A Portable Tunable Diode Laser Absorption Spectroscopy System for Dissolved CO2 Detection Using a High-Efficiency Headspace Equilibrator

Zhihao Zhang, Meng Li, Jinjia Guo, Baolu Du, Ronger Zheng2021 · DOI

TL;DR

Researchers have developed a compact, portable system using tunable diode laser absorption spectroscopy (TDLAS) to measure dissolved CO2 in surface seawater in real-time. This system, featuring an improved headspace equilibrator, offers faster response times and high precision, making it suitable for underway measurements crucial for understanding ocean carbon cycles.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The ocean plays a critical role in absorbing atmospheric carbon dioxide (CO2), helping to mitigate climate change. However, the increasing levels of CO2 are altering ocean chemistry, leading to acidification. To understand these complex processes and the ocean's role in the global carbon cycle, accurate, high-resolution measurements of dissolved CO2 (specifically its partial pressure, pCO2) in surface waters are essential. Existing methods, like gas chromatography (GC) and membrane injection mass spectrometry (MIMS), have limitations such as slow sampling rates, large instrument size, and complex operation, hindering real-time, continuous underway measurements. While optical methods like NDIR, Raman, CRDS, and OA-ICOS offer advantages, they also have drawbacks like poor selectivity, insufficient sensitivity, or complex setups. TDLAS, known for its selectivity, cost-effectiveness, and environmental adaptability, shows promise for this application, but its use in underway oceanic pCO2 measurements has been limited. This paper aims to bridge this gap by presenting a portable TDLAS system designed for rapid, continuous dissolved CO2 detection in surface seawater.

Methods

The core of the system is a portable Tunable Diode Laser Absorption Spectroscopy (TDLAS) setup integrated into a compact aluminum alloy chamber. The TDLAS principle relies on a tunable diode laser emitting at a specific wavelength (4991.26 cm⁻¹) that is characteristic of CO2 absorption. By scanning the laser wavelength and measuring the absorption of the light, the CO2 concentration in the gas phase can be determined.

Key methodological innovations include:

  • High-Efficiency Headspace Equilibrator: This is a novel, home-made device designed to efficiently transfer dissolved CO2 from seawater into a gas phase for TDLAS analysis. It combines both spray and bubble methods to maximize the gas-liquid contact area, significantly improving gas-liquid separation efficiency and reducing response time by approximately 50% compared to traditional "shower head" systems.
  • Multi-Pass Gas Cell (MPGC): A customized MPGC with an effective optical path length of over 11 meters was designed to enhance sensitivity while maintaining a small internal volume (<80 mL) for a faster dynamic response.
  • Integrated System Design: The optical detection and sample extraction components are integrated into a single portable chamber, reducing gas pipeline volume and improving portability and response time.
  • Empirical Equation for Gas-to-Liquid Conversion: The researchers derived an empirical equation to convert the measured gas-phase CO2 concentration to the aqueous-phase concentration, accounting for factors like temperature and salinity.
  • TDLAS-WMS: The system utilizes wavelength modulation spectroscopy (WMS) to improve sensitivity for weak signal detection.

Datasets

The paper describes calibration and validation using:

  • Certified Calibration Gases: Four dry, certified calibration gases with concentrations of 398, 808, 1006, and 2019 ppmv were used for system calibration. An additional checkpoint gas of 601 ppmv was also used for verification.
  • Fresh Tap Water: A sample of fresh tap water was used to test the system's ability to measure dissolved CO2 in a known, low-CO2 environment.
  • Laboratory Atmosphere: Ambient CO2 levels were monitored in a laboratory setting for approximately 40 hours, comparing the TDLAS system's performance against a commercial GGA (off-axis integrated cavity output spectroscopy) instrument.
  • Jiaozhou Bay Field Data: Real-time underway measurements of dissolved CO2 were conducted in Jiaozhou Bay, Qingdao, China, at various stations representing different environmental conditions (estuaries, human activity areas, bay center, and bay mouth).

No new benchmark datasets were introduced; rather, existing calibration gases and real-world environmental conditions were used for evaluation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Shower Head" is Outdated: The paper highlights that traditional headspace equilibrators are inefficient. Their novel spray-and-bubble approach significantly speeds up the gas-liquid equilibrium process, crucial for real-time measurements.
  • Portability and Integration are Key: Combining the optical detection and gas sampling into a single, compact unit is a major step towards practical, deployable oceanographic sensors. This reduces complexity and potential sources of error.
  • TDLAS is a Viable Alternative: The study demonstrates that TDLAS, when coupled with an efficient sampling system, can achieve the necessary sensitivity and speed for oceanic pCO2 monitoring, offering a competitive alternative to other spectroscopic methods.
  • Understanding Ocean Carbon Dynamics Requires Speed: The fast response times achieved (as low as 20 seconds for certain concentration changes) are critical for capturing the rapid spatial and temporal variations in oceanic pCO2, which are often missed by slower methods.

Key Results

  • Monitoring Precision: A precision of 0.5% was achieved with time-series measurements.
  • Detection Limits: The system demonstrated a limit of detection (LOD) of 2.3 ppmv at a 1-second integration time and 0.1 ppmv at a 128-second integration time.
  • Fast Response Time: The improved headspace equilibrator achieved response times of approximately 41 seconds for a 3079 ppmv concentration span and as fast as 20 seconds for a 1902 ppmv span. The fastest response time, after accounting for delay, was around 41 seconds.
  • Calibration Accuracy: The system showed good agreement with calibration gases, with a fitting relative error of less than 2% and a R-squared value greater than 0.999.
  • Laboratory Comparison: The TDLAS system showed high consistency with a commercial GGA instrument in laboratory atmosphere monitoring, with a linear fitting correlation coefficient of 0.973.
  • Field Measurement: Underway measurements in Jiaozhou Bay revealed significant spatial variations in dissolved CO2 (550-820 ppmv), with trends explained by surface runoff, human activities, and geographic position.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Focus on pCO2: The current system is designed to measure only dissolved CO2. The authors suggest that the sample extraction device has the potential to detect other dissolved gases, such as methane, which could be explored in future research.
  • Delay Time Subtraction: While the response time was significantly improved, the calculation of the "fastest response time" involved subtracting a "delay time" related to reagent mixing and reaction, which are not present in natural aquatic systems.
  • Limited Data for Afc and T90 Relationship: The paper notes that the available data for the relationship between concentration change (Afc) and response time (T90) was insufficient for a more quantitative conclusion, though a trend was observed.
  • Future Work: The authors propose exploring the detection of other dissolved gases and further optimizing the system for long-term, robust deployment in marine environments.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@misc{zhang2021portable,
  author = {Zhihao Zhang and Meng Li and Jinjia Guo and Baolu Du and Ronger Zheng},
  title = {{A Portable Tunable Diode Laser Absorption Spectroscopy System for Dissolved CO2 Detection Using a High-Efficiency Headspace Equilibrator}},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.3390/s21051723},
}

Loading related content...

Figure