A PRELIMINARY INVESTIGATION ON COMPARISON AND TRANSFORMATION OF SENTINEL-2 MSI AND LANDSAT 8 OLI

F. Chen, Shenlong Lou, Qunqun Fan, Jonathan Li, Chunjin Wang, Martin Claverie2018 · DOI

Abstract

Combining data from Sentinel-2 (MSI) and Landsat 8 (OLI) offers a powerful opportunity for high-frequency Earth observation, potentially reducing revisit times to 2–3 days. However, differences in sensor Spectral Response Functions (SRFs) introduce radiometric discrepancies. This study quantifies these differences using simulated reflectance from ASTER and Hyperion spectral libraries. Results indicate that while some bands are highly consistent, others—particularly in the visible and near-infrared (NIR) ranges—show significant variation. Notably, using Sentinel-2’s narrow NIR band (8a) instead of the broad band (8) substantially improves consistency in NDVI calculations.

Introduction

For time-sensitive applications like emergency response or agricultural monitoring, high-frequency satellite data is critical. While Sentinel-2 and Landsat 8 are both medium-resolution workhorses, their individual revisit cycles (5–10 days) are often insufficient. Harmonizing their data can provide a 2–3 day revisit cycle. However, "harmonization" is complicated by the fact that different sensors have unique "sensitivity profiles," known as Spectral Response Functions (SRFs).

Quantifying Spectral Discrepancies

The core of the challenge lies in how each sensor's filters respond to incoming light. Even when looking at the same target, MSI and OLI will report different reflectance values because their SRFs do not perfectly overlap.

Comparison of Spectral Response Functions (SRFs) for Sentinel-2 MSI (blue) and Landsat 8 OLI (black) across VNIR and SWIR wavelengths.

As shown in the SRF comparison, there are notable shifts and width differences in the corresponding bands. The study used high-resolution "ground truth" spectra from the ASTER Spectral Library and Hyperion data archives to simulate how these SRF differences manifest as reflectance errors.

Key Findings: The NIR Advantage and Index Propagation

The research revealed that discrepancies are not uniform across all bands. Coastal Aerosol, SWIR, and Cirrus channels showed high consistency (relative difference < 5%). In contrast, the Blue, Green, Red, and broad NIR channels exhibited much higher differences.

A critical insight for vegetation monitoring is the choice of NIR band. Sentinel-2 features both a broad NIR band (Band 8) and a narrow one (Band 8a). The study found that Band 8a is a much closer match to Landsat 8’s NIR band.

Difference in NDVI values between MSI and OLI as a function of OLI NDVI, comparing the use of MSI Band 8 (broad) versus Band 8a (narrow).

As illustrated above, using Band 8a significantly reduces the discrepancy in NDVI calculations. For the ASTER dataset, this switch reduced the median relative difference in NDVI from -14.8% to -6.3%. This highlights how small band-level errors can be amplified when calculating spectral indices.

The Challenge of Universal Transformation

The study also tested linear transformation models ($OLI = Slope \times MSI + Offset$) to see if MSI data could be corrected to match OLI. A key warning for practitioners emerged: transformation models are highly sensitive to the underlying land cover. A model calibrated on one spectral library (e.g., ASTER) often performed poorly or even increased errors when applied to another (e.g., Hyperion). This suggests that there is no "universal" constant for cross-sensor calibration; corrections must likely be land-cover specific.

Conclusion

While the joint use of Sentinel-2 and Landsat 8 is promising, the differences in their spectral response functions present a significant hurdle. Achieving high consistency requires careful band selection—such as prioritizing MSI Band 8a for vegetation indices—and a recognition that simple linear transformations may not generalize across diverse landscapes. Future work must focus on developing more robust, context-aware harmonization techniques.

Summary updated

Abstract

A PRELIMINARY INVESTIGATION ON COMPARISON AND TRANSFORMATION OF SENTINEL-2 MSI AND LANDSAT 8 OLI Timely and accurate earth observation with short revisit interval is usually necessary, especially for emergency response. Currently, several new generation sensors provided with similar channel characteristics have been operated onboard different satellite platforms, including Sentinel-2 and Landsat 8. Joint use of the observations by different sensors offers an opportunity to meet the demands for emergency requirements. For example, through the combination of Landsat and Sentinel-2 data, the land can be observed every 2–3 days at medium spatial resolution. However, differences are expected in radiometric values (e.g., channel reflectance) of the corresponding channels between two sensors. Spectral response function (SRF) is taken as an important aspect of sensor settings. Accordingly, between-sensor differences due to SRFs variation need to be quantified and compensated. The comparison of SRFs shows difference (more or less) in channel settings between Sentinel-2 Multi-Spectral Instrument (MSI) and Landsat 8 Operational Land Imager (OLI). Effect of the difference in SRF on corresponding values between MSI and OLI was investigated, mainly in terms of channel reflectance and several derived spectral indices. Spectra samples from ASTER Spectral Library Version 2.0 and Hyperion data archives were used in obtaining channel reflectance simulation of MSI and OLI. Preliminary results show that MSI and OLI are well comparable in several channels with small relative discrepancy (&lt; 5 %), including the Costal Aerosol channel, a NIR (855–875 nm) channel, the SWIR channels, and the Cirrus channel. Meanwhile, for channels covering Blue, Green, Red, and NIR (785–900 nm), the between-sensor differences are significantly presented. Compared with the difference in reflectance of each individual channel, the difference in derived spectral index is more significant. In addition, effectiveness of linear transformation model is not ensured when the target belongs to another spectra collection. If an improper transformation model is selected, the between-sensor discrepancy will even largely increase. In conclusion, improvement in between-sensor consistency is possibly a challenge, through linear transformation based on model(s) generated from other spectra collections.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{chen2018preliminary,
  author = {F. Chen and Shenlong Lou and Qunqun Fan and Jonathan Li and Chunjin Wang and Martin Claverie},
  title = {{A PRELIMINARY INVESTIGATION ON COMPARISON AND TRANSFORMATION OF SENTINEL-2 MSI AND LANDSAT 8 OLI}},
  booktitle = {˜The},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.5194/isprs-archives-xlii-3-2619-2018},
}
Figure