A Population of Heavily Reddened, Optically Missed Novae from Palomar Gattini-IR: Constraints on the Galactic Nova Rate

Kishalay De, M. M. Kasliwal, M. Hankins, J. L. Sokoloski, S. M. Adams, M. C. B. Ashley, A. Babul, Ashot Bagdasaryan, Alexandre Delacroix, Richard Dekany, Timothée Greffe, David Hale, J. Jencson, Viraj Karambelkar, Ryan M. Lau, A. Mahabal, D. McKenna, Anna Moore, E. O. Ofek, M. Sharma, Roger M. Smith, Jamie Soon, Roberto Soria, Gokul P. Srinivasaragavan, Samaporn Tinyanont, Tony Travouillon, Anastasios Tzanidakis, Yuhan YaoThe Astrophysical Journal 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper uses the Palomar Gattini-IR (PGIR) near-infrared survey to identify a population of heavily dust-obscured Galactic novae that are missed by optical surveys. By simulating the survey's detection efficiency, they derive a new estimate for the Galactic nova rate of ~46 yr⁻¹, suggesting that previous estimates have underestimated the true rate due to dust extinction.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The rate of novae in our Milky Way galaxy is a crucial but poorly constrained parameter. It's vital for understanding how elements are synthesized and distributed in the galaxy, and it also provides clues about the progenitors of Type Ia supernovae. Previous estimates for the Galactic nova rate have varied wildly (10-300 yr⁻¹) and relied on either extrapolating from a few very bright optical novae or scaling from nova rates in other galaxies. Both methods have significant uncertainties. A major challenge is that optical surveys only detect a small fraction of the expected number of novae (around 5-10 yr⁻¹), even with advanced all-sky surveys. This discrepancy suggests that a significant number of novae are either too faint or too obscured by interstellar dust to be seen in optical wavelengths.

Methods

The authors leverage the Palomar Gattini-IR (PGIR) survey, which operates in the J-band (around 1.2 µm). Near-infrared light is much less affected by dust extinction than optical light, making it ideal for finding obscured objects. They developed a detection pipeline that identifies large-amplitude transients in the PGIR data. Candidates were then vetted by human observers and followed up with spectroscopic observations for confirmation.

To estimate the Galactic nova rate, they performed detailed simulations of the PGIR survey. This involved:

  1. Simulating nova populations: They generated synthetic nova populations distributed according to the Milky Way's stellar mass distribution.
  2. Modeling extinction: They used 3D dust maps of the Milky Way to estimate the extinction each simulated nova would experience.
  3. Simulating survey detection: They modeled the PGIR survey's actual observing schedule and its known detection efficiency (which varies with sky position and source brightness) to determine which simulated novae would have been detected.
  4. Monte Carlo simulations: By running many simulations with different input Galactic nova rates, they compared the simulated number of detected novae to the observed number (12 novae) to find the best-fit rate and its uncertainty.

Datasets

  • Palomar Gattini-IR (PGIR) survey data: This is the primary dataset, comprising 17 months of J-band time-domain observations.
  • Zwicky Transient Facility (ZTF) data: Publicly available g-band and r-band data were used for multi-color light curve analysis.
  • Archival optical and near-infrared spectra: Data from telescopes like Keck-I, IRTF, P200, and SSO were used for spectroscopic classification and extinction measurements.
  • Extragalactic nova samples: Data from previous optical surveys (e.g., Özdönmez et al. 2016, 2018) were used for comparison.
  • Milky Way mass and dust models: Data from Cautun et al. (2020) and Green et al. (2019) were used to model the distribution of stars and dust in the Galaxy.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Invisible" Nova Population: The most striking finding is the strong evidence for a large population of heavily dust-obscured novae that are systematically missed by optical surveys. The PGIR sample shows a much higher extinction distribution than optically selected samples, with over 50% of novae having an extinction of A_V ≥ 5 magnitudes.
  • Near-Infrared Surveys are Key: This work highlights the crucial role of wide-field, near-infrared time-domain surveys like PGIR for obtaining a complete census of Galactic novae. Their J-band sensitivity allows them to pierce through dust that blinds optical telescopes.
  • Dust Extinction is a Major Factor: The study directly links the discrepancy between expected and observed optical nova rates to dust extinction, showing that the PGIR sample's extinction distribution aligns well with dust models of the Milky Way.
  • Refined Galactic Nova Rate: By combining observational data with sophisticated simulations, the paper provides a more robust estimate of the Galactic nova rate, suggesting previous estimates were too low.

Key Results

  • Sample of 12 Confirmed Novae: The PGIR survey detected and spectroscopically confirmed 12 Galactic novae in its first 17 months of operation.
  • High Extinction: Over 50% of the PGIR sample novae are obscured by A_V ≥ 5 magnitudes, a stark contrast to optically selected samples.
  • Statistically Significant Difference: A Kolmogorov-Smirnov (KS) test and Anderson-Darling (AD) test showed a null-hypothesis probability of < 0.01% when comparing the PGIR and optical extinction distributions, confirming they probe different populations.
  • Galactic Nova Rate Estimate: The paper derives a Galactic nova rate of 46.0 +12.5 / -12.4 yr⁻¹. This is higher than rates estimated from nearby galaxies but consistent with some previous estimates based on local solar neighborhood novae.
  • Detection Efficiency: The PGIR survey's detection efficiency was quantified, showing it's high at higher galactic latitudes but reduced in the crowded and dusty galactic plane.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Assumptions in Rate Estimation: The nova rate estimate relies on assumptions about the uniformity of the nova luminosity function and the Maximum Magnitude Rate of Decline (MMRD) relationship. The paper acknowledges that variations in these assumptions (e.g., brighter Milky Way novae, or distinct bulge/disk populations) can lead to slightly different rate estimates, though still consistent within errors. The presence of faint and fast novae, which are harder to detect, could mean the current estimate is an underestimate.
  • Limited Sample Size: While significant, the sample of 12 novae is still relatively small, especially for constraining the precise contributions of bulge versus disk novae.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that upcoming NIR wide-field surveys with finer pixel scales and southern hemisphere coverage (like DREAMS and PRIME) will be crucial for obtaining a more complete census of novae, particularly in the dust-obscured Galactic bulge. Combining data from these surveys with PGIR data will help accurately constrain the relative bulge and disk nova rates.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract The nova rate in the Milky Way remains largely uncertain, despite its vital importance in constraining models of Galactic chemical evolution as well as understanding progenitor channels for Type Ia supernovae. The rate has been previously estimated to be in the range of ≈10–300 yr −1 , either based on extrapolations from a handful of very bright optical novae or the nova rates in nearby galaxies; both methods are subject to debatable assumptions. The total discovery rate of optical novae remains much smaller (≈5–10 yr −1 ) than these estimates, even with the advent of all-sky optical time-domain surveys. Here, we present a systematic sample of 12 spectroscopically confirmed Galactic novae detected in the first 17 months of Palomar Gattini-IR (PGIR), a wide-field near-infrared time-domain survey. Operating in the J band (≈1.2 μ m), which is significantly less affected by dust extinction compared to optical bands, the extinction distribution of the PGIR sample is highly skewed to a large extinction values (&gt;50% of events obscured by A V ≳ 5 mag). Using recent estimates for the distribution of Galactic mass and dust, we show that the extinction distribution of the PGIR sample is commensurate with dust models. The PGIR extinction distribution is inconsistent with that reported in previous optical searches (null-hypothesis probability &lt;0.01%), suggesting that a large population of highly obscured novae have been systematically missed in previous optical searches. We perform the first quantitative simulation of a 3 π time-domain survey to estimate the Galactic nova rate using PGIR, and derive a rate of <mml:math xmlns:mml="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML" overflow="scroll"> <mml:mo>≈</mml:mo> <mml:msubsup> <mml:mrow> <mml:mn>43.7</mml:mn> </mml:mrow> <mml:mrow> <mml:mo>−</mml:mo> <mml:mn>8.7</mml:mn> </mml:mrow> <mml:mrow> <mml:mo>+</mml:mo> <mml:mn>19.5</mml:mn> </mml:mrow> </mml:msubsup> </mml:math> yr −1 . Our results suggest that all-sky near-infrared time-domain surveys are well poised to uncover the Galactic nova population.
BibTeX
@article{de2021population,
  author = {Kishalay De and M. M. Kasliwal and M. Hankins and J. L. Sokoloski and S. M. Adams and M. C. B. Ashley and A. Babul and Ashot Bagdasaryan and Alexandre Delacroix and Richard Dekany and Timothée Greffe and David Hale and J. Jencson and Viraj Karambelkar and Ryan M. Lau and A. Mahabal and D. McKenna and Anna Moore and E. O. Ofek and M. Sharma and Roger M. Smith and Jamie Soon and Roberto Soria and Gokul P. Srinivasaragavan and Samaporn Tinyanont and Tony Travouillon and Anastasios Tzanidakis and Yuhan Yao},
  title = {{A Population of Heavily Reddened, Optically Missed Novae from Palomar Gattini-IR: Constraints on the Galactic Nova Rate}},
  journal = {The Astrophysical Journal},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.3847/1538-4357/abeb75},
}
Figure