A reduced Landau-de Gennes study for nematic equilibria in three-dimensional prisms

Yucen Han, Baoming Shi, Lei Zhang, Apala MajumdarIMA 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper explores the complex behavior of nematic liquid crystals within three-dimensional prism shapes. By connecting 2D liquid crystal configurations to 3D prism behavior, the authors reveal how to engineer multistability (multiple stable states) in these materials, which is crucial for advanced optical and electronic devices.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Nematic liquid crystals (NLCs) are fascinating materials with applications ranging from displays to AI. Understanding and predicting their behavior in confined geometries is essential for designing new technologies. While 2D models of NLCs are well-studied, extending this understanding to realistic 3D shapes like prisms presents significant challenges. Specifically, this paper aims to bridge the gap between 2D and 3D NLC behavior by investigating how 2D "pathways" on a prism's cross-section can dictate the 3D configurations within the prism. A key challenge is to understand how to control and predict the multiple stable states (multistability) that NLCs can exhibit in 3D, which is vital for applications requiring precise control over their optical properties.

Methods

The authors employ the reduced Landau-de Gennes (rLdG) framework, a powerful theoretical tool for describing NLCs. They focus on 3D prisms with polygonal cross-sections and impose specific boundary conditions on the prism's surfaces. Crucially, the boundary conditions on the top and bottom surfaces are chosen to be "critical points" of the 2D rLdG energy on the polygonal cross-section. This clever choice allows them to directly link 2D "solution landscapes" (maps of stable and unstable configurations) to the 3D behavior within the prism. They utilize a combination of asymptotic analysis (approximating solutions for extreme cases, like very tall or very wide prisms) and numerical simulations to study these configurations. They also introduce a saddle dynamics (SD) method for efficiently computing critical points in these complex 3D systems.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study focuses on theoretical modeling and numerical simulations of idealized geometries rather than experimental data.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Bridging 2D and 3D: The core insight is that 2D "pathways" on the cross-sectional plane of a prism can directly inform and even construct 3D NLC configurations. This provides a powerful way to understand and predict complex 3D behavior.
  • Boundary Conditions as Control: The choice of boundary conditions on the top and bottom surfaces is not arbitrary; it acts as a crucial control knob. By selecting specific 2D critical points as boundary conditions, researchers can influence the 3D states within the prism.
  • Multistability Engineered: The paper demonstrates how to engineer multistability in 3D prisms. By carefully choosing boundary conditions that correspond to different 2D states, multiple stable 3D configurations can arise, offering exciting possibilities for tunable optical properties.
  • Defect Lines as Connectors: Defect lines, where the liquid crystal director is undefined, play a critical role in connecting different stable states and mediating transitions between them within the 3D prism.
  • WORS and BD States: The study highlights the importance of specific 2D configurations like the "Well Order Reconstruction Solution" (WORS) and "BD states" in influencing the 3D behavior, even leading to novel 3D structures like the "D1-WORS-D2" state.

Key Results

  • The authors successfully demonstrate the construction of 3D rLdG critical points by utilizing pathways on 2D solution landscapes.
  • They show that not all 2D pathways translate to 3D critical points, indicating the existence of subtle "compatibility conditions" between boundary states.
  • For cuboid and hexagonal prisms, they illustrate how varying prism dimensions (height and cross-section size) can lead to multistability, with different stable 3D configurations emerging.
  • They observe that certain multi-block 3D critical points, where the prism is effectively divided into regions with distinct 2D configurations, can become unstable as the prism height increases.
  • The study provides a framework for understanding the rich solution landscapes of NLCs in 3D prisms, revealing complex interconnections between stable and unstable states.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Idealized Geometries: The study focuses on prisms with regular polygonal cross-sections. Extending the analysis to more complex, irregular shapes would be a natural next step.
  • Special Temperature: The analysis is simplified by considering a specific temperature where the rLdG energy has a particular form. Generalizing to arbitrary temperatures would introduce more complex eigenvalue structures and require more advanced techniques.
  • Experimental Validation: While the work provides theoretical insights, direct experimental validation of the predicted 3D configurations and multistability would be valuable.
  • "Hidden Compatibility Conditions": The paper raises the question of what determines which 2D pathways lead to 3D critical points. Identifying these "hidden compatibility conditions" is presented as a deep and open question for future research.
  • Broader Applicability: The authors speculate that their findings on multistability and the influence of boundary conditions could be generalized to other types of liquid crystal systems and geometries.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract We model nematic liquid crystal configurations inside three-dimensional prisms, with a polygonal cross-section and Dirichlet boundary conditions on all prism surfaces. We work in a reduced Landau-de Gennes framework, and the Dirichlet conditions on the top and bottom surfaces are special in the sense that they are critical points of the reduced Landau-de Gennes energy on the polygonal cross-section. The choice of the boundary conditions allows us to make a direct correspondence between the three-dimensional Landau-de Gennes critical points and pathways on the two-dimensional Landau-de Gennes solution landscape on the polygonal cross-section. We explore this concept by means of asymptotic analysis and numerical examples, with emphasis on a cuboid and a hexagonal prism, focusing on three-dimensional multistability tailored by two-dimensional solution landscapes.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{han2023reduced,
  author = {Yucen Han and Baoming Shi and Lei Zhang and Apala Majumdar},
  title = {{A reduced Landau-de Gennes study for nematic equilibria in three-dimensional prisms}},
  booktitle = {IMA},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1093/imamat/hxad031},
}
Figure