A Preliminary Study on the Programmatic Module Construction of Collective Negotiation

Xiang AoInternational Journal of Frontiers in Sociology 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper proposes a modular, AI-driven framework to transform collective bargaining from a high-friction "tug-of-war" into a data-driven, scientific process. By integrating big data, automatic control theory, and psychological modeling, the author provides a roadmap for labor unions to eliminate information asymmetry and establish fair wage growth ranges, even during economic crises like the post-pandemic era.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Collective negotiation—the process where labor and management agree on wages and conditions—is often paralyzed by a "dare not talk, won't talk" stalemate. Management often refuses to negotiate out of fear of excessive demands, while labor unions lack the granular data (on industry standards, government policies, and enterprise profits) to make reasonable requests.

This "information asymmetry" leads to inefficient outcomes. The paper tackles three main obstacles:

  1. Insufficient reference data: Lack of historical and industry-wide benchmarks.
  2. Information asymmetry: Management holds the financial cards; labor is in the dark.
  3. Unscientific growth rates: The inability to calculate a wage increase that balances worker needs with enterprise sustainability.

Methods

The author introduces a six-module programmatic architecture that combines human decision-making with computer processing (AI and Big Data):

  1. Big Data Screening: Collects and filters demands from both sides against a shared data platform.
  2. Policies and Regulations Correction: Ensures all data and demands comply with legal boundaries.
  3. Cloud Computing Processing (The Core): Uses regression, marginal analysis, and system operation analysis to predict next-year business data and calculate wage ranges.
  4. Equity Compensation: Adds "temperature" to the cold data by factoring in social justice, poverty relief, and labor protection.
  5. Psychological Expectation Modification: Involves sociologists and psychologists to balance the "utility" and expectations of both parties.
  6. Supervision: A third-party mechanism to ensure the final agreement is actually implemented.

Technically, the paper borrows from Automatic Control Theory, applying "negative feedback" loops and "closed-loop control" to adjust wage increases. It also utilizes 2D Coordinate Analysis (plotting absolute wage vs. relative growth rate) to visualize the "optimal" negotiation zone.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on the architectural framework for a data-sharing platform rather than testing on a specific static dataset. It describes a theoretical "dual-layer linkage" system that would ingest real-time data from the All-China Federation of Trade Unions (ACFTU), government guidelines (CPI, minimum wage), and enterprise financial reports.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Information as a Deterrent: The author argues that a transparent data-sharing platform acts as a deterrent against "capital" (management). When data is transparent, management is less likely to hide profits or act in bad faith.
  • The "Negative Feedback" Analogy: The economy is treated as a mechanical system. During "special circumstances" (like a pandemic), the government acts as an "automatic stabilizer," using negative feedback to prevent the system from losing control.
  • The Golden Section (0.618) Rule: In cases of profit decline, the paper suggests using the "golden section" method to find a wage level ($S2$) that allows the enterprise to maintain reproduction while still protecting workers' basic income.
  • Human-in-the-Loop AI: The framework doesn't replace negotiators; it "intelligentizes" the process. Modules 4 and 5 specifically require human expertise (psychologists/sociologists) to handle the nuances that algorithms miss.

Key Results

  • The F-G-H-J Shadow Module: The paper defines a specific "reasonable value range" for wage increases on a 2D plane. This provides a mathematical "safe zone" for negotiators.
  • Crisis Formulas: The author provides quantitative formulas for:
  • $P$: Weighted average rate of return on net assets.
  • $Q$: Weighted average of wage negotiation increases.
  • $F$: Industry-wide weighted average growth rate.
  • Win-Win Flowchart: A comprehensive logic flow (Figure 7) for correcting wage increases when corporate profits decline, ensuring that even in a loss, wage growth shouldn't fall below the Consumer Price Index (CPI).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Implementation Scale: The author acknowledges that building this system is an "indeed large" project that requires massive cross-departmental cooperation.
  • Interdisciplinary Requirements: The model relies heavily on the integration of AI, sociology, and economics, which may be difficult to coordinate in practice.
  • Preliminary Nature: The study is self-described as "preliminary" and "superficial" in some areas, calling for more experts to share "the wisdom of collective negotiation" to refine the mathematical models.

Summary updated

Abstract

Insufficient reference data, information asymmetry, and inability to scientifically determine the growth rate are the main obstacles restricting the proposal of a reasonable and effective collective negotiation plan. In the context of the country accelerating the national cyber development strategy, the construction of digital China, and labor unions vigorously promoting the construction of intelligent labor unions, this paper follows the whole process of collective negotiation, utilizing human decision making (intervention) and computer information processing (AI, etc.), and tries to establish six modules, including big data screening, policy and regulation correction, cloud computing processing, rights and interests compensation, psychological expectation revision, and supervision, to intelligentize the main process of collective negotiation. The scientific operation of the modules is ensured by establishing a dynamic prediction platform based on improving data accuracy and a dual-layer linkage data sharing platform based on improving the breadth of data from All-China Federation of labor unions (ACFTU) to grass-roots labor unions vertically and from industry to enterprise labor unions horizontally. At the same time, reasonable wage increase range and quantitative correction scheme under special circumstances are given through the use of "negative feedback" principle of automatic control theory, the large cycle of closed-loop control system, and the analysis of the absolute and relative value range of wage increase in two-dimensional coordinates. Using qualitative and quantitative analysis methods, the exploration of intelligent collective negotiation can be creatively carried out, and they provide innovative ideas for breaking through the barriers of collective negotiation between labor and management, formulating scientific and feasible collective negotiation plans, and promoting win-win and stability for both labor and management.
BibTeX
@article{ao2023preliminary,
  author = {Xiang Ao},
  title = {{A Preliminary Study on the Programmatic Module Construction of Collective Negotiation}},
  journal = {International Journal of Frontiers in Sociology},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.25236/ijfs.2023.050816},
}

Loading related content...

Figure