A Ranking Model of Proximal and Structural Text Retrieval Based on Region Algebra

Katsuya MasudaACL 2003

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel ranking model for information retrieval that leverages "region algebra" to understand the structure and relationships within documents, going beyond simple keyword matching. By automatically annotating documents with structural and semantic tags, their model can retrieve relevant information even when exact keyword matches fail, demonstrating improved robustness and effectiveness for complex queries.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Searching through large collections of documents, especially in specialized fields like biomedicine, presents a significant challenge. Traditional keyword-based retrieval systems often struggle because they don't account for the relationships between words or the inherent structure of documents (e.g., titles, sentences, authors). Users may miss relevant information because keywords appear in different contexts or are not explicitly linked in a way the system can understand. While some models attempt to incorporate structure, they often lack robustness, retrieving only exact matches. This paper aims to bridge this gap by developing a more flexible and powerful retrieval model that can handle both structural and proximal (nearby) relationships between terms within documents.

Methods

The core of this paper is the application of a "ranked region algebra" for information retrieval. Region algebra, as described, represents text extents (regions) using start and end positions and defines operators to capture relationships like containment (e.g., a sentence within a paragraph) and ordering. The authors extend this by proposing a ranking model that decomposes structured queries into subqueries. The relevance of a document to the overall query is then represented as a vector of relevance measures for these subqueries.

Key methodological contributions include:

  • Automatic Annotation: Documents are automatically annotated with structural tags (like "title," "sentence") and semantic tags using taggers. This is crucial for applying structured queries to unannotated corpora.
  • Ranked Region Algebra: The paper utilizes and extends region algebra operators to define complex queries that specify both the content (words) and structure (e.g., a word within a title).
  • Vector-Based Relevance: Instead of a single score, the relevance of a document to a structured query is initially represented as a vector, where each element corresponds to the relevance of a subquery.
  • Scalar Conversion: To facilitate ranking, these relevance vectors are converted into scalar values using methods like simple summation or more sophisticated interpolated coefficients that consider the structure of the query.
  • Robustness through Partial Matching: The model is designed to be robust, meaning it can retrieve relevant documents even if they don't perfectly match the entire structured query, as long as parts of the query (subqueries) are matched.

Datasets

The paper evaluates its approach on two datasets:

  • GENIA Corpus: A smaller, manually tag-annotated corpus of biomedical abstracts. This was used for preliminary experiments and to evaluate the model on a dataset with known structure.
  • OHSUMED Test Collection: A large, publicly available test collection for biomedical information retrieval. Crucially, OHSUMED is not originally annotated with tags. The authors therefore automatically annotated it to apply their structured query approach.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Structure Matters: The experiments strongly suggest that incorporating document structure significantly improves retrieval performance, especially for queries that are difficult to express with keywords alone.
  • Robustness is Key: The proposed model's ability to handle partial matches and structural variations makes it more robust than exact-matching models, leading to the retrieval of relevant documents that exact methods miss.
  • Automatic Annotation is Feasible: The success of applying the model to the OHSUMED corpus demonstrates that automatic annotation can be a viable strategy for enabling structured retrieval on large, unannotated datasets.
  • Subquery Decomposition: Breaking down complex structured queries into smaller, manageable subqueries allows for a more nuanced understanding of relevance and improves the model's ability to find documents that satisfy parts of the user's intent.

Key Results

The paper reports that their model generally outperformed both the "exact matching" region algebra model and a "flat" (non-structured) keyword-based model across various queries.

  • GENIA Corpus: The model achieved high relevance scores (e.g., 10/10 relevant results for several queries) compared to exact and flat models.
  • OHSUMED Test Collection: While results varied, the model consistently showed superiority over the exact model and often outperformed the flat model, particularly for queries where structural specification was effective. For instance, for Query 4, 5, and 6, the model was superior to the flat model.
  • Retrieval Time: The retrieval time was found to increase with the size of the document collection, but the system was deemed efficient enough for moderately sized datasets like GENIA.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Annotation Quality: The effectiveness of the model relies heavily on the quality of automatic annotations. The paper notes that using tags representing relations between technical terms (rather than just individual terms) could further improve results.
  • Query Formulation: Converting natural language queries into appropriate structured queries remains a challenge. The authors suggest that improving this conversion process is important for question answering.
  • Weighting Schemes: The current weighting of subqueries is based on simple frequency. Future work could involve assigning weights based on user intent or the importance of specific structures within a query.
  • Test Collections: The authors highlight the need for test collections that are not only annotated but also specifically designed for structured retrieval, with queries and relevance judgments that reflect structural matching.
  • Scalability: While efficient for smaller datasets, further research is needed to optimize the algorithm for extremely large databases, such as those used in web-based applications.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{masuda2003ranking,
  author = {Katsuya Masuda},
  title = {{A Ranking Model of Proximal and Structural Text Retrieval Based on Region Algebra}},
  booktitle = {Annual Meeting of the Association for Computational Linguistics},
  year = {2003},
}

Loading related content...

Figure