A Preliminary Study on the Effect of Post-rock Musicon the Mental Health of College Students in Acceptance Music Therapy

Rong JinJournal of Humanities Arts and Social Science 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This study explores the therapeutic potential of post-rock music—a genre characterized by instrumental textures and "sound walls"—as an intervention for college students suffering from mild depression and anxiety. Results indicate that an 8-week receptive music therapy program significantly lowered clinical scores for mental distress, suggesting that post-rock’s unique physiological and aesthetic properties make it a potent tool for modern psychological intervention.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

College students face escalating mental health challenges driven by academic pressure and a fast-paced social environment. While music therapy is a well-established field, the "sound ontology" of specific modern genres is often overlooked in favor of classical or traditional "relaxing" music.

The author argues that post-rock music, which emerged as a significant cultural force in China around 2010, possesses specific structural qualities—such as its lack of lyrics, use of ambient sampling, and dense instrumental layering—that may be uniquely suited to the aesthetic preferences and physiological needs of younger generations. The paper seeks to provide the first experimental data to move post-rock therapy from a theoretical discussion to an evidence-based practice.

Methods

The researchers employed a receptive music therapy approach, where subjects listen to and process music rather than performing it. The intervention followed a three-stage process (creation, development, and "perfect" stages) over 8 weeks, consisting of 60-minute weekly sessions.

The implementation was divided into three core components:

  1. Scenario Creation: Curating a specific post-rock library (featuring artists like Wang Wen and Water Fai) designed to trigger therapeutic responses.
  2. Music Imagination: Using both guided and non-guided sessions to allow subjects to project their subconscious onto the music's abstract textures.
  3. Feedback Discussion: A collaborative session where students shared feelings and recorded emotional states.

The study used a randomized controlled trial (RCT) format with 26 students screened for mild depression and anxiety, split evenly into an experimental group and a control group.

Datasets

The study did not use large-scale digital datasets but relied on standardized clinical psychometric scales to evaluate the participants:

  • Symptom Checklist 90 (SCL-90): To measure a broad range of psychological symptoms.
  • Self-Rating Depression Scale (SDS): Specifically for depressive symptoms.
  • Self-Rating Anxiety Scale (SAS): Specifically for anxiety symptoms.
  • NetEase Cloud Music Metadata: The author also referenced a brief statistical analysis of user-generated playlists to demonstrate the "healing" association users already have with the post-rock genre.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Sound Wall" and Theta Waves: Post-rock often utilizes a "sound wall" technique—rapid tremolo picking on electric guitars. The paper notes that the physical frequency of these notes (4-8Hz) overlaps with Theta waves (3-7Hz) in the human brain, which are associated with deep relaxation, meditation, and spiritual awareness.
  • The 1/F Spectrum: Post-rock's frequency distribution often mimics the 1/F (pink noise) spectrum found in nature. This is hypothesized to stimulate the hypothalamus to release neurotransmitters that regulate the autonomic nervous system and endocrine health.
  • Synesthesia through Sampling: By incorporating non-musical samples (ocean waves, birdsong, children laughing, or train announcements), post-rock creates "ambient scenes" that trigger synesthesia. This allows listeners to visualize "subconscious pictures," facilitating emotional catharsis without the restrictive narrative of lyrics.
  • Rhythmic Entrainment: The genre typically maintains a beat rate of 50-80 BPM, which closely mirrors the resting human heart rate (approx. 75 BPM), promoting a state of physiological calm.

Key Results

The quantitative data showed a clear divergence between the experimental and control groups over time:

  • Depression (SCL-90): The experimental group’s scores dropped from a mean of 26.92 to 25.30 over 8 weeks. Statistical significance ($p < 0.05$) was achieved by week 6, becoming extremely significant ($p < 0.01$) by week 7 and 8.
  • Anxiety (SCL-90): Scores dropped from 30.50 to 29.30. Significant differences appeared after week 5.
  • Sustainability: A follow-up at 16 weeks (8 weeks after the intervention ended) showed that the improvements remained stable, suggesting that the therapy has a lasting "time-dependent" effect rather than being a fleeting mood boost.

Limitations and Future Work

The author identifies several constraints that should be addressed in future research:

  • Sample Size: With only 26 participants, the study is a "preliminary" look. Larger cohorts are needed to generalize the findings.
  • Demographic Variables: The study did not account for how gender or age might influence the acceptance of post-rock music.
  • Subjective Preference: The "degree of music acceptance" (i.e., whether a student actually likes post-rock) was not controlled for, which could significantly skew the efficacy of a receptive intervention.
  • Scope of Genre: The study focused exclusively on post-rock; future work could compare its efficacy against other modern genres like Lo-fi, Ambient, or Shoegaze.

Summary updated

Abstract

With the increase of the group base of college students, the heavy scientific research, study and work, as well as the influence of various internal and external factors, such as the accelerated pace of life, some college students often expose psychological health problems. This study used the receptive Post Rock Music therapy intervention to carry out positive psychological intervention on the depression and anxiety symptoms of the selected students with mental health symptoms, After the trial intervention, there were significant differences in depression and anxiety scores on the Symptom Checklist 90 (SCL-90), Self-Rating Depression Scale (SDS), and Self-Rating Anxiety Scale (SAS) questionnaire, which has a good effect on the performance of depression and anxiety, indicating that post rock music has a significant effect on the intervention of mental health. It demonstrates the therapeutic function of post rock music, and provides experimental data and theoretical support for the practice and application of post rock music in music therapy.
BibTeX
@article{jin2023preliminary,
  author = {Rong Jin},
  title = {{A Preliminary Study on the Effect of Post-rock Musicon the Mental Health of College Students in Acceptance Music Therapy}},
  journal = {Journal of Humanities Arts and Social Science},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.26855/jhass.2023.01.012},
}
Figure