A Possibilistic Model for Qualitative Sequential Decision Problems under Uncertainty in Partially Observable Environments

Régis SabbadinUAI 1999

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel framework for sequential decision-making under uncertainty, called Possibilistic Partially Observable Markov Decision Processes (II-POMDPs). It extends traditional POMDPs by using possibility distributions to model uncertainty and preferences, offering a qualitative, ordinal approach that avoids the infinite belief state spaces often encountered in stochastic POMDPs.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Sequential decision-making under uncertainty is a fundamental problem in artificial intelligence. The standard approach, Partially Observable Markov Decision Processes (POMDPs), models uncertainty using probability distributions. While powerful, POMDPs face significant challenges in practice. Even for problems with a finite number of states, the "belief state" (representing the agent's uncertainty about the true state) can become infinite. This makes exact computation of optimal policies computationally intractable. This paper addresses this by proposing a qualitative, "possibilistic" alternative that uses possibility distributions instead of probability distributions. This approach aims to maintain a finite belief state space, making the problem more tractable.

Methods

The core of this paper is the development of a possibilistic framework for sequential decision problems. Key methods include:

  • Possibility Distributions: Instead of probabilities, the paper uses possibility distributions to represent uncertainty about state transitions and observations, and preferences over outcomes. These distributions take values from a finite ordinal scale (e.g., {0, 0.5, 1}).
  • Sugeno Integral: The decision criterion is based on the Sugeno integral, which is presented as an ordinal counterpart to the Choquet integral and generalizes the expected utility criterion.
  • Possibilistic Markov Decision Processes (II-MDPs): The paper first extends standard MDPs to a possibilistic setting for fully observable multistage decision problems. It introduces algorithms like possibilistic backwards induction and possibilistic value iteration to find optimal policies.
  • Possibilistic Conditioning: To handle partial observability, the paper defines a notion of possibilistic conditioning. This is crucial for updating the agent's belief state when observations are made.
  • Possibilistic POMDPs (II-POMDPs): The framework is then extended to partially observable environments. The authors show that II-POMDPs can be transformed into II-MDPs over a finite, albeit potentially large, possibilistic belief state space.
  • Algorithms for II-POMDPs: A possibilistic value iteration algorithm is adapted to solve II-POMDPs, operating on the possibilistic belief state space.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper uses a toy example of a robot in a room to illustrate its concepts and algorithms.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Qualitative Decision-Making: The paper demonstrates that a qualitative, ordinal approach using possibility theory can effectively model decision problems under uncertainty, offering an alternative to probabilistic methods.
  • Finite Belief State Space: A major advantage highlighted is the ability to maintain a finite belief state space, even with partial observability, which is a significant computational advantage over traditional POMDPs.
  • Pessimistic Criterion: The paper focuses on the "pessimistic" possibilistic decision criterion, which is shown to be more conservative and guarantees that policies eventually lead to non-unsatisfactory states, unlike the "adventurous" criterion.
  • Decomposability: The possibilistic framework allows for a decomposability of multistage decision problems, enabling the use of dynamic programming-like algorithms.
  • Possibilistic Conditioning is Key: The definition and application of possibilistic conditioning are central to extending the framework to partially observable environments.

Key Results

The paper proposes a theoretical framework and algorithms for solving qualitative sequential decision problems under uncertainty in partially observable environments. The primary result is the definition of II-POMDPs and the associated possibilistic value iteration algorithm that can compute optimal policies. The paper demonstrates that this approach can handle problems that are intractable for standard POMDPs due to infinite belief state spaces. An example with a robot in a room illustrates the computation of an optimal policy.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Computational Complexity: While the belief state space is finite, it can still be exponentially larger than the original state space, leading to high computational complexity. The paper acknowledges this worst-case complexity.
  • Uniqueness of Conditioning: The paper notes that possibilistic conditioning is not uniquely defined, and the chosen approach is based on minimum specificity.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that the compatibility of the possibilistic decision criterion with structured representations of decision problems, particularly in possibilistic logic, could lead to more structured languages and algorithms for II-POMDPs. They also mention that the framework could be extended to handle more complex scenarios, such as those involving non-stationary environments or more sophisticated preference structures.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{sabbadin1999possibilistic,
  author = {Régis Sabbadin},
  title = {{A Possibilistic Model for Qualitative Sequential Decision Problems under Uncertainty in Partially Observable Environments}},
  booktitle = {Conference on Uncertainty in Artificial Intelligence},
  year = {1999},
}
Figure