A Realistic and Integrated Model for Evaluating Offshore Oil Development

Rui Qiu, Zhuochao Li, Qin Zhang, Xin Yao, Shuyi Xie, Qi Liao, Bohong WangJournal of Marine Science and Engineering 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel, data-driven integrated model for evaluating the economic viability of offshore oil development projects. By incorporating modules from subsea to platform systems and using historical data, it provides a more realistic assessment than previous submodule-focused approaches, crucial for navigating the capital-intensive and volatile offshore oil industry.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Developing offshore oil fields is a complex, capital-intensive endeavor fraught with significant risks. Unlike onshore projects, offshore operations face unique challenges including harsh marine environments, complex reservoir characteristics, and the need for extensive infrastructure. Furthermore, the industry is highly susceptible to fluctuating oil prices, making accurate economic evaluation critical for investment decisions. Existing economic evaluation models often focus on specific components of a project rather than providing a holistic view, and many lack validation with actual project data. This paper aims to bridge this gap by developing a comprehensive, data-validated model that accounts for the entire offshore oil development lifecycle and addresses parameter uncertainties.

Methods

The core of this research is the development of a "realistic and integrated evaluation model" for offshore oil development. The methodology involves several key steps:

  • Data Collection and Parameter Screening: Historical project data from various sources (National Bureau of Statistics of China, industry statistics, technical literature) were collected. Key engineering factors influencing investment were identified and screened.
  • Submodule Development via Regression Analysis: The project lifecycle was broken down into several submodules (geological reserve estimation, drilling and completion, underwater production system, platform substructure, platform upper chunk, operation cost). For each submodule, multiple linear regression was employed to establish quantitative relationships between key parameters and costs, using the collected historical data.
  • Integrated Economic Evaluation Model: The submodule models were integrated into a comprehensive economic evaluation framework, culminating in a Net Present Value (NPV) model. This model considers project revenues (oil and gas sales) and expenditures (investment, operation costs, royalties, taxes).
  • Uncertainty Analysis: To account for the inherent uncertainties in offshore projects, Monte Carlo simulation was used. This allows for the assessment of the probability of positive NPV under varying conditions.
  • Sensitivity Analysis: The impact of individual uncertain parameters on the project's economic outcome (specifically NPV) was analyzed to identify the most influential factors.

Datasets

The primary dataset used in this study is based on actual historical project data from offshore oil fields. Specifically, the authors mention drawing from:

  • The National Bureau of Statistics of China.
  • Field practice data.
  • Industry statistics.
  • Technical literature.

This data was used to develop and validate the regression models for each submodule and to perform the uncertainty and sensitivity analyses. The paper does not introduce a new benchmark dataset but rather leverages existing, real-world data to build its model.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Holistic Approach is Crucial: Evaluating offshore oil projects requires a comprehensive model that integrates all stages and components, from subsea infrastructure to platform operations, rather than focusing on isolated submodules.
  • Data-Driven Models Enhance Realism: Using actual historical project data significantly improves the applicability and reliability of the economic evaluation model, ensuring input parameters have realistic values and ranges.
  • Recovery Factor and Oil Price Dominate Economics: The study highlights that the recovery factor and oil price are the most critical drivers of economic benefits in offshore oil development. This underscores the importance of optimizing extraction techniques and closely monitoring market prices.
  • Uncertainty Management is Key: Given the inherent volatility and risks, robust uncertainty analysis (like Monte Carlo simulation) is essential for providing decision-makers with a probabilistic understanding of project outcomes.
  • Low Oil Prices Demand Strategic Focus: In low oil price environments, enhancing reservoir recovery and minimizing construction investment become paramount strategies for ensuring project viability.

Key Results

  • Deterministic Breakeven Oil Price: For the case study project in Bohai Bay, the deterministic breakeven oil price (where NPV = 0) was calculated to be 40.59 USD/bbl.
  • Sensitivity Analysis Findings: The recovery factor (50.80%) and oil price (24.00%) were identified as the two most significant contributors to NPV variation, collectively accounting for over 75% of the uncertainty.
  • Impact of Oil Price on NPV Probability:
    • At an oil price of 70 USD/bbl, the probability of a positive NPV is as high as 97.39%, even with parameter uncertainties.
  • At an oil price of 30 USD/bbl, the probability of a positive NPV drops to 23.98%.
  • Parameter Uncertainty Effects: Under low oil prices, increased parameter uncertainty can favorably impact the economic evaluation by increasing the probability of a positive NPV. However, as oil prices rise, the influence of parameter uncertainty diminishes.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Data Dependency: The accuracy and reliability of the model are heavily dependent on the quantity and quality of historical project data. For different types of offshore oil fields, the submodule models may need to be updated and refitted with specific historical data.
  • Generalizability: While the model is presented as general, its application to vastly different offshore environments or project types might require further adaptation.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that for different types of offshore oil fields, the model submodules should be updated according to their specific characteristics, and cost calculation models should be fitted based on specific historical data to enhance applicability. Further research could also explore incorporating more sophisticated uncertainty modeling techniques or expanding the scope to include environmental and social impact assessments.

Summary updated

Abstract

With the rising consumption of oil resources, major oil companies around the world have increasingly engaged in offshore oil exploration and development, and offshore oil resources have accounted for an increasing proportion. Offshore oil engineering projects are capital intensive, and the development of offshore oil fields faces a tough battle, especially in a period of low oil prices. Thus, a comprehensive evaluation model is highly needed to help assess economic benefits and provide meaningful and valuable information for operators and investors to make sensible decisions. This study firstly proposed a realistic and integrated evaluation model for offshore oil development based on actual historical project data. This evaluation model incorporated modules from the underwater system to the platform system and processes from oil reservoir extraction to oil, gas and water treatment. The uncertain parameters in the evaluation process are dealt with by sensitivity analysis and Monte Carlo simulation. The proposed model is applied to a typical offshore oil development project in Bohai Bay, China. The results reveal that the recovery factor and oil price have the greatest impact on the economic benefits. In the case of deterministic analysis, the breakeven oil price of the project is 40.59 USD/bbl. After considering the uncertainty of project parameters, the higher the oil price, the greater the probability of NPV > 0. When the oil price is higher than 70 USD/bbl, even with uncertain project parameters, the probability of NPV > 0 can still be as high as 97.39%.
BibTeX
@article{qiu2022realistic,
  author = {Rui Qiu and Zhuochao Li and Qin Zhang and Xin Yao and Shuyi Xie and Qi Liao and Bohong Wang},
  title = {{A Realistic and Integrated Model for Evaluating Offshore Oil Development}},
  journal = {Journal of Marine Science and Engineering},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/jmse10081155},
}
Figure