A physics and data co-driven surrogate modeling approach for temperature field prediction on irregular geometric domain

Kairui Bao, Wen Yao, Xiaoya Zhang, Wei Peng, Yu LiStructural 2022 · DOI · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel approach to predict temperature fields on complex, irregular shapes by combining physics-based simulations with deep learning. Their method effectively bridges the gap between traditional, computationally expensive simulations and the need for fast, accurate predictions in engineering design, particularly for aircraft thermal analysis.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Optimizing aircraft designs often involves extensive thermal analysis, which is computationally demanding, especially when dealing with irregular geometric domains. Traditional numerical methods like finite element analysis require generating detailed meshes, a process that is both time-consuming and complex for non-standard shapes. While deep learning has shown promise in surrogate modeling, existing Convolutional Neural Networks (CNNs) struggle with irregular geometries because they are primarily designed for regular image-like data. This paper tackles the challenge of creating an efficient and accurate surrogate model for temperature field prediction on these irregular domains.

Methods

The authors propose a two-stage, physics and data co-driven surrogate modeling framework:

  • Body-fitted Coordinate Mapping: To handle irregular geometries, they first parameterize the irregular boundary using Bezier curves. Then, a body-fitted coordinate mapping technique is employed to transform the irregular physical plane into a regular computational plane. This allows standard image-based deep learning models to be applied.
  • Physics-Driven Meshing Surrogate: To generate structured meshes on the regular computational plane, they develop a physics-informed CNN. This surrogate uses the residuals of a nonlinear elliptic equation (related to coordinate mapping) as its loss function, enabling it to learn mesh generation with minimal labeled data.
  • Multi-level Data-Driven Thermal Surrogate: For predicting the temperature field on the regular computational plane, they use a data-driven approach based on a multi-level reduced-order model (specifically, Proper Orthogonal Decomposition - POD). This method learns the mapping from geometric parameters to POD coefficients, which are then used to reconstruct the temperature field. This approach is designed to improve accuracy and reduce reliance on large datasets.
  • Combined Model: Finally, the outputs from the meshing surrogate (grid positions) and the thermal surrogate (temperature field on the regular plane) are combined to reconstruct the irregular temperature field.

Datasets

The paper does not explicitly mention a specific named dataset for training or evaluation. Instead, it describes a process for generating datasets:

  • Generated Data: The authors generate datasets of irregular geometries using Latin Hypercube sampling. For the meshing surrogate, they mention using boundary values as input. For the thermal surrogate, geometric parameters are used as input, and temperature fields are generated using a finite difference method.
  • Data Split: For experiments, 70% of the generated samples are used for training, and the remaining 30% for testing.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Bridging Geometry and Physics: The core innovation lies in effectively combining geometric parameterization and physics-informed learning to handle irregular domains, a significant challenge for standard CNNs.
  • Physics-Informed Meshing: Using PDE residuals as a loss function for mesh generation is a powerful way to ensure physically plausible and high-quality meshes, even with limited training data.
  • Multi-level POD for Efficiency: Employing a multi-level POD approach for the thermal surrogate significantly reduces the dimensionality of the problem, leading to faster training and prediction while maintaining accuracy, especially with smaller datasets.
  • Generalization Beyond Training Data: The physics-driven meshing surrogate demonstrates strong generalization capabilities, performing well even on geometric parameters outside the training set range.

Key Results

  • Meshing Surrogate Performance: The physics-driven meshing surrogate (U-net) achieved high prediction accuracy with a Mean Absolute Error (MAE) of 0.023K and Mean Relative Errors (MREx, MREy) of 0.11% and 0.25% respectively. It generated high-quality meshes comparable to numerical methods.
  • Thermal Surrogate Performance: The multi-level data-driven thermal surrogate achieved an MAE of 0.0122K and an MRE of 0.0299% on the test set.
  • Dataset Size Impact: The model's prediction accuracy showed little change with dataset sizes greater than 1000 samples, indicating its effectiveness with smaller datasets.
  • Computational Efficiency: The multi-level model trains in approximately 2 minutes, significantly faster than U-net or FNO models which take around 20 minutes, while achieving higher predictive accuracy.
  • Comparison with CNNs: The proposed model outperformed single-level models and showed comparable or better accuracy than U-net and FNO models, especially in regions near boundaries.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations:
    • The paper focuses on 2D steady-state temperature fields.
  • While the meshing surrogate shows good generalization, the thermal surrogate's performance on parameters far outside the training range is not extensively detailed.
  • Future Work:
    • Extending the model to handle more complex boundary conditions.
  • Applying the framework to more intricate problems and potentially three-dimensional temperature field prediction.
  • Exploring the use of deep learning models for more complex mesh types.

Summary updated

Abstract

In the whole aircraft structural optimization loop, thermal analysis plays a very important role. But it faces a severe computational burden when directly applying traditional numerical analysis tools, especially when each optimization involves repetitive parameter modification and thermal analysis followed. Recently, with the fast development of deep learning, several Convolutional Neural Network (CNN) surrogate models have been introduced to overcome this obstacle. However, for temperature field prediction on irregular geometric domains (TFP-IGD), CNN can hardly be competent since most of them stem from processing for regular images. To alleviate this difficulty, we propose a novel physics and data co-driven surrogate modeling method. First, after adapting the Bezier curve in geometric parameterization, a body-fitted coordinate mapping is introduced to generate coordinate transforms between the irregular physical plane and regular computational plane. Second, a physics-driven CNN surrogate with partial differential equation (PDE) residuals as a loss function is utilized for fast meshing (meshing surrogate); then, we present a data-driven surrogate model based on the multi-level reduced-order method, aiming to learn solutions of temperature field in the above regular computational plane (thermal surrogate). Finally, combining the grid position information provided by the meshing surrogate with the scalar temperature field information provided by the thermal surrogate (combined model), we reach an end-to-end surrogate model from geometric parameters to temperature field prediction on an irregular geometric domain. Numerical results demonstrate that our method can significantly improve accuracy prediction on a smaller dataset while reducing the training time when compared with other CNN methods.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{bao2022physics,
  author = {Kairui Bao and Wen Yao and Xiaoya Zhang and Wei Peng and Yu Li},
  title = {{A physics and data co-driven surrogate modeling approach for temperature field prediction on irregular geometric domain}},
  booktitle = {Structural},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1007/s00158-022-03383-x},
}
Figure