A practical perspective on the potential of rechargeable Mg batteries

J. Alberto Blázquez, Rudi Ruben Maça, Olatz Leonet, Eneko Azaceta, Ayan Mukherjee, Zhirong Zhao‐Karger, Zhenyou Li, A. A. Kovalevsky, Ana Fernández‐Barquín, Aroa R. Mainar, Piotr Jankowski, Laurin Rademacher, Sunita Dey, Siân E. Dutton, Clare P. Grey, Janina Drews, Joachim Häcker, Timo Danner, Arnulf Latz, Dane Sotta, M. Rosa Palacín, Jean‐Frédéric Martin, J. M. García‐Lastra, Maximilian Fichtner, Sumana Kundu, Alexander Kraytsberg, Yair Ein‐Eli, Malachi Noked, Doron AurbachEnergy 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper bridges the gap between laboratory-scale research and industrial reality for rechargeable magnesium batteries (RMBs). The authors report the first non-aqueous multilayer RMB pouch cell prototypes and outline a strategic roadmap to achieve energy densities of ~160 Wh/kg by optimizing electrolytes, current collectors, and electrode materials.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

While Lithium-ion batteries (LIBs) dominate the market, they face significant sustainability and supply-chain hurdles due to the scarcity and uneven distribution of lithium, cobalt, and nickel. Magnesium is a compelling alternative: it is the 8th most abundant element in Earth’s crust, safer to handle, and theoretically offers high volumetric capacity without the same dendrite-growth risks that plague lithium.

However, most RMB research remains confined to "coin cells"—small, laboratory-scale setups that use a massive excess of electrolyte and thick magnesium foils. These setups hide critical engineering flaws, such as the weight of heavy nickel current collectors and poor "dead volume" management. This paper addresses the "technology readiness level" (TRL) gap by moving RMBs into a pouch cell format, which is a much more accurate predictor of commercial performance.

Methods

The researchers moved beyond single-layer experiments to develop multilayer RMB pouch cell prototypes. Their approach involved:

  • Format Transition: Moving from coin cells to stacked pouch cells (44 x 61 mm) to optimize the electrolyte-to-capacity ratio.
  • Electrolyte Evolution: Comparing the benchmark "All Phenyl Complex" (APC) electrolyte—which is corrosive to aluminum—with newer, non-corrosive boron-based salts like $Mg[B(hfip)_4]_2$ in dimethoxyethane (DME).
  • Anode Engineering: Evaluating thin foils of AZ31 magnesium alloy (96% Mg, 3% Al, 1% Zn) as a more ductile and manufacturable alternative to pure, brittle Mg foil.
  • Cathode Comparison: Using the standard Chevrel-phase ($Mo_6S_8$) as a baseline and modeling the impact of high-capacity $VS_4$ cathodes.
  • Mass Distribution Analysis: A detailed breakdown of how each component (separator, current collector, electrolyte) contributes to the total weight of the battery.

Datasets

As an experimental and perspective paper, it does not use external training datasets. Instead, it generates original experimental data on:

  • Publication Trends: A meta-analysis of RMB research over the last two decades (Fig. 1).
  • Electrolyte Performance: Comparative data on ionic conductivity and electrochemical windows for various liquid and solid-state electrolytes (Table 1).
  • Cell Metrics: A comprehensive comparison of cell components and energy densities across four "generations" of RMB designs (Table 2).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Coin Cell Illusion": In typical lab coin cells, there is a 214-fold excess of magnesium and a massive "flooded" electrolyte volume. This results in a measly energy density of ~2 Wh/kg. Simply moving to a pouch cell architecture with better balancing immediately boosts this to 18 Wh/kg using the same chemistry.
  • The Aluminum Advantage: Standard RMB electrolytes contain chlorides that corrode aluminum, forcing researchers to use heavy nickel current collectors. By switching to chloride-free boron-based electrolytes, the authors can use lightweight aluminum foils, reducing current collector weight by 82%.
  • AZ31 as a Practical Hero: Pure magnesium is difficult to manufacture into the ultra-thin foils (<25 µm) needed for high energy density. The AZ31 alloy provides the necessary ductility for industrial processing while maintaining electrochemical performance similar to pure Mg.
  • The $VS_4$ Leap: While the Chevrel-phase cathode is stable, its low voltage limits energy density. Transitioning to $VS_4$ (a chain-like structure that allows easy Mg-ion transport) is identified as the key to breaking the 100 Wh/kg barrier.

Key Results

  • Prototype Success: The authors demonstrated a first-generation pouch cell with 18 Wh/kg and 100% capacity retention over 200 cycles.
  • The Roadmap: Through systematic improvements, the paper projects a path to 157 Wh/kg (4th Generation).
  • Mass Optimization: By optimizing the design, the "inactive" mass (current collectors and electrolyte) was reduced from nearly 65% of the cell weight in coin cells to a projected 40% in advanced pouch cells.
  • Anode Balancing: The excess of magnesium was reduced from a 214-fold excess in coin cells to a realistic 1.7-fold excess in the 4th generation model.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Cycle Life of Advanced Chemistries: While the 1st-gen (Chevrel-phase) cell showed excellent cycling, the authors acknowledge that high-capacity cathodes like $VS_4$ and high-voltage oxides still face challenges regarding long-term stability and electrolyte compatibility.
  • Voltage Windows: Current electrolytes are stable up to ~3V. To truly compete with high-end LIBs, RMBs need electrolytes that can handle even higher voltages without decomposing.
  • Kinetics: Divalent $Mg^{2+}$ ions interact more strongly with crystal lattices than monovalent $Li^+$ ions, often leading to slower charging/discharging speeds. Further work on "open" cathode structures is required to improve power density.

Summary updated

Abstract

Emerging energy storage systems based on abundant and cost-effective materials are key to overcome the global energy and climate crisis of the 21st century.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{blazquez2023practical,
  author = {J. Alberto Blázquez and Rudi Ruben Maça and Olatz Leonet and Eneko Azaceta and Ayan Mukherjee and Zhirong Zhao‐Karger and Zhenyou Li and A. A. Kovalevsky and Ana Fernández‐Barquín and Aroa R. Mainar and Piotr Jankowski and Laurin Rademacher and Sunita Dey and Siân E. Dutton and Clare P. Grey and Janina Drews and Joachim Häcker and Timo Danner and Arnulf Latz and Dane Sotta and M. Rosa Palacín and Jean‐Frédéric Martin and J. M. García‐Lastra and Maximilian Fichtner and Sumana Kundu and Alexander Kraytsberg and Yair Ein‐Eli and Malachi Noked and Doron Aurbach},
  title = {{A practical perspective on the potential of rechargeable Mg batteries}},
  booktitle = {Energy},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1039/d2ee04121a},
}
Figure