A possible characteristic of foreshocks derived from the evaluation of loading/unloading induced by earth tides

Huaizhong Yu, Jie Liu, Yawei Ma, Rui Yan, Chen Yu, Shengle Li, Zhigao Yang, Min Hong, Hongwei Tu, Zhiwei Zhang, Binbin Zhao, Yuchuan MaFrontiers in Earth Science 2022 · DOI

Abstract

The detection of the potential of a larger event immediately after a moderate earthquake is a quite difficult problem. In this work, we devised an approach to determine whether an earthquake is a foreshock to a larger mainshock by evaluating loading/unloading states. This is done by calculating the Coulomb failure stress (CFS) change induced by Earth tides along the tectonically preferred slip direction on the seismogenic fault surface of each of the candidates. The technique is based on the load/unload response ratio (LURR) method, but the determination of the sliding direction of CFS is different, which is derived from the moderate earthquake that has just occurred rather than the assumption from the regional stress setting. Using the approach, we tested since the year 2000 the $M_s \geq 4.0$ foreshocks of the $M_s \geq 6.0$ earthquakes on the Chinese mainland, and also the earthquake swarms where no subsequent larger mainshocks were expected in the previous 10 years. The former mostly occurred in the loading process, while the latter arose more frequently in a random process. The marked difference indicates that the occurrence of earthquakes during loading may imply the critical state of the seismogenic faults, and the derived stress is more likely to trigger a larger event than that of the earthquakes that occurred during unloading.

Introduction

Identifying a foreshock is one of the "holy grails" of seismology. If scientists could reliably determine that a moderate earthquake (e.g., $M_s 4.0$) is a precursor to a major event ($M_s 6.0+$), they could provide life-saving early warnings. However, most moderate earthquakes are part of "swarms" that dissipate without a larger mainshock. This study proposes a refined approach to distinguish true foreshocks by analyzing the subtle stress changes caused by Earth tides.

Methodology: Refined LURR and Focal Mechanisms

The core of this research lies in refining the Load/Unload Response Ratio (LURR) method. Traditional LURR models often rely on broad assumptions about regional tectonic stress. This study improves accuracy by integrating the specific focal mechanism—the direction and angle of the slip—of the moderate earthquake that has just occurred to calculate tidal stress more accurately.

The relationship between tectonic-induced ($\vec{\tau}^T$) and tide-induced ($\vec{\tau}^t$) effective shear stresses in the slip direction ($\vec{u}$).

By calculating the rate of change of tidal stress ($p$), researchers can determine if the fault is in a "loading" phase ($p > 0$), where the tide is pushing the fault toward failure, or an "unloading" phase ($p < 0$).

The Critical State and LURR

The underlying theory suggests that a fault system near failure responds differently to external stress. In the elastic stage, the response to loading and unloading is nearly identical. However, as the fault reaches a "critical state" (the yield or dilatant stage), it becomes highly sensitive to even the infinitesimal stress changes induced by Earth tides—stresses 100 to 1000 times smaller than tectonic forces.

The variation of LURR relative to the rock constitutive curve, showing the transition from the elastic stage to failure.

When a fault is at its breaking point, earthquakes are "modulated" by the tide, occurring predominantly when the tide is actively pushing the fault toward failure. In non-threatening earthquake swarms, the timing of quakes relative to tides is essentially random.

Empirical Evidence and Key Results

The researchers tested this model against seismic history on the Chinese mainland since 2000, focusing on $M_s \geq 4.0$ foreshocks of $M_s \geq 6.0$ earthquakes and non-precursory earthquake swarms from the last 10 years.

  • Foreshock Correlation: In 15 out of 16 major earthquake cases involving multiple foreshocks, the events occurred during the tidal loading process.
  • Swarm Contrast: In "harmless" swarms, no more than 30% of events occurred during loading. Crucially, no earthquakes in these swarms occurred consecutively during loading phases.
  • Probability Gain: While a single quake during loading offers a 3% probability gain, two consecutive quakes during loading phases increase the probability gain to 60%. The method achieved an R-score of 0.85, significantly outperforming traditional forecasting models.

Discussion and Limitations

While promising, the proposed "Red-Yellow-Green" traffic-light model faces real-world challenges. Calculating the focal mechanism currently takes approximately 20 minutes, which must be reduced for effective real-time early warning. Additionally, the sample size of 16 mainshock-foreshock sequences is small, requiring further global validation. Geothermally active regions, such as parts of Tibet, may also require adjusted calculations due to fluid movement affecting fault response.

Integrating this tidal evaluation into existing real-time seismic monitoring networks could provide a dynamic, high-confidence risk assessment following any moderate earthquake, potentially identifying the critical state of seismogenic faults before a disaster strikes.

Summary updated

Abstract

The detection of the potential of a larger event immediately after a moderate earthquake is a quite difficult problem. In this work, we devised an approach to determine whether an earthquake is a foreshock to a larger mainshock by evaluating loading/unloading states. This is done by calculating the Coulomb failure stress ( CFS ) change induced by Earth tides along the tectonically preferred slip direction on the seismogenic fault surface of each of the candidates. The technique is based on the load/unload response ratio (LURR) method, but the determination of the sliding direction of CFS is different, which is derived from the moderate earthquake that has just occurred rather than the assumption from the regional stress setting. Using the approach, we tested since the year 2000 the M s ≥ 4.0 foreshocks of the M s ≥ 6.0 earthquakes on the Chinese mainland, and also the earthquake swarms where no subsequent larger mainshocks were expected in the previous 10 years. The former mostly occurred in the loading process, while the latter arose more frequently in a random process. The marked difference indicates that the occurrence of earthquakes during loading may imply the critical state of the seismogenic faults, and the derived stress is more likely to trigger a larger event than that of the earthquakes that occurred during unloading.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{yu2022possible,
  author = {Huaizhong Yu and Jie Liu and Yawei Ma and Rui Yan and Chen Yu and Shengle Li and Zhigao Yang and Min Hong and Hongwei Tu and Zhiwei Zhang and Binbin Zhao and Yuchuan Ma},
  title = {{A possible characteristic of foreshocks derived from the evaluation of loading/unloading induced by earth tides}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Earth Science},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3389/feart.2022.967264},
}
Figure