TL;DR
This paper introduces THESEUS-PP, a novel Bayesian probabilistic model for superimposing protein structures using deep probabilistic programming. By leveraging probabilistic programming, THESEUS-PP offers a more flexible and robust approach than traditional methods, particularly for handling variations within protein structures.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Comparing and aligning protein structures is fundamental to understanding their function, dynamics, and evolution. The standard method, Root Mean Square Deviation (RMSD), minimizes the sum of squared distances between corresponding atoms. However, RMSD makes a simplifying assumption that all atoms have equal variance (homoscedasticity) and are uncorrelated. This is problematic for proteins, which often have flexible regions (like loops or termini) where atoms exhibit higher variance. THESEUS-PP aims to address this limitation by providing a probabilistic framework that can account for these variations (heteroscedasticity) and correlated atom positions, leading to more accurate superpositions.
Methods
The core of this work is the development of THESEUS-PP, a Bayesian model built upon the existing THESEUS framework. While the original THESEUS model used maximum likelihood estimation, THESEUS-PP employs a Bayesian approach with maximum a-posteriori (MAP) estimation. This is achieved by defining prior distributions over the model's parameters: rotation, translation, variances, and the latent mean structure.
A key innovation is the implementation of THESEUS-PP using the deep probabilistic programming language Pyro. Pyro's automated inference capabilities allow for the efficient estimation of these complex Bayesian models. The model treats observed protein structures as noisy observations of an underlying latent mean structure, which is then rotated and translated. The paper details the formulation of priors for the mean structure (using a Student's t-distribution for numerical stability), translation (a standard trivariate normal distribution), rotation (using quaternions for a uniform prior), and variances. The likelihood function is derived from a matrix-normal distribution, which is then expressed as a product of univariate Student's t-distributions to handle heteroscedasticity.
Datasets
The algorithm was tested on several proteins obtained from the RCSB protein database, specifically from Nuclear Magnetic Resonance (NMR) experiments. These structures were chosen because they typically contain multiple models of the same protein, representing structural dynamics and thus exhibiting both conserved and variable regions, making them suitable for evaluating robust superposition methods. The specific PDB IDs used were: 1ADZ, 1AHL, 1AK7, 2CPD, 2KHI, 2LKL, and 2YS9.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Probabilistic Programming as a Paradigm Shift: The paper highlights probabilistic programming languages like Pyro as a powerful new tool for formulating and implementing complex Bayesian models in bioinformatics, offering flexibility and automation.
- Beyond RMSD's Homoscedasticity: THESEUS-PP's ability to model heteroscedasticity (varying atom variances) is crucial for accurately superimposing proteins with flexible regions, where RMSD can fail to distinguish conserved from variable parts.
- Bayesian Approach for Robustness: By incorporating priors and performing MAP estimation, the Bayesian framework provides a more principled way to handle uncertainty and potentially improve the robustness of protein structure superposition.
- Potential for Error Modeling: The authors envision THESEUS-PP as a valuable error model for Bayesian protein structure prediction, enabling better distinction between correct and incorrect predictions.
Key Results
The paper demonstrates that THESEUS-PP can successfully superimpose protein structures, and in visual comparisons (Figure 2, 4-9), it appears to better distinguish between regions of high and low variance compared to conventional RMSD. This leads to a more accurate matching of conserved regions. The algorithm was tested on several proteins, with average convergence times under 0.1 seconds for the original THESEUS algorithm, and slightly longer for THESEUS-PP due to variational inference and priors. The paper provides a table (Table I) detailing the number of atoms, models, average computational time, and epochs for each tested protein.
Limitations and Future Work
- Speed vs. Flexibility: While probabilistic programming offers significant flexibility, the authors acknowledge that it comes with a speed penalty compared to the original, faster maximum likelihood estimation-based THESEUS algorithm.
- Error Model for Prediction: The authors suggest that THESEUS-PP could serve as an error model for Bayesian protein structure prediction, but this remains a future direction.
- Further Development of Error Models: The paper notes that to achieve end-to-end protein structure prediction with associated statistical uncertainties, suitable error models and likelihood functions need to be developed and incorporated, with THESEUS-PP being a promising candidate.
Summary updated