A possible detection of the cosmic antineutrino background in the presence of flavor effects

Yufeng Li, Zhi‐zhong XingPhysics 2011 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

Standard cosmological models predict a relic background of neutrinos and antineutrinos from the Big Bang, known as the Cosmic Neutrino Background ($C\nu B$). Due to their extremely low kinetic energies, these particles remain one of the most elusive targets in experimental physics. This paper investigates the feasibility of detecting the cosmic antineutrino background ($C\bar{ u}B$) through thresholdless capture on the radioactive isotope Holmium-163 ($^{163}\text{Ho}$). By incorporating the effects of neutrino flavor mixing and mass hierarchy, the study demonstrates that the capture signal is highly sensitive to the underlying neutrino mass structure. Achieving a successful detection requires significant advancements in calorimetric energy resolution and the acquisition of substantial isotope masses.

Introduction

The Cosmic Neutrino Background ($C\nu B$) is a fundamental prediction of the Big Bang theory, representing a snapshot of the universe just one second after its birth. While the Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) has been mapped with high precision, the $C\nu B$ remains undetected because its constituents have cooled to approximately 1.95 K ($E \sim 10^{-4}$ eV). Traditional neutrino detection methods, which rely on high-energy interactions, are ineffective for such low-energy relics.

A promising alternative is the "thresholdless capture" of relic neutrinos on unstable nuclei. In this process, the energy released by the neutrino capture is added to the decay energy, creating a signal just beyond the endpoint of the natural decay spectrum. While Tritium ($^3\text{H}$) is the most famous candidate for neutrino capture, this research focuses on the capture of antineutrinos using $^{163}\text{Ho}$, specifically examining how neutrino flavor oscillations and mass hierarchies influence the observable spectrum.

Theoretical Framework

The detection method relies on comparing two competing processes involving the isotope $^{163}\text{Ho}$:

  1. Natural Electron Capture (EC): $^{163}\text{Ho} + e^- \to ^{163}\text{Dy}^* + \nu_e$
  2. Relic Antineutrino Capture: $\bar{ u}_e + ^{163}\text{Ho} + e^- \to ^{163}\text{Dy}^*$

The natural EC decay produces a continuous spectrum of energy, ending at a specific $Q$-value. The relic antineutrino capture, however, produces a distinct peak (or series of peaks) located at an energy $E = Q + m_{\nu}$, where $m_{\nu}$ is the mass of the captured antineutrino.

To model this accurately, the authors utilize a Breit-Wigner resonance profile to describe the atomic levels of the Dysprosium daughter atom ($^{163}\text{Dy}^*$). To account for experimental limitations, the theoretical sharp lines are convolved with a Gaussian resolution function characterized by a width $\Delta$.

The Impact of Flavor Effects

Unlike earlier studies that treated neutrinos as single-mass particles, this work incorporates the $3 \times 3$ PMNS (Pontecorvo-Maki-Nakagawa-Sakata) mixing matrix. This framework accounts for the fact that the electron antineutrino ($\bar{ u}_e$) is a superposition of three mass eigenstates ($m_1, m_2, m_3$).

The study evaluates two possible mass orderings:

  • Normal Hierarchy (NH): $m_1 < m_2 < m_3$
  • Inverted Hierarchy (IH): $m_3 < m_1 < m_2$

The results indicate that flavor effects significantly alter the predicted capture rate and the shape of the resulting spectrum. In the Inverted Hierarchy scenario, the flavor effects are more pronounced, potentially making the signal easier to distinguish from the background. Specifically, the endpoint of the background spectrum shows greater sensitivity to the mixing angle $\theta_{13}$ under the IH assumption. If experimental resolution were perfect, this method would effectively allow researchers to "weigh" each neutrino mass eigenstate simultaneously.

Experimental Requirements and Challenges

The primary challenge in detecting the $C\bar{ u}B$ is the required energy resolution. The signal peak is separated from the natural decay endpoint by the mass of the lightest neutrino. To prevent the natural EC background from overwhelming the relic signal, the authors calculate that an energy resolution (FWHM) of approximately $0.015$ eV is necessary. At the time of the study, this requirement was nearly two orders of magnitude beyond the capabilities of state-of-the-art calorimetric detectors.

Furthermore, the capture rate is relatively low. Using a reference target mass of 30 kg of $^{163}\text{Ho}$, the authors provide a benchmark for the scale of a future experiment. While 30 kg is a massive quantity for such a rare isotope, it serves to illustrate the industrial and financial hurdles involved. Additionally, the authors note that a larger $Q$-value actually suppresses the capture rate, making isotopes with the smallest possible $Q$-values the most desirable targets.

Conclusion

Detecting the cosmic antineutrino background using $^{163}\text{Ho}$ is theoretically possible but remains experimentally daunting. This research highlights that neutrino flavor physics is a critical component in predicting the capture signal accurately. While current technology is not yet capable of the $0.015$ eV resolution required, this work provides a clear roadmap for the sensitivity and scale needed for future "fossil" neutrino observatories. Future considerations may also include gravitational clustering; if neutrinos are sufficiently heavy, they might cluster around the Earth, potentially increasing the local density and the resulting signal strength.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2011possible,
  author = {Yufeng Li and Zhi‐zhong Xing},
  title = {{A possible detection of the cosmic antineutrino background in the presence of flavor effects}},
  booktitle = {Physics},
  year = {2011},
  doi = {10.1016/j.physletb.2011.03.044},
}
Figure