly into grid control algorithms to maximize lifespan.

By addressing these challenges, BESS can transition from a niche technology to the backbone of a resilient, renewable-powered energy future.

Summary updated

Abstract

Battery Energy Storage Systems (BESS) are essential for increasing distribution network performance. Appropriate location, size, and operation of BESS can improve overall network performance. The appropriately scaled and installed BESS helps meet peak energy demand, improve the advantages of integrating renewable and distributed energy sources, improve power quality control, and lower the cost of expanding or re-configuring the distribution networks. This paper investigates the feasibility of BESS for providing short-term and long-term ancillary services in power distribution grids by reviewing the developments and limitations in the last decade (2010–2022). The short-term ancillary services are reviewed for voltage support, frequency regulation, and black start. The long-term ancillary services are reviewed for peak shaving, congestion relief, and power smoothing. Reviewing short-term ancillary services provides renewable energy operators and researchers with a vast range of recent BESS-based methodologies for fast response services to distribution grids. Long-term ancillary services will provide the distributed network system operators and researchers with current BESS-based bulk-energy methods to improve network reliability and power quality and maximize revenue from renewable energy generation. The review presents a list of energy storage policies and BESS projects worldwide with a cost-benefit analysis. The challenges for deploying BESS in distribution grids recommended solutions for the implementation challenges, and future research directions are also presented.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{prakash2022review,
  author = {K. Prakash and Muhammad Ali and Md. Nazrul Islam Siddique and Aneesh A. Chand and Nallapaneni Manoj Kumar and Daoyi Dong and H. R. Pota},
  title = {{A review of battery energy storage systems for ancillary services in distribution grids: Current status, challenges and future directions}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Energy Research},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3389/fenrg.2022.971704},
}
Figure