Abstract
Visual input from the left and right visual fields is processed predominantly in the contralateral hemisphere. Here we investigated whether this preference for contralateral over ipsilateral stimuli is also found in high-level visual areas that are important for the recognition of objects and faces. Human subjects were scanned with functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) while they viewed and attended faces, objects, scenes, and scrambled images in the left or right visual field. With our stimulation protocol, primary visual cortex responded only to contralateral stimuli. The contralateral preference was smaller in object- and face-selective regions, and it was smallest in the fusiform gyrus. Nevertheless, each region showed a significant preference for contralateral stimuli. These results indicate that sensitivity to stimulus position is present even in high-level ventral visual cortex.
Introduction
A central question in visual neuroscience is the extent to which high-level visual areas represent spatial information. While early visual areas like the primary visual cortex (V1) are strictly retinotopic—mapping specific points in the visual field to specific neural locations—higher-level areas in the ventral stream are often characterized as "position-invariant." These areas, such as the Lateral Occipital (LO) complex and the Fusiform Face Area (FFA), are specialized for identifying what an object is, rather than where it is.
This study by Hemond, Kanwisher, and Op de Beeck (2007) challenges the notion of complete position invariance. By measuring brain activity in response to stimuli presented in the left or right visual fields, the researchers sought to determine if a contralateral bias—a preference for the opposite side of space—persists into the most specialized regions of the human visual system.
Methods
The researchers used functional Magnetic Resonance Imaging (fMRI) to monitor the brain activity of nine healthy subjects.
Stimuli and Task
Subjects viewed four categories of images: human faces, common objects, outdoor scenes, and Fourier-scrambled versions of these images. Images were presented for 300ms in blocks, appearing either to the left or the right of a central fixation point (1 degree of visual angle away). To ensure subjects maintained fixation and attention, they performed a color change detection task on the stimuli.
Regions of Interest (ROIs)
The study identified five key regions in each subject's brain to track the progression of spatial bias:
- V1-2: Early visual cortex.
- LO: Lateral occipital (object-selective).
- OFA: Occipital face area.
- PF: Posterior fusiform (object-selective).
- FFA: Fusiform face area.
Key Results
The researchers quantified the spatial bias using a Preference Index: (Contralateral - Ipsilateral) / Contralateral.
- The Gradient of Invariance: The study confirmed a clear spatial gradient. V1-2 acted as a "hard" gate, showing a preference index of nearly 1.0, meaning it responded almost exclusively to stimuli on the opposite side. This also served as a control, proving subjects maintained fixation.
- Mid-Level Bias: Areas LO and OFA showed a strong but reduced bias (index ~0.5). In these regions, the response to the "wrong" side was roughly half that of the "correct" side.
- High-Level Persistence: Even in the highest-level areas, PF and FFA, a statistically significant contralateral bias remained (index ~0.15 to 0.2). While these areas are more tolerant of position, they are not truly position-invariant.
- Objects vs. Faces: The contralateral preference in the object-selective LO area was notably stronger than in the face-selective OFA, suggesting that spatial "anchoring" may vary by stimulus category.
Discussion
These findings demonstrate that "where" information is preserved even in the "what" pathway of the human brain. The preference for contralateral stimuli in high-level areas like the FFA suggests that these regions are not purely abstract category detectors but remain rooted in the spatial organization of the visual system.
This bias may serve an evolutionary purpose, perhaps priming the motor system to move the eyes toward a recognized object in the periphery. Furthermore, the similarity between these human fMRI results and previous electrophysiological data from macaques suggests that this contralateral preference is a fundamental, conserved feature of the primate visual hierarchy.
Limitations
The authors note that because stimulus location and the focus of attention were identical in this study, the measured bias likely reflects a combination of sensory input and spatial attention. Future research is needed to decouple these factors. Additionally, while the sample size (n=9) was standard for 2007, larger modern cohorts could further refine these preference indices.
Summary updated