A qualitative study to explore strategies to improve the Road to Health Application for maternal and child health outcomes in South Africa

Janan J. Dietrich, Lerato M. Makhale, Thenjiwe Dubazane, Gugulethu Tshabalala, Boitumelo Maimela, Martin Weiss, Mamakiri MulaudziFrontiers Digit. Health 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study explores barriers and enablers to using the Road to Health Application (RTHA) in South Africa, a digital tool for maternal and child health. Key findings highlight the need for improved accessibility, language inclusivity, and enhanced functionality to increase user engagement and effectiveness in diverse communities.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In South Africa, ensuring equitable health and development for all children is a significant challenge. The National Department of Health developed the Road to Health Application (RTHA) as a digital extension of the traditional Road to Health booklet, aiming to provide maternal and child health guidelines, track immunizations, and create a child health database. However, the successful adoption and utilization of such digital health interventions are often hindered by various factors, particularly in diverse socio-economic and linguistic contexts like South Africa. This paper addresses the critical gap in understanding the real-world experiences of users with the RTHA, specifically identifying the barriers and enablers that influence its uptake and effectiveness. Without this understanding, efforts to improve digital health tools may fall short, failing to meet the needs of the intended users.

Methods

The researchers employed a qualitative research design, conducting 50 serial interviews with pregnant women and mothers of children under five years old. These interviews were conducted in two separate sessions, one month apart, to capture evolving user experiences. Participants were divided into two groups: 25 existing users and 25 new users of the RTHA. Eligibility criteria included being 18 years or older, owning an Android smartphone, and being pregnant or having a child under five. The interviews were semi-structured, using a guide to explore barriers, enablers, and the overall usability of the RTHA, including experiences with downloading, registration, navigation, and content. Data analysis involved thematic analysis using Framework Analysis, with a codebook developed through inductive and deductive approaches and analyzed using NVivo software.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relied on qualitative data collected through interviews with participants.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Digital Divide Persists: Despite the RTHA's potential, a significant barrier is the lack of smartphone access among many community members, limiting the app's reach.
  • Language is a Major Hurdle: The RTHA's availability in only isiZulu and English excludes a large portion of the South African population, who speak one of the country's 11 official languages. This linguistic barrier significantly impacts inclusivity and comprehension.
  • Cost of Data is a Practical Constraint: Even for those with smartphones, the high cost of mobile data makes consistent app usage difficult, rendering the app redundant for extended periods.
  • Usability and Design Matter: Technical difficulties, a lack of intuitive navigation, and an over-reliance on text with insufficient graphics can deter users, especially those with lower literacy levels.
  • Need for Personalization and Updates: Users desire personalized information based on their child's milestones and regular content updates to keep the app engaging and relevant beyond basic tracking.
  • Integration with Existing Systems is Key: Linking the RTHA to the National Department of Health's Child Immunization Database and potentially replacing the physical booklet could streamline processes and reduce data loss.

Key Results

  • Participant Demographics: 33% of participants reported IsiZulu as their main language, and 6% reported English. The majority (92%) had completed high school, with a substantial portion (73.9%) pursuing post-high school training.
  • Barriers Identified:
    • Mobile Phone and Data Access: Lack of smartphone ownership and high data costs were frequently cited.
  • App Usability: Technical difficulties (e.g., app taking long to open, error messages) and issues with profile creation were noted.
  • App Aesthetics: The app was described as having "too much text" and "little graphics," which could be challenging for users with low literacy.
  • Language: The app's availability in only two languages was a significant barrier for users of other South African languages.
  • Content Updates: Users found the information repetitive and not updated frequently enough, leading to a lack of continued engagement.
  • Features and Functions: Lack of backup functionality for user data was a concern, as was the absence of reminders or notifications.
  • Enablers Identified: The accessibility of important information regarding prenatal and postnatal childcare was recognized as a key benefit.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that the study's findings cannot be generalized to all demographics, particularly as smartphone ownership was an exclusion criterion. Future research could include participants who do not own smartphones and potentially provide devices to gain a more inclusive perspective. The authors suggest that future work should focus on:

  • Making the RTHA available offline and at clinics in rural areas.
  • Implementing backup options and fixing bugs.
  • Enhancing readability with more graphics.
  • Offering the app in all official South African languages.
  • Providing personalized information and regular content updates.
  • Linking the RTHA to the National Department of Health's Child Immunization Database.

The study also highlights the need for further research into the feasibility and acceptability of utilizing the RTHA during regular clinic visits.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{dietrich2022qualitative,
  author = {Janan J. Dietrich and Lerato M. Makhale and Thenjiwe Dubazane and Gugulethu Tshabalala and Boitumelo Maimela and Martin Weiss and Mamakiri Mulaudzi},
  title = {{A qualitative study to explore strategies to improve the Road to Health Application for maternal and child health outcomes in South Africa}},
  journal = {Frontiers Digit. Health},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3389/fdgth.2022.1094754},
}
Figure