A Proposed Methodology for the Dynamic Standard Evaluation of Water Quality in Estuaries: A Case Study of the Pearl River Estuary

Zhongyuan Wang, Hongkang ZhangJournal of Marine Science and Engineering 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel "dynamic standard" for evaluating estuarine water quality, addressing the inadequacy of applying separate river and sea standards to these transitional zones. By incorporating salinity, this method offers a more accurate and practical assessment of estuarine health, as demonstrated in a case study of the Pearl River Estuary.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Estuaries are unique environments where freshwater rivers meet saltwater seas, creating complex mixing zones with distinct water quality characteristics. Currently, China (and many other regions) lacks specific water quality standards for these areas. Instead, either the "Environmental Quality Standards for Surface Water" or the "Seawater Quality Standard" is applied, often leading to inaccurate assessments. This can result in situations where estuarine water quality appears to exceed seawater standards, even when the upstream river water and the incoming seawater itself meet their respective standards. This disconnect hinders effective environmental management and protection of these vital ecosystems.

Methods

The core of this paper is the proposal of a "dynamic evaluation standard" for estuarine water quality. This method ingeniously bridges the gap between existing surface water and seawater quality standards by using salinity as a key variable. The approach involves:

  1. Establishing Correspondence: Mapping the functional categories of surface water standards (Classes I-V) to seawater quality standards (Classes I-IV), recognizing that Class I surface water and Class II seawater share similar protection objectives, and so on.
  2. Dynamic Standard Calculation: For each water quality parameter, a dynamic standard value is calculated based on the salinity (S) of the estuarine water. This calculation uses linear interpolation between the corresponding surface water and seawater standard values. Specifically, if $A_1$ is the Class I seawater standard and $B_{II}$ is the Class II surface water standard for a given element, the dynamic standard $C_1$ is calculated as:
  3. When $A_1 < B_{II}$: $C_1 = A_1 + (B_{II} – A_1) \times S/35$

    • When $A_1 > B_{II}$: $C_1 = B_{II} + (A_1 - B_{II}) \times S/35$
    • When $A_1 = B_{II}$: Direct evaluation is sufficient. Similar formulas are used for calculating dynamic standards for Classes II, III, and IV.
  4. Water Quality Classification: The measured water quality parameter is then compared to these calculated dynamic standard values to classify the water quality into Class I, II, III, or IV.

This method is designed to be simple and effective, utilizing parameters common to both existing standards. The paper focuses on eight representative parameters: Pb, pH, PI (Permanganate Index, equivalent to COD in seawater standards), DO (Dissolved Oxygen), Cu, Zn, Cd, and Hg.

Datasets

The study utilizes on-site monitoring data collected from the Pearl River Estuary (PRE) between 2004 and 2010. Samples were collected at three stations (S01, S02, S03) at different depths and during both ebb and rising tides. The parameters measured included salinity, Pb, pH, PI, DO, Cu, Zn, Cd, and Hg. No new benchmark datasets were introduced; rather, existing national standards (GB3097-1997 for seawater and GB3838-2002 for surface water) were used as the basis for comparison and the development of the dynamic standard.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Salinity as a Unifying Factor: The paper highlights salinity as a crucial, yet often overlooked, variable that dictates the mixing dynamics and thus the water quality characteristics of estuaries.
  • Bridging the Standard Gap: The dynamic standard effectively harmonizes disparate surface water and seawater quality standards, creating a more holistic evaluation framework for transitional aquatic environments.
  • Improved Accuracy: The dynamic standard provides a more scientifically sound and realistic assessment of estuarine water quality compared to simply applying one of the existing standards. This is particularly important when estuarine conditions fall between the strictness of surface water and seawater limits.
  • Practical Applicability: The method is presented as simple to implement, requiring only salinity measurements and existing standard values, making it accessible for routine monitoring.

Key Results

The application of the dynamic standard to the Pearl River Estuary yielded significant insights:

  • Improved Classification for Key Parameters: For parameters like Pb and pH, the dynamic standard resulted in a more favorable water quality classification (e.g., Pb changing from Class II to Class I, and pH from Class III to Class I) compared to the seawater quality standard.
  • Consistent Results for Less Polluted Parameters: For elements like Cu, Zn, Cd, and Hg, which were found to be at very low pollution levels in the PRE, both the seawater quality standard and the dynamic standard yielded consistent Class I classifications.
  • Reflects Actual Conditions: The study concludes that the dynamic standard is more reflective of the actual environmental quality in estuaries than direct application of the Seawater Quality Standard.
  • PI and DO Differences: While Pb and pH showed significant improvements in classification, PI and DO also showed some differences in evaluation results between the two methods, with the dynamic standard often yielding better classifications.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Parameter Limitations: The current dynamic standard can only evaluate 17 parameters that are common to both the "Seawater Quality Standard" and the "Environmental Quality Standards for Surface Water." Parameters like petroleum, which have different analytical methods and definitions across the two standards, cannot be evaluated.
  • Nutrient Salt Indicators: A significant limitation identified is the absence of nutrient salt indicators (total nitrogen and total phosphorus) in the current Chinese seawater quality standards. These are crucial for assessing eutrophication, a major marine environmental problem. The authors emphasize the need to revise existing standards to include these indicators.
  • Geographic Scope: While the study focused on three sites in the Pearl River Estuary, the authors suggest that the method is valid and can be extended to evaluate more sites to establish a broader evaluation scope for the entire estuary region.
  • Global Applicability Prerequisites: For the dynamic standard to be applied globally, corresponding "Environmental Quality Standards for Surface Water" and "Seawater Quality Standards" are needed, along with unified water quality levels and monitoring elements across these standards.
  • Future Work: The authors strongly advocate for revising and unifying China's surface water and seawater quality standards, particularly by incorporating nutrient salt indicators, to enable a more comprehensive dynamic evaluation of estuarine and marine environments.

Summary updated

Abstract

Currently, China’s river water quality evaluation adopts the “Environmental Quality Standards for Surface Water”, while the seawater quality evaluation uses the “Seawater Quality Standard”. However, estuarine areas, where rivers meet the sea, do not have evaluation standards, and most often, the “Seawater Quality Standard” is applied. At present, the water quality in the estuary area sometimes exceeds the corresponding seawater quality standards, even though the quality of the surface water does not exceed surface water environmental quality standards and the quality of the seawater before mixing also meets the seawater quality standards. This paper proposes a dynamic evaluation standard based on the salinity of estuarine water and uses this standard to evaluate the water quality in estuaries, thus solving the abovementioned issue. The implementation of this method is simple and effective. Taking the Pearl River Estuary as an example, this paper introduces the dynamic standard evaluation method for water quality in the Pearl River Estuary. Compared to the existing seawater quality standards implemented in estuaries, this dynamic evaluation standard can assess the water quality in estuaries more accurately and provide a reference for water quality evaluation methods in estuaries.
BibTeX
@article{wang2024proposed,
  author = {Zhongyuan Wang and Hongkang Zhang},
  title = {{A Proposed Methodology for the Dynamic Standard Evaluation of Water Quality in Estuaries: A Case Study of the Pearl River Estuary}},
  journal = {Journal of Marine Science and Engineering},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3390/jmse12071039},
}
Figure