A Prompt Decarbonization Pathway for Shipping: Green Hydrogen, Ammonia, and Methanol Production and Utilization in Marine Engines

Jie Shi, Yuanqing Zhu, Yongming Feng, Jun Yang, Chong XiaAtmosphere 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

The shipping industry faces immense pressure to decarbonize. This review paper explores the production and application of green hydrogen, ammonia, and methanol as viable low- or zero-emission marine fuels, highlighting the critical role of renewable energy in their production and the challenges that remain for widespread adoption.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The global shipping industry is a significant contributor to greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions, primarily due to its reliance on heavy fossil fuels. The International Maritime Organization (IMO) has set ambitious targets to reduce these emissions, necessitating a transition to cleaner energy sources. While various alternative fuels are being discussed, a comprehensive understanding of the "green fuel pathway" – from renewable energy generation to the production and utilization of fuels like hydrogen, ammonia, and methanol – is crucial for effective decarbonization. This paper aims to fill this gap by reviewing the production methods for these green fuels and assessing their potential for marine applications.

Methods

This paper is a comprehensive review and analysis of existing literature. It synthesizes information on:

  • Green Power Production: It examines various renewable energy sources (hydropower, wind, solar, bioenergy) and their potential for generating "green power," which is electricity derived from renewable sources.
  • Green Fuel Production: It details the production pathways for green hydrogen (electrolysis of water, biomass conversion), green ammonia (primarily via the Haber-Bosch process using green hydrogen), and green methanol (from biomass or CO2 hydrogenation).
  • Application in Shipping: It analyzes the potential and challenges of using these green fuels in marine engines and fuel cells, considering factors like storage, safety, and infrastructure.

The methodology is primarily literature-based, drawing on a wide range of scientific publications, reports, and industry data to provide a holistic overview.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Green Fuel Pathway" is Key: The paper emphasizes that simply using renewable energy directly on ships is often impractical. The more viable approach is to use renewable energy to produce green fuels, which can then be stored and transported.
  • Interconnectedness of Green Fuels: Green hydrogen is presented as a foundational fuel, serving as a feedstock for both green ammonia and green methanol production. This highlights the interconnectedness of these decarbonization efforts.
  • Methanol's Near-Term Advantage: While hydrogen offers a truly zero-emission solution in the long run, methanol is highlighted as a more promising near-term option due to its higher energy density, easier storage and transport, and existing infrastructure compatibility.
  • Ammonia's Promise and Peril: Ammonia offers high energy density and easier storage than hydrogen, making it a strong contender. However, its toxicity and potential for N2O emissions require careful management.
  • Cost Remains a Major Hurdle: A consistent theme is that green fuels are currently more expensive than conventional fossil fuels. Reducing production costs through improved renewable energy technology and more efficient fuel production processes is critical.
  • Infrastructure is a Bottleneck: Beyond production, the development of robust supply chains, refueling infrastructure, and onboard storage solutions are significant challenges for all green fuels, particularly hydrogen.

Key Results

  • Production Pathways Identified: The paper clearly outlines the primary methods for producing green hydrogen (seawater electrolysis with green power), green ammonia (green hydrogen + Haber-Bosch), and green methanol (from CO2 using green power).
  • Comparative Advantages and Challenges: Table 2 provides a concise summary of the advantages and challenges for each fuel in ship applications, noting:
  • Hydrogen: Low toxicity, less environmental impact from leakage, but high storage costs and explosion risk.
  • Ammonia: Low flammability, easy to store, but high toxicity, potential N2O emissions, and poor combustion characteristics.
  • Methanol: Commercialized engines, easy to store, less harmful than traditional fuels, but high storage costs and potential need for infrastructure modifications.
  • Recommendations for Decarbonization: The authors suggest improving green power production technology to lower costs, developing more efficient electrochemical fuel production, and exploring novel technologies.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Cost Competitiveness: The paper acknowledges that in the short term, green fuels are expected to be more expensive than conventional fuels. Further cost reduction is essential for widespread adoption.
  • Infrastructure Development: Significant investment and strategic planning are needed to establish the necessary infrastructure for producing, storing, and distributing green fuels, especially for hydrogen.
  • Technological Maturity: While promising, some technologies for green fuel production and utilization are still under development and require further research and optimization.
  • Safety Regulations: Specific regulations for the safe use and storage of these new fuels, particularly ammonia, need to be further developed and harmonized.
  • Future Work: The authors strongly advocate for continued research and development in renewable energy and green fuel production technologies, alongside expanding production capacity to ensure an adequate supply of low- and zero-emission marine fuels. They also highlight the need for a comprehensive approach that considers the entire fuel pathway and ship operation.

Summary updated

Abstract

The shipping industry has reached a higher level of maturity in terms of its knowledge and awareness of decarbonization challenges. Carbon-free or carbon-neutralized green fuel, such as green hydrogen, green ammonia, and green methanol, are being widely discussed. However, little attention has paid to the green fuel pathway from renewable energy to shipping. This paper, therefore, provides a review of the production methods for green power (green hydrogen, green ammonia, and green methanol) and analyzes the potential of green fuel for application to shipping. The review shows that the potential production methods for green hydrogen, green ammonia, and green methanol for the shipping industry are (1) hydrogen production from seawater electrolysis using green power; (2) ammonia production from green hydrogen + Haber–Bosch process; and (3) methanol production from CO2 using green power. While the future of green fuel is bright, in the short term, the costs are expected to be higher than conventional fuel. Our recommendations are therefore as follows: improve green power production technology to reduce the production cost; develop electrochemical fuel production technology to increase the efficiency of green fuel production; and explore new technology. Strengthening the research and development of renewable energy and green fuel production technology and expanding fuel production capacity to ensure an adequate supply of low- and zero-emission marine fuel are important factors to achieve carbon reduction in shipping.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{shi2023prompt,
  author = {Jie Shi and Yuanqing Zhu and Yongming Feng and Jun Yang and Chong Xia},
  title = {{A Prompt Decarbonization Pathway for Shipping: Green Hydrogen, Ammonia, and Methanol Production and Utilization in Marine Engines}},
  booktitle = {Atmosphere},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/atmos14030584},
}
Figure