A qualitative exploration of escalation of care in the acute ward setting

Jody Ede, Emma Jeffs, Sarah Vollam, Peter WatkinsonNursing 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This qualitative study explored how nurses and doctors escalate care for deteriorating patients on hospital wards, revealing that while Early Warning Scores (EWS) are used, clinical judgment and contextual factors heavily influence decisions. The research highlights significant communication barriers and identifies specific patient groups (complex and outliers) at higher risk of care failures during escalation, suggesting a need for more proactive and documented escalation pathways.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper addresses the critical issue of "Failure to Rescue" (FTR), which occurs when healthcare professionals fail to prevent avoidable patient deterioration and death. While interventions like Early Warning Scores (EWS) exist to flag declining patient conditions, delays in escalating care still lead to adverse outcomes. The authors aim to understand the nuanced barriers and facilitators to effective care escalation in acute hospital settings, focusing on modifiable factors to improve patient safety. This is crucial because FTR events are linked to diagnostic errors and poor recognition of deterioration, underscoring the need for a deeper understanding of the human and systemic factors involved in the escalation process.

Methods

This study employed a qualitative service evaluation methodology, primarily using observational methods and semi-structured ad-hoc interviews. Researchers spent 55 hours observing 12 different medical and surgical wards within a single National Health Service trust. The observations focused on capturing instances of care escalation, with field notes being extensively annotated. These notes were then thematically analyzed by two researchers using NVivo software. The analysis involved open coding, axial coding to identify relationships between themes, and selective coding to focus on highly relevant themes. The research team also engaged in iterative discussions to refine methods and ensure data saturation. A key aspect of the methodology was the focus on capturing "thick descriptions" of events, aiming to uncover factors influencing FTR that might not be explicitly articulated by clinicians.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relied on direct observation and interviews within a specific healthcare trust, rather than pre-existing datasets for training or evaluation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • EWS are a guide, not a mandate: Clinical staff don't solely rely on EWS alerts. They integrate these scores with their own clinical judgment, considering factors like bleeding or patient history, which are not always captured by scoring systems. This highlights the importance of experienced clinical intuition.
  • Re-escalation is a blind spot: While initial escalation might occur, re-escalating a patient whose condition remains abnormally stable (low-level EWS) is often overlooked. This suggests a potential gap in continuous monitoring and re-evaluation.
  • "Soft signals" matter: Nurses often identify deterioration based on subtle cues ("soft signals") like changes in skin color or breathing patterns, which are outside the scope of standard EWS. This underscores the value of experienced observation.
  • Complex patients are high-risk: Patients with complex care needs, those who are "outliers" (not on their usual ward), or those managed by multiple teams are at a significantly higher risk of escalation failures. Coordinating care and responsibility for these patients is a major challenge.
  • Communication breakdowns are pervasive: Team tension, inadequate staffing, and poor handover practices are significant barriers to effective communication during escalation, leading to delays and errors.

Key Results

  • Clinical nursing staff frequently challenged the sensitivity and specificity of EWS, finding them insufficient on their own.
  • Staff often did not re-escalate low-level EWS scores.
  • Complex care needs, patient outlier status, and involvement of multiple care teams were identified as significant barriers to escalation.
  • Team tension, staffing levels, and inadequate handover negatively impacted the chain of communication during escalation.
  • The study identified that re-escalation or tracking of deterioration was more problematic than initial detection.

Limitations and Future Work

Limitations: * The study was conducted within a single NHS trust, limiting the generalizability of its findings to the wider NHS. * Qualitative observations inherently carry the possibility of researcher bias, although efforts were made to mitigate this through team discussions and a structured observation guide.

Future Work: * The authors suggest that identifying high-risk patient groups (complex patients, outliers, those with multiple teams) and developing proactive, documented escalation pathways for them could be beneficial. * Encouraging meta-cognition (clinician introspection on decisions) and a culture of challenging assumptions could improve decision-making during escalation. * Further research is needed to understand the variability in escalation practices and how to bridge the gap between EWS and clinical judgment. * Integrating awareness of these factors into undergraduate and nurse training is suggested.

Summary updated

Abstract

This service evaluation demonstrates continuing health care communication barriers. Patient groups (complex patients and outliers) risk process failures during escalation. This can be applied in clinical practice by staff anticipating problems in these patients, documenting clear escalation pathways.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{ede2019qualitative,
  author = {Jody Ede and Emma Jeffs and Sarah Vollam and Peter Watkinson},
  title = {{A qualitative exploration of escalation of care in the acute ward setting}},
  booktitle = {Nursing},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1111/nicc.12479},
}
Figure