A physical perspective to understand myelin II: The physical origin of myelin development

Yonghong Liu, Wenji Yue, Shoujun Yu, Tian Zhou, Yapeng Zhang, Ran Zhu, Bing Song, Tianruo Guo, Fenglin Liu, Yubin Huang, Tianzhun Wu, Hao WangFrontiers in Neuroscience 2022 · DOI

Abstract

The physical principle of myelin development is obtained from our previous study by explaining Peter's quadrant mystery: an externally applied negative and positive E-field can promote and inhibit the growth of the inner tongue of the myelin sheath, respectively. In this study, this principle is considered as a fundamental hypothesis, named Hypothesis-E, to explain more phenomena about myelin development systematically. Specifically, the g-ratio and the fate of the Schwann cell's differentiation are explained in terms of the E-field. Moreover, an experiment is proposed to validate this theory.

Introduction

Myelin, the insulating layer surrounding axons, is fundamental to the rapid transmission of electrical signals in the nervous system. While the molecular signaling pathways involved in myelination are well-documented, the physical principles governing its precise structural development—such as the consistent ratio of axon diameter to total fiber diameter (the g-ratio) and the selective myelination of large axons (radial sorting)—have remained elusive.

This paper proposes Hypothesis-E, a unified physical theory suggesting that electric fields (E-fields) are the primary drivers of myelin development. By treating the developing nerve as a dynamic electrical system, the authors bridge the gap between neural electrical activity and structural growth.

Hypothesis-E provides a framework for understanding myelin morphology, including the g-ratio and radial sorting mechanisms.

Theoretical Framework and Methodology

Hypothesis-E posits that a negative E-field promotes the growth of the "inner tongue" (the leading edge of the myelin sheath), while a positive E-field inhibits it. To explore this, the authors utilized several modeling techniques:

  1. Equivalent Circuit Modeling: The myelin sheath is represented as a series of capacitors. The voltage on the innermost layer is calculated by treating the axon’s resting potential ($V_R$) or action potential ($V_A$) as the primary voltage source.
  2. Dipole Potential Calculation: The axon membrane is modeled as a lipid bilayer composed of electric dipoles. The authors calculated how membrane curvature affects the dipole potential ($V_{ED}$), providing a physical basis for why axon size dictates myelination.
  3. Simulink Simulations: For non-compact myelin, MATLAB/Simulink circuit networks were used to incorporate resistors representing the conductive cytoplasmic fluid within the sheath.

Key Insights: The Physics of Growth

Myelin Growth as Electrical Feedback

The model demonstrates that myelin growth is a self-limiting process. As layers are added, the total capacitance of the sheath changes, causing the E-field at the inner tongue to decay. Growth ceases when the field reaches a specific threshold, naturally resulting in the mathematically predictable g-ratio observed across species.

Curvature and Radial Sorting

The dipole potential generated by the axon membrane is highly sensitive to curvature. In large axons, this potential is sufficient to promote Schwann cell adhesion and subsequent growth. Conversely, in small axons with high curvature, the potential drops significantly, physically preventing the initiation of myelination and leading to the formation of unmyelinated Remak bundles.

The Inhibitory Role of Action Potentials

A counterintuitive finding of the model is that frequent action potentials—which generate positive E-fields relative to the inner tongue—act as a "brake" on myelin thickening. This explains why sensory fibers, which typically fire more frequently, often possess thinner myelin than motor fibers.

The model explains how E-field phases (promoting vs. inhibitory) regulate the thickness and development of the myelin sheath.

Results and Validation

The derived g-ratio curves align closely with the "lower edge" of experimental data aggregated from over 15 studies spanning several decades. By incorporating the dipole potential, the authors resolved a mathematical flaw in previous models where small axons appeared to have infinitely thick myelin; the revised model correctly shows myelination dropping to zero below a specific axonal diameter threshold.

Furthermore, the theory is consistent with biological experiments where silencing action potentials leads to hypermyelination, supporting the hypothesis that electrical activity regulates growth through inhibitory E-fields.

Conclusion and Future Directions

While the current model is qualitative, it provides a robust physical foundation for understanding neural development. The authors propose a future "nanowire experiment" using silver nanowires coated in parylene to precisely control E-fields and observe glial cell responses. Integrating these physical E-field effects with known molecular signaling pathways will be essential for a comprehensive theory of myelination.

Summary updated

Abstract

The physical principle of myelin development is obtained from our previous study by explaining Peter's quadrant mystery: an externally applied negative and positive E-field can promote and inhibit the growth of the inner tongue of the myelin sheath, respectively. In this study, this principle is considered as a fundamental hypothesis, named Hypothesis-E, to explain more phenomena about myelin development systematically. Specifically, the g-ratio and the fate of the Schwann cell's differentiation are explained in terms of the E-field. Moreover, an experiment is proposed to validate this theory.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{liu2022physical,
  author = {Yonghong Liu and Wenji Yue and Shoujun Yu and Tian Zhou and Yapeng Zhang and Ran Zhu and Bing Song and Tianruo Guo and Fenglin Liu and Yubin Huang and Tianzhun Wu and Hao Wang},
  title = {{A physical perspective to understand myelin II: The physical origin of myelin development}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Neuroscience},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3389/fnins.2022.951998},
}
Figure