Abstract
The number of students with intellectual disabilities in regular classrooms has been expanding yearly, but the problem of school bullying has severely impacted their physical and mental health and future development. Seven ordinary teachers were invited to participate in semi-structured interviews, and qualitative data analysis was performed using MAXQDA 2022. The results showed that children with intellectual disabilities who were bullied lacked social skills and anti-bullying consciousness. Children with intellectual disabilities were often isolated and treated differently by ordinary students. Furthermore, schools failed to address school bullying, and teachers did not deal with school bullying properly. There were also problems in the parenting of those who had been bullied, and the parents’ attitudes towards their children were often negative. In view of this, relevant countermeasures were proposed.
Introduction
In China, the "Learning in Regular Classrooms" (LRC) initiative has successfully integrated hundreds of thousands of students with special needs into mainstream schools. However, physical integration does not guarantee social integration. Students with intellectual disabilities (ID) are disproportionately targeted for bullying, yet research from the perspective of the frontline educators who witness these dynamics is sparse. This study aims to understand the systemic and interpersonal gaps that allow bullying to persist, identifying how the interaction between the individual, their family, their peers, and the school administration creates a "perfect storm" for persistent victimization.
Methods
The researchers employed a qualitative approach based on Grounded Theory, a systematic methodology involving the construction of theories through data analysis. Key technical aspects included:
- Semi-structured Interviews: The team interviewed seven teachers (grades 3–6) and three parents of bullied students to gather primary narrative data.
- Three-Level Coding: Using MAXQDA 2022 software, the researchers processed the interview transcripts through open coding (extracting 22 free nodes), spindle coding (summarizing into 10 secondary codes), and selective coding to identify core categories.
- Theoretical Modeling: They developed a "four-factor" conceptual model to visualize the hierarchy and correlation of bullying influences.
The Mechanism of Bullying Influence
The paper’s most significant contribution is the Mechanism Model of Factors Influencing School Bullying, which categorizes drivers into four distinct but overlapping domains divided by direct and indirect influence.
Direct Influences
- The School Environment (The Primary Driver): This was cited most frequently (37.8% of instances). Within this category, teachers’ mishandling of incidents accounted for 40% of the mentions. This suggests that bullying is often exacerbated by a lack of professional training for teachers in inclusive settings.
- Individual Factors: Students with ID often lack "anti-bullying consciousness." Due to cognitive impairments, they may not recognize bullying as a violation or may lack the social communication skills to seek help effectively.
Indirect Influences
- The "Isolation-Neglect" Peer Cycle: Peers often engage in indirect bullying, such as social isolation and neglect. These behaviors can be harder for teachers to detect than physical altercations but are equally damaging to the student's mental health.
- Family Environment: A significant insight was the "permissive" or "ignorant" attitude of some parents. Some parents viewed bullying as an inevitable consequence of their child being "different," leading to a lack of advocacy and communication with the school.
Key Results
The quantitative distribution of the identified factors provides a clear hierarchy of where intervention is most needed:
- School Environment Factors: 37.8% (Highest frequency)
- Individual Factors: 27.7%
- Family Factors: 19.2%
- Peer Factors: 15.2%
Qualitatively, the study found that a "negative school climate"—characterized by a lack of anti-bullying publicity and scientific management of incidents—is the single most important risk factor. The researchers conclude that without specific "integrated education" training, teachers in regular classrooms are ill-equipped to protect students with intellectual disabilities.
Limitations and Future Work
The authors acknowledge several constraints, including a small convenience sample (n=10) and a focus primarily on elementary schools, which may limit generalizability to older students. Additionally, the direct perspective of students with ID was missing due to the complexities of interviewing children with cognitive impairments.
Future Work: Research should focus on the efficacy of specific interventions, such as social skills training for students with ID and specialized professional development for mainstream teachers to foster a truly inclusive and safe environment.
Summary updated