A reference frame-based microgrid primary control for ensuring global convergence to a periodic orbit

Xinyuan Jiang, Constantino M. Lagoa, Daning Huang, Yan LiarXiv 2024 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

Modern microgrids, increasingly dominated by inverter-based resources, face significant stability challenges due to the coupling of voltage and phase dynamics. This paper introduces a novel grid-forming control strategy that guarantees global convergence to a stable periodic orbit (AC steady state). By leveraging port-Hamiltonian theory and an extension of shifted passivity, the proposed framework ensures synchronization even when the final frequency deviates from nominal values. The control architecture, implemented in the stationary reference frame, demonstrates superior robustness in low-inertia and highly resistive networks compared to traditional droop control.

Introduction

In modern microgrids dominated by renewable energy, traditional "droop control" often relies on the assumption that voltage amplitudes change much faster than phases, allowing researchers to treat the system like a collection of simple oscillators. However, in reality, these dynamics are coupled. The steady state of an AC microgrid is not a single point; it is a limit cycle (a periodic orbit). Proving that a system will always settle into this orbit from any starting condition—global stability—is notoriously difficult because the final steady-state frequency depends on the load and is not known in advance. Furthermore, standard passivity tools often fail in rotating reference frames due to constant terms that do not dissipate toward a fixed point.

Control Architecture and Methodology

The authors propose a reference frame-based primary control strategy modeled as a Port-Hamiltonian (pH) system. This approach naturally tracks energy flow and dissipation across the entire microgrid, including generators, lines, and loads. Unlike many controllers that operate in a rotating $dq$ frame, this controller uses a second-order integrator in the stationary reference frame, avoiding complex transformations that can obscure stability properties.

Block diagram of the proposed reference frame-based primary control architecture.

As shown in the control diagram above, the system integrates a second-order integrator and swing equations to modulate the inverter output. The control gains are determined using a Semidefinite Program (SDP), ensuring that each Distributed Energy Resource (DER) contributes to the overall passivity of the network. This local tuning approach ensures that if each DER satisfies specific constraints, the entire microgrid remains stable regardless of the network topology.

Stability Analysis: Shifted Passivity

To handle the mathematical difficulty of a rotating system, the authors extend the concept of "shifted passivity"—originally designed for non-zero equilibrium points—to analyze periodic orbits. A key innovation is the "artificial shrinking" trick: the authors introduce a minute amount of artificial dissipation into the equations to prove the orbit is attractive, then demonstrate that the result holds as that artificial term approaches zero. By exploiting the angle symmetry of AC systems, they define a time-varying phase that cancels out rotation, allowing the limit cycle problem to be treated with the rigor of a standard equilibrium problem.

Evaluation and Results

The proposed controller was evaluated using a simulated 12-node microgrid test system featuring four DER units, $R-L$ line models, and ZIP (Constant Impedance, Current, and Power) loads. Key findings include:

  • Global Attractivity: Mathematical proof and simulation confirm that the state space globally converges to the circular limit cycle.
  • Robustness in Resistive Grids: In low-voltage, highly resistive scenarios where standard droop control failed to converge after disturbances, the proposed controller remained stable.
  • Transient Performance: The controller exhibited significantly fewer voltage overshoots during severe events, such as islanding from the main grid or sudden 40% load changes, compared to baseline PI-based droop controls.

Conclusion

This research demonstrates that power system stability does not rely solely on physical inertia. By designing controllers to be "shifted passive," global stability can be guaranteed in inverter-heavy microgrids. Future work will look to extend this framework to unbalanced three-phase systems and incorporate more complex dynamic loads, such as large electric motors, into the port-Hamiltonian model.

Summary updated

Abstract

Power systems with a high penetration of renewable generation are vulnerable to frequency oscillation and voltage instability. Traditionally, the stability of power systems is considered either in terms of local stability or as an angle oscillator synchronization problem with the simplifying assumption that the dynamics of the amplitudes are on much shorter time scales. Without this assumption, however, the steady state being studied is essentially a limit cycle with the convergence of its orbit in question. In this paper, we present a method to analyze the orbital stability of a microgrid and propose a voltage controller for the inverter-interfaced renewable generators. The main hurdle to the problem lies in the constant terms in the rotating internal reference frames of each generator. We extend the shifted passivity of port-Hamiltonian systems to the analysis of limit cycles and prove that, if the system is shifted passive without considering these constant terms, then the periodic orbit is globally attractive. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first global stability result for non-nominal steady states of the microgrid in the full state space, which provides new insights into the synchronization phenomenon where the dissipativity of the system ensures convergence. The proposed controller is verified with a test microgrid, demonstrating its stability and transient smoothness compared to the standard droop control.
BibTeX
@misc{jiang2024reference,
  author = {Xinyuan Jiang and Constantino M. Lagoa and Daning Huang and Yan Li},
  title = {{A reference frame-based microgrid primary control for ensuring global convergence to a periodic orbit}},
  year = {2024},
  eprint = {2408.00916},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2408.00916},
}
Figure