TL;DR
This pilot study explores using Heart Rate Variability (HRV) synchrony between surgeons as an objective marker for intraoperative teamwork. They found that increased HRV synchrony within surgical pairs is associated with shorter procedure times, suggesting it could be a valuable tool for assessing and improving surgical team performance.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Ensuring effective teamwork in the operating room is crucial for patient safety and surgical outcomes. However, objectively quantifying this teamwork has been challenging. While factors like team familiarity and non-technical skills are known to influence performance, there's a need for a more direct, physiological measure of how well a surgical team is "in sync." Previous research has shown that stress can negatively impact surgical performance, and HRV is known to reflect physiological stress responses. This paper aims to bridge this gap by investigating if the synchrony of surgeons' physiological responses (specifically HRV) can serve as an objective indicator of their collaborative effectiveness during surgery.
Methods
The researchers employed a cross-sectional study design, recruiting surgical teams (consultant and two registrars) from Ear, Nose, and Throat (ENT) and vascular surgery departments.
Key methodological aspects include:
- ECG Recording: Continuous electrocardiogram (ECG) data was collected from each team member using wearable devices for the entire duration of the surgical procedure.
- HRV Analysis: Heart Rate Variability (HRV) was extracted from the ECG data. The core of their analysis involved quantifying HRV synchrony, which measures the degree to which surgeons' HRV fluctuations track together. This was achieved using a sophisticated approach involving:
- Empirical Mode Decomposition (EMD): A data-driven method to decompose non-linear time series into intrinsic mode functions (IMFs).
- Noise-Assisted Multivariate EMD (NA-MEMD): A variant of EMD used to handle signal vibrations and link IMF channels.
- Intrinsic Phase Synchrony (IPS) and Nested Intrinsic Phase Synchrony (N-IPS): Frameworks to quantify the phase relationship and cooperation between physiological signals across multiple scales.
- Phase Synchrony Index (PSI): A metric derived from these analyses to quantify the level of synchrony.
- HRV Synchrony Metrics: Four specific metrics were derived from the PSI analysis to quantify different aspects of HRV synchrony:
- Number of HRV synchronies per hour (n-HRV-S)
- Number of HRV synchrony trends per hour (n-HRV-ST)
- Length of HRV synchrony trends per hour (L-HRV-ST)
- Area under the HRV synchrony trend curve per hour (area-HRV-ST)
- Data Collection: In addition to ECG, data on procedure length (LOP), intraoperative glitches, team familiarity (Familiarity Score), pre- and intraoperative stress levels (STAI questionnaire), non-technical skills (NOTECHS score), and team experience were collected.
- Statistical Analysis: Stepwise multiple linear regression was used to explore correlations between HRV synchrony metrics and other variables, including LOP.
Datasets
The study utilized data collected from 24 surgical pairs (12 ENT and 12 vascular) across 19 ENT and 16 vascular procedures. No pre-existing public datasets were used; the data was collected prospectively for this study.
Key Insights and Ideas
- HRV Synchrony as a Physiological Marker of Teamwork: The study successfully demonstrates that HRV synchrony can be quantified and potentially serves as an objective, physiological marker of how well surgical teams are collaborating.
- Synchrony Predicts Efficiency: The most striking finding is the inverse correlation between HRV synchrony and the length of the surgical procedure (LOP). This suggests that when surgeons are more physiologically synchronized, the surgery is completed more efficiently.
- L-HRV-ST as a Promising Metric: Among the four HRV synchrony metrics investigated, the "Length of HRV synchrony trends per hour" (L-HRV-ST) emerged as the most predictive metric for LOP.
- Stress and LOP Correlation: Higher intraoperative stress levels (as measured by the STAI questionnaire for the whole team) were positively correlated with longer procedure times, reinforcing the known impact of stress on performance.
- Team Familiarity Not Directly Correlated: Interestingly, despite previous findings, team familiarity did not show a significant direct correlation with LOP in this study, suggesting that HRV synchrony might capture a more immediate aspect of real-time collaboration.
- Non-Technical Skills and Experience Not Directly Correlated: Similar to familiarity, NOTECHS scores and collective team experience did not show a significant correlation with LOP, highlighting the potential unique contribution of physiological synchrony.
Key Results
- Inverse Correlation with LOP: All four HRV synchrony metrics (n-HRV-S, n-HRV-ST, L-HRV-ST, area-HRV-ST) were inversely correlated with the length of the procedure (LOP) at statistically significant levels (p < 0.0001 to p = 0.002).
- L-HRV-ST as Most Predictive: The L-HRV-ST metric showed the strongest inverse correlation with LOP (R = -0.574, p = 0.002).
- Positive Correlation with Stress and Familiarity: LOP was positively correlated with intraoperative STAI scores (p = 0.007, R = 0.493) and Familiarity Score (p = 0.043, R = 0.358).
- Feasibility: The ECG recording and HRV analysis methodology were found to be feasible and well-tolerated by the surgical teams.
Limitations and Future Work
- Sample Size and Heterogeneity: The authors acknowledge that the study's main limitations are the small sample size and the heterogeneity of the surgical procedures, particularly within the vascular teams. This may have impacted the ability to detect correlations for some variables (e.g., NOTECHS, team experience).
- Focus on Sub-team: The analysis focused on surgical pairs, not the entire surgical team, which might miss broader team dynamics.
- ECG Device Susceptibility: The ECG recording device was susceptible to failure due to movement and electrode detachment, which could lead to data corruption.
- Future Directions:
- Larger, Multi-center Studies: The authors suggest that future work should involve larger, multi-center studies to confirm these findings and explore the associations further.
- Simulated Environments: Controlling for factors like team familiarity in simulated environments could help clarify their role.
- "In-ear" Recordings: Investigating the use of "in-ear" recordings could mitigate issues with electrode detachment.
- Objective Teamwork Assessment: The ultimate goal is to use these objective HRV-based synchrony metrics for formative assessment, identifying high-functioning and potentially weaker teams to develop targeted training strategies.
Summary updated