A prospective evaluation of cardiovascular magnetic resonance measures of dyssynchrony in the prediction of response to cardiac resynchronization therapy

Manav Sohal, Simon Duckett, Xiahai Zhuang, Wenzhe Shi, Matthew Ginks, Anoop Shetty, Eva Sammut, Sebastian Kozerke, Steven Niederer, Nic Smith, Sébastien Ourselin, Christopher A. Rinaldi, Daniel Rueckert, Gerald Carr‐White, Reza RazaviJournal of Cardiovascular Magnetic Resonance 2014 · DOI

Abstract

Many patients with electrical dyssynchrony who undergo cardiac resynchronization therapy (CRT) do not obtain substantial benefit. Assessing mechanical dyssynchrony may improve patient selection. We sought to evaluate cardiac motion in patients with heart failure and electrical dyssynchrony using cardiovascular magnetic resonance (CMR). We developed a framework for comparing measures of myocardial mechanics and evaluated how well they predicted response to CRT. CMR was performed prior to CRT, acquiring steady-state free precession (SSFP) and tagged cine images. Images were processed to extract regional ventricular volume-change, thickening, and strain. A systolic dyssynchrony index (SDI) was computed for all parameters. Volume-change SDI was identified as the strongest predictor of reverse remodeling (RR), defined as a decrease in end-systolic volume (ESV) ≥ 15% at 6 months. In a validation cohort of 50 patients, volume-change SDI was the only statistically significant predictor of RR compared to QRS duration, LBBB morphology, and scar burden.

Introduction: The Challenge of CRT Non-Response

Cardiac Resynchronization Therapy (CRT) uses specialized pacing to coordinate the contraction of the left and right ventricles in heart failure patients. While it can be life-saving, approximately 30–50% of patients are "non-responders"—they undergo the invasive procedure but see no functional improvement. Currently, clinical selection relies on "electrical dyssynchrony," typically measured by QRS duration on an ECG. However, electrical delays do not always translate to mechanical dysfunction. Previous attempts to use echocardiography to measure "mechanical dyssynchrony" were hampered by poor image quality and high inter-observer variability. This study investigates whether the superior image quality and reproducibility of Cardiovascular Magnetic Resonance (CMR) can provide a more reliable mechanical predictor to improve patient selection.

Methods: A Novel Framework for Motion Analysis

The researchers developed a novel image-processing framework to analyze CMR data across a 16-segment model of the left ventricle. This framework allowed for the comparison of three distinct mechanical measurements:

  1. Regional Volume Change: The amount of blood displaced by each segment during contraction.
  2. Myocardial Thickening: The change in heart wall thickness during a beat.
  3. Myocardial Strain: The internal deformation or stretching of the heart tissue.
Comprehensive motion tracking framework for analyzing 3D tagged and untagged CMR images.

The study utilized two types of MRI sequences: standard SSFP cine (video of the heart) and CSPAMM tagging (which "labels" heart tissue to track motion). The research was conducted in two phases. In Phase 1 (Discovery), 44 patients were analyzed to identify the most potent predictor among the CMR metrics. In Phase 2 (Validation), the optimal metric—Volume-change SDI—was tested on an independent group of 50 patients and compared against standard clinical predictors like QRS duration, LBBB morphology, and myocardial scar burden.

Key Insights: Why Volume Coordination Trumps Tissue Strain

A pivotal finding of the study was that Volume-change SDI was a far superior predictor compared to Strain SDI. While myocardial strain is a popular research topic, it measures local tissue deformation, which is highly sensitive to the complex, helical arrangement of heart fibers and local image noise. In contrast, volume change acts as an integrated measure of how well a segment actually contributes to the heart's pumping action. This makes it a more robust and clinically relevant marker of mechanical coordination.

Left ventricular segmentation and regional volume-change curves used to calculate the Systolic Dyssynchrony Index (SDI).

Furthermore, the CMR-based Volume-change SDI demonstrated exceptional reproducibility, with a coefficient of variation of approximately 2.8% in patients. This stability is crucial for real-world clinical application, addressing the primary failure point of previous echocardiographic methods. Importantly, this metric can be derived from standard "cine" MRI images already included in routine protocols, meaning hospitals would not necessarily require specialized "tagging" sequences to implement this approach.

Key Results and Clinical Implications

The study identified an SDI value of >9.75% as the optimal cutoff for predicting response. In the discovery phase, patients with a high Volume-change SDI were 5.67 times more likely to experience successful reverse remodeling (p=0.003). In the Phase 2 validation cohort, Volume-change SDI was the only statistically significant predictor of response when tested alongside traditional markers. Despite their theoretical appeal, myocardial strain measures were the least predictive of CRT success.

Conclusion

A systolic dyssynchrony index derived from regional volume change is a highly reproducible measurement that can be derived from routinely acquired SSFP cine images. It effectively predicts reverse remodeling following CRT, whereas traditional electrical markers and complex strain measurements often fall short. Future research should focus on integrating this volume-based SDI into automated AI pipelines to provide real-time decision support for cardiologists during the CRT screening process.

Summary updated

Abstract

Many patients with electrical dyssynchrony who undergo cardiac resynchronization therapy (CRT) do not obtain substantial benefit. Assessing mechanical dyssynchrony may improve patient selection. Results from studies using echocardiographic imaging to measure dyssynchrony have ultimately proved disappointing. We sought to evaluate cardiac motion in patients with heart failure and electrical dyssynchrony using cardiovascular magnetic resonance (CMR). We developed a framework for comparing measures of myocardial mechanics and evaluated how well they predicted response to CRT. CMR was performed at 1.5 Tesla prior to CRT. Steady-state free precession (SSFP) cine images and complementary modulation of magnetization (CSPAMM) tagged cine images were acquired. Images were processed using a novel framework to extract regional ventricular volume-change, thickening and deformation fields (strain). A systolic dyssynchrony index (SDI) for all parameters within a 16-segment model of the ventricle was computed with high SDI denoting more dyssynchrony. Once identified, the optimal measure was applied to a second patient population to determine its utility as a predictor of CRT response compared to current accepted predictors (QRS duration, LBBB morphology and scar burden). Forty-four patients were recruited in the first phase (91% male, 63.3 ± 14.1 years; 80% NYHA class III) with mean QRSd 154 ± 24 ms. Twenty-one out of 44 (48%) patients showed reverse remodelling (RR) with a decrease in end systolic volume (ESV) ≥ 15% at 6 months. Volume-change SDI was the strongest predictor of RR (PR 5.67; 95% CI 1.95-16.5; P = 0.003). SDI derived from myocardial strain was least predictive. Volume-change SDI was applied as a predictor of RR to a second population of 50 patients (70% male, mean age 68.6 ± 12.2 years, 76% NYHA class III) with mean QRSd 146 ± 21 ms. When compared to QRSd, LBBB morphology and scar burden, volume-change SDI was the only statistically significant predictor of RR in this group. A systolic dyssynchrony index derived from volume-change is a highly reproducible measurement that can be derived from routinely acquired SSFP cine images and predicts RR following CRT whilst an SDI of regional strain does not.
BibTeX
@article{sohal2014prospective,
  author = {Manav Sohal and Simon Duckett and Xiahai Zhuang and Wenzhe Shi and Matthew Ginks and Anoop Shetty and Eva Sammut and Sebastian Kozerke and Steven Niederer and Nic Smith and Sébastien Ourselin and Christopher A. Rinaldi and Daniel Rueckert and Gerald Carr‐White and Reza Razavi},
  title = {{A prospective evaluation of cardiovascular magnetic resonance measures of dyssynchrony in the prediction of response to cardiac resynchronization therapy}},
  journal = {Journal of Cardiovascular Magnetic Resonance},
  year = {2014},
  doi = {10.1186/preaccept-1270501173126876},
}
Figure